When will the Muslims in India win their freedom?

[El Sidd]

Meanwhile Trump

 

[proudindian20]

Muslims of India are not stupid. They are not pseudo-Arabs like Pakistanis...they are Indians and will always be our brothers. Breaking of Pakistan in 1971 proved that ethnic identities are stronger than religion.

Peace!

 

[insight-out]

Jinnah won them freedom in 1947 - but they decided not to move to Pakistan.

Please do not presume. Not everyone could afford to leave their properties, livelihood, and extended family, and go to a new country with nothing to their name.

There is a reason why education among muhajirs was relatively high - the less educated ones simply could not come.

 

[El Sidd]

Jinnah won them freedom in 1947 - but they decided not to move to Pakistan.

maybe they did not want to live far away from great Saints buried in India. maybe they thought if they keep going to these Saints they will become PM of India and bring Change.

Please do not presume. Not everyone could afford to leave their properties, livelihood, and extended family, and go to a new country with nothing to their name.

There is a reason why education among muhajirs was relatively high - the less educated ones simply could not come.

bla bla bla

see above how one does it

 

[insight-out]

Muslims of India are not stupid. They are not pseudo-Arabs like Pakistanis...they are Indians and will always be our brothers. Breaking of Pakistan in 1971 proved that ethnic identities are stronger than religion.

Peace!

That is what you said before 1947.

 

[El Sidd]

Muslims of India are not stupid. They are not pseudo-Arabs like Pakistanis...they are Indians and will always be our brothers. Breaking of Pakistan in 1971 proved that ethnic identities are stronger than religion.

Peace!

Yes that is why by the end of Mahabhrata there will again be princely states based on ethnicity in what is today known as India.

 

[insight-out]

maybe they did not want to live far away from great Saints buried in India. maybe they thought if they keep going to these Saints they will become PM of India and bring Change.


bla bla bla

see above how one does it

Bla bla bla? That's your argument? You really are nothing but a troll.

 

[proudindian20]

1947 was perfect to remove pseudo-Arabs from our heartland. Only real Indians stayed behind. We Indians thank Jinnah for that.

 

[masterchief_mirza]

I don't think it's a relevant news that requires Reuters or APs attention, did you see news on curfews lifted in Lal chowk in AP or Reuters? Many Kashmir osint sources shared this info in twitter.

Lift the internet curfew so they can tell us themselves how they're doing. Your sources count for nothing if you're not letting them speak themselves. What horse crap in the modern world that an internet lockdown is in place for so long.

 

[El Sidd]

Bla bla bla? That's your argument? You really are nothing but a troll.

you need to understand the history of the poster. Mr. Signallian holds very strong beliefs that IK and Istanbul's ruler are PM/Leader of their respective countries because they visit Saints in their resting places. Mr. Signallian also indulge in deep sufi behavior as well but when it comes to voicing concern for Indian muslims, he simply turns a blind eye.

It is childish to assume that every single Muslim would have migrated in 1940s.

Why are Pakistanis blaming Indian muslims for something they did not do? I am pretty sure average age of Indian muslim is not 95.

There is an element of racism, sectarianism and economics with politics deeply involved. Blanket statements like the one Mr. Signallian has given are not to be taken seriously at all.

 

[masterchief_mirza]

1947 was perfect to remove pseudo-Arabs from our heartland. Only real Indians stayed behind. We Indians thank Jinnah for that.

You know the Indian Muslims who got shot in the head and back by armed UP police, are they your Non-arabised brothers too? If so, are you going to defend them?

 

[El Sidd]

1947 was perfect to remove pseudo-Arabs from our heartland. Only real Indians stayed behind. We Indians thank Jinnah for that.

which statistically mean over 900 million people are stateless in India as India welcomed 2020 today.

 

[proudindian20]

You know the Indian Muslims who got shot in the head and back by armed UP police, are they your Non-arabised brothers too? If so, are you going to defend them?

Have you ever been to UP state in India? Doesn't matter if you're muslim or not just go there and see the daily crime there. You'd be surprised. I'm not surprised Police acted in that manner. I'd even prefer them to shoot Hindu hooligans to keep the peace. That place is a crime hotbed.

which statistically mean over 900 million people are stateless in India as India welcomed 2020 today.

Lol any sources to back this up?

 

[Arsalan 345]

as a pakistani,i don't care about muslims in india.we urged them in 47 to migrate but they raised slogans in favor of india.i have zero sympathy for indians whether muslim indians or hindu indians.our focus should be on pakistan.we must get stronger and hit enemy where it hurts.obviously dividing india in independent states are now easy so we should support muslims of india but please don't give them respect equal to pakistani muslims.we migrated.we accepted pakistan as our home and we are all together and united.

india should better handle their own problems.it's now 70 years of independence and suddenly india realized that muslims are infiltrators.very sad that educated india is doing these type of things.it doesn't suit them.

 

[proudindian20]

as a pakistani,i don't care about muslims in india.we urged them in 47 to migrate but they raised slogans in favor of india.i have zero sympathy for indians whether muslim indians or hindu indians.our focus should be on pakistan.we must get stronger and hit enemy where it hurts.obviously dividing india in independent states are now easy so we should support muslims of india but please don't give them respect equal to pakistani muslims.we migrated.we accepted pakistan as our home and we are all together and united.

Danish Kaneria proved how united you are and how you treat your minorities...