Who is Subhas Chandra Bose to people today?

[Suriya]

Historical Speech of Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose [Historical Speeches TV]​

Historical Speech of Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose [Historical Speeches TV]​

Subhas Chandra Bose - International Documentary​

 

[SaadH]

Happened because we started speaking Thier language, Hindustani instead of making our own language Sindhi, Pashto national language or going to pre British era with Farsi
Now what else would they consider Pakistan but to be just another Outpost of gangaland?

Our fault more than thiers

Agha Khan had the right idea, advised Quad-e-Azam to make Arabi our national language.

If that was the case, we'd have long established a clean break and gotten rid of this baggage in the process.

 

[Maula Jatt]

Agha Khan had the right idea, advised Quad-e-Azam to make Arabi our national language.

If that was the case, we'd have long established a clean break and gotten rid of this baggage in the process.

My first choice would have been either sandhi or Pashto because they are native but if it had to foreign than Dari
We f-ed up big time with Urdu now you'll be nothing but just a Muslim outpost of ganga
don't know how we can change it now...

 

[Suriya]

Marching Song of Indian National Army:

Qadam Qadam Badhaye Ja​

Qadam Qadam Badhaye Ja - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

 

[untitled]

I thought he made high end speakers

Better history through revisionism

 

[SIPRA]

Hardly related to the cause of Muslims and Pakistan.

 

[Suriya]

Hardly related to the cause of Pakista

 

[SIPRA]

View attachment 811220

At that time (1938), he was the President of the Indian National Congress; so must have been welcomed by INC workers and supporters, in Lahore. Nothing to do with Muslims and Pakistan.

And, at that time, Hindus and Sikhs formed majority in Lahore city.

 

[Musalman]

We got separated from India because we had differences with the some of the Hindu leaders of Hindustan. However, that does not mean all Hindus are bad or all Muslims who sided with Congress were bad. Mr. Bose was the only "naar" leader in the freedom struggle of United India. He was secular and many Muslim fought under him. He sided with Germany and Japanese just like the Bosnian Muslims or the Palestinian Muslim (including Imam Masjid Aqsa) sided with Germany for the independence of their country.

We all need to recognize the fact that there are two different things, Independence and creation of Pakistan. Jinnah, Nehru, Ghandi etc. etc. were all our heros when it comes to independence. However, regarding creation of Pakistan, Jinnah is the hero. Bose was our hero too because he is only related with Independence, so is Bhagat Singh etc.

My request to all, please disagree with each other, do not "hate". If you start hating you and people demolishing Babri Masjid will be no different.

 

[MH.Yang]

He is a member of the fascist group.

 

[Suriya]

He is a member of the fascist group.

LOL! he was a leftist leader. Before joining hands with German or then Japan, the first went to Russia and sought assistance of Stalin.

 

[MH.Yang]

LOL! he was a leftist leader. Before joining hands with German or then Japan, the first went to Russia and sought assistance of Stalin.

But it is true that he joined the fascist group, he is fascist.
Gandhi, Jinnah and Nehru are the leaders of the independence movement in South Asia, bose is not.

 

[-blitzkrieg-]

This Pakistani loves this man. He was the only freedom fighter for this region.

Jamal ud din Afghani
Syed Ahmed Barelvi
Fazl e Haq
Ubaidullah Sindhi
Hasrat Mohani
and many others

 

[Adonis]

Are you an idiot
How is he from this region?

Would Ranjeet Singh, faqeer if ipi, Bulleh Shah, sachal sarmast be considered part of "this" region in Tamil, Bangal or Hindustan?

Guess you should check if you are not an idiot...as you said.

Topic is he fought for independence against Britishers.....so per you only people from region have the right to do so.....if you count (off course you have to read the true history not your text books)...most number of freedom fighters are from Bengal...since 1880....you want to challenge?.....

 

[Adonis]

But it is true that he joined the fascist group, he is fascist.
Gandhi, Jinnah and Nehru are the leaders of the independence movement in South Asia, bose is not.

With due respect, Jinnah never opposed Britishers out of the way...and never went to jail...leave aside sacrifice......Gandhi on other hand opposed Britishers and went to jail several times...but again remaining within boundaries of not getting against the law ...so none of them did anything which could defame them.....in the eyes of Britishers.

My Great grand father (paternal), who was cousin of General Shahnawaz Khan of INA (Indian National Army), was killed in Burma. He through letter (while he was POW in Singapore) to my great grand father (letter is still with cousins in Karachi), that despite multiple requests from Bose / INA, to support, both Jinnah and Gandhi ignored and they said , they don't want to jeopardise their movement by supporting an outlaw movement.... both don't have the balls to call "a spade, a spade".

By the way Mate...by "Fascist", if you mean slayer of people.....what do you call Mao Tse Tung / Mao Zedong?...and Red revolution where millions were slaughtered??