What's new

Why China isn’t ready to invade Taiwan – yet

Joined
Oct 15, 2017
Messages
28,401
Reaction score
-82
Country
Canada
Location
Canada
President Xi Jinping wants to restore China to its former glory – and that means bringing Taiwan under the Communist Party’s control, one way or another.

That was the gist of Xi’s direction-setting New Year’s speech on Jan. 2, when he addressed a packed house at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing. Xi’s speech marked 40 years since China stopped regular artillery bombardment of Taiwan-controlled islands off the Chinese coast. While he spoke at length about peace, he also made it clear that he’s running out of patience for polite politics.

“We are willing to create a vast space for peaceful unification, but we will never leave any room for any sort of Taiwan independence or separatist activities,” Xi said from his seat at the front of the auditorium. He then directly addressed the scope of action China may use to enforce this: “We do not promise to renounce the use of force and reserve the option to use all necessary measures.”

Xi’s comments sparked a rebuke from Taiwan’s president, Tsai Ing-wen. “China must face the fact of the existence of Taiwan, and not deny the system of a democratic county that has been commonly built up by the Taiwanese people,” she said in a speech the next day.

Tsai’s pro-independence party, the Democratic Progressive Party, replaced the China-friendly Kuomintang party in 2016, making it less likely than ever that Taipei will accept a peaceful “reunification” with the Communist-governed mainland. If anything, the back-and-forth might cement the two sides in opposition to one another.

Xi’s comments are raising fears of a military conflict between the two sides, even if it’s not China’s preferred option. Taiwan announced a new round of military drills aimed at fending off invasion after Xi’s remarks, and President Tsai has asked international leaders to pledge their help in the event of a crisis.

Despite the escalating rhetoric, experts tell Global News an imminent military conflict is unlikely.

While Ian Easton, a research fellow at the Project 2049 Institute, says “this is a very dangerous flashpoint,” he points out that China would fail if it tried to invade Taiwan in 2019. However, China’s chances for victory will be much greater in five-to-10 years, once it’s finished building up its military.


“The farther forward you project, the more likely it becomes that there will be a military crisis in the Taiwan Strait,” said Easton, author of the book The Chinese Invasion Threat: Taiwan’s Defense and American Strategy in Asia. “They’re building up all the capabilities that they would need to launch a potential invasion of Taiwan at some point in the next decade.”

Here’s why China is so focused on controlling Taiwan, and why it probably can’t take over the island by force – at least for now.

The enemy next door
China has long viewed Taiwan as a rogue province run by nationalists who never accepted losing the Chinese Civil War in 1949, when Mao Zedong’s Communists rose to power. Taiwan views itself as a free and democratic country that stands apart from the controlling Communist Party. However, it can’t officially declare it’s full independence from China, lest it face some form of attack.

Many western nations treated Taiwan as the “true” China until 40 years ago, when the Communist government in Beijing started reaching out to the world. That same year, in 1979, the U.S. shifted diplomatic relations to Beijing while promising to continue selling weapons to Taiwan for its defence.

President Xi’s speech on Jan. 2 marked that anniversary.

Taiwan – which officially calls itself the Republic of China – occupies a large island separated from mainland China by the Taiwan Strait, a 160-kilometre-wide stretch of water off China’s east coast. The self-governed island of approximately 23.6 million people has strong economy with a gross domestic product of approximately US$572 billion. It’s a booming hub for technology, shipping and banking, and it occupies a key strategic position between China and the Pacific Ocean.

more at https://globalnews.ca/news/4837941/china-taiwan-invasion-attack/
 
.
"While Ian Easton, a research fellow at the Project 2049 Institute, says “this is a very dangerous flashpoint,” he points out that China would fail if it tried to invade Taiwan in 2019. However, China’s chances for victory will be much greater in five-to-10 years, once it’s finished building up its military."

The great unknown is if the USN gets involved then China would fail 5/10 years down the line as well.
Also are we taking into account that as the Chinese threat gets greater, Taiwan will increase defence spending substantially as well? It is currently around 2% of GDP and could easily rise to 3-4% range.

For sure by mid-2030s onward, even with the help of the USN, China will probably be able to invade Taiwan but the cost may be unacceptably high for even the CPC.
 
.
"While Ian Easton, a research fellow at the Project 2049 Institute, says “this is a very dangerous flashpoint,” he points out that China would fail if it tried to invade Taiwan in 2019. However, China’s chances for victory will be much greater in five-to-10 years, once it’s finished building up its military."

The great unknown is if the USN gets involved then China would fail 5/10 years down the line as well.
Also are we taking into account that as the Chinese threat gets greater, Taiwan will increase defence spending substantially as well? It is currently around 2% of GDP and could easily rise to 3-4% range.

For sure by mid-2030s onward, even with the help of the USN, China will probably be able to invade Taiwan but the cost may be unacceptably high for even the CPC.

Depends how fast America declines. China will attack as soon as they can.

For sure by mid-2030s onward, even with the help of the USN, China will probably be able to invade Taiwan but the cost may be unacceptably high for even the CPC.

China can devastate Taiwan without sacrificing 1 man. All those power plants are sitting targets.
 
.
China can devastate Taiwan without sacrificing 1 man. All those power plants are sitting targets.

Taiwan currently has 240 HF-2E cruise missiles that can strike up to 600km away.

There is a new missile called Yun Feng in development that may be able to strike 2000kms away - enough to hit Beijing.
 
.
Taiwan currently has 240 HF-2E cruise missiles that can strike up to 600km away.

There is a new missile called Yun Feng in development that may be able to strike 2000kms away - enough to hit Beijing.

True. Taiwan's missiles can hit a few targets and kill a dozen or so Chinese soldiers. But China will still overwhelm Taiwan. J-20 easily takes air superiority. H-20 devastate power plants. More than 90% of Taiwan's missiles would be intercepted and destroyed. KJ-2000 and J-20 and HQ-9B and Type 055 combo is pretty formidable.

Taiwan currently has 240 HF-2E cruise missiles that can strike up to 600km away.

There is a new missile called Yun Feng in development that may be able to strike 2000kms away - enough to hit Beijing.

A few missiles strikes on Beijing won't do much damage. For 1 missile Taiwan can shoot, China can shoot 100.
 
.
.

@waz

Does this qualify as racism?

One of the screwball reasons is because Chinese people have an innate fear of water. The majority can't swim and certainly have no interest in learning. That little water barrier between China and Taiwan is one of the biggest obstacles.

So what? China has airborne. If they don't want to use ships. No big deal.

 
.
Taiwan currently has 240 HF-2E cruise missiles that can strike up to 600km away.

There is a new missile called Yun Feng in development that may be able to strike 2000kms away - enough to hit Beijing.

China faces a massive problem as the US militarys anti-ship capabilities are growing rapidly. Just 4 B-1 bombers are capable of launching nearly 100 LRASM missiles. US submarines will be lying in wait armed with upgraded torpedos and antiship missiles. US destroyers are armed with the SM-6 and soon 1,000 mile antiship Tomahawk. The US Army and Marines are rapidly moving out on shore based antiship missiles.

Many Chinese are going to die in the Taiwan Strait and thats before whatever is left hits the heavily defended beaches. China is making a huge mistake if they try to invade Taiwan.
 
.
China faces a massive problem as the US militarys anti-ship capabilities are growing rapidly. Just 4 B-1 bombers are capable of launching nearly 100 LRASM missiles. US submarines will be lying in wait armed with upgraded torpedos and antiship missiles. US destroyers are armed with the SM-6 and soon 1,000 mile antiship Tomahawk. The US Army and Marines are rapidly moving out on shore based antiship missiles.

Many Chinese are going to die in the Taiwan Strait and thats before whatever is left hits the heavily defended beaches. China is making a huge mistake if they try to invade Taiwan.

America would not fight China if China surrounds and invades Taiwan. Trump's approval is at a historic low. He ain't winning 2020 election as it is, let alone getting America into war with China.

Many Chinese are going to die in the Taiwan Strait and thats before whatever is left hits the heavily defended beaches. China is making a huge mistake if they try to invade Taiwan.

Bomb the power plants and Taiwan will capitulate within a week.

China faces a massive problem as the US militarys anti-ship capabilities are growing rapidly. Just 4 B-1 bombers are capable of launching nearly 100 LRASM missiles. US submarines will be lying in wait armed with upgraded torpedos and antiship missiles. US destroyers are armed with the SM-6 and soon 1,000 mile antiship Tomahawk. The US Army and Marines are rapidly moving out on shore based antiship missiles.

Many Chinese are going to die in the Taiwan Strait and thats before whatever is left hits the heavily defended beaches. China is making a huge mistake if they try to invade Taiwan.

Also, America didn't get into war with Russia when Russia took back Crimea, so what makes you think America would get into war with China if China takes back Taiwan? America does not even recognize Taiwan diplomatically.
 
.
Does this qualify as racism?

Watch the video. While you and I grew up with access to swimming pools in private residences, public pools, high school pools, and college pools it was only recently that these became available to the average Chinese citizen. So of course the majority do not know how to swim since they simply didn't have the opportunity to learn. Just like how somebody in Bermuda probably doesn't know how to build a snow fort.
 
Last edited:
.
Watch the video. While you and I grew up with access to swimming pools in private residences, public pools, high school pools, and college pools it was only recently that these became available to the average Chinese citizen. So of course the majority do not know how to swim since they simply didn't have the opportunity to learn. Just like how somebody in Bermuda probably doesn't know how to build a snow fort.

I suggest you take a trip to China and see for yourself.
 
.
One of the screwball reasons is because Chinese people have an innate fear of water. The majority can't swim and certainly have no interest in learning. That little water barrier between China and Taiwan is one of the biggest obstacles.
Chinese cannot even afford to eat tea eggs, how can they swim?:woot::woot:
505CF815-A52F-4DEC-813F-CB51780BEB0A.jpeg

You make my abs hurt...:rofl:
 
. . . .

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom