Whatever

[war&peace]

What I feel is that management tries to maintain a balance.
BTW, there's sub-forum "forum rule book" so all members should read it.

1. We cannot open threads based on tweet only (though I have some objections on this rule but still I follow it)
2. We cannot open threads with a video only, except in the general multimedia section.
3. If you want to open threads with videos or tweet in normal sections, add a summary and context.

Rest of the rules are common sense. i.e. no trolling, no personal insults and language of the forum is English

 

[B.K.N]

They claim whole west of Indus if you must know.
You probably never have crossed the Indus to the western side i can assume given you only speak for ''apne zillay ke log''.

Not true they don't claim actually thousands of Iranian Baloch are living in Pakistan bla type groups aren't pro Iran and most of Baloch look very similar to Punjabis even looks wise they are not similar to Iranians there are some internet Aryans who would claim baloch look like pashtuns etc

They migrated from British India which constituted part of Pakistan under British Monarchy.

No one is sending them back aap ko fikar kyon horahi hai waisay it's my suggestion not government policy aap bhi to suggestion detay Hain interest rate kam karo

 

[El Sidd]

Not true they don't claim actually thousands of Iranian Baloch are living in Pakistan bla type groups aren't pro Iran and most of Baloch look very similar to Punjabis even looks wise they are not similar to Iranians there are some internet Aryans who would claim baloch look like pashtuns etc

Iranians claim the region as part of their old empire. There are multiple ethnicities in Iran and is not homogeneous contrary to your claims. Ask the Iranians who come to distribute and take money in Jhang. You will get to know this.

No one is sending them back aap ko fikar kyon horahi hai waisay it's my suggestion not government policy aap bhi to suggestion detay Hain interest rate kam karo

Well i am just advancing on your brilliant suggestions. I am not worried i do not have a problem with this. and frankly these native urdu speakers are used to it

 

[B.K.N]

Iranians claim the region as part of their old empire. There are multiple ethnicities in Iran and is not homogeneous contrary to your claims. Ask the Iranians who come to distribute and take money in Jhang. You will get to know this.

But like some people say like iranic language and iranic people etc that's not true they don't claim people of south western Pakistani province are ours etc like an other failed state in west

 

[El Sidd]

But like some people say like iranic language and iranic people etc that's not true they don't claim people of south western Pakistani province are ours etc like an other failed state in west

Why don't you engage those people along the same lines as you engage people who respect Urdu as National Language and not treat as National Security Threat?

I would like to see you explain this to someone from west of the indus and see how long you last with your arguments. Its easy to do that with native Urdu speakers since India is declared enemy of the State and Iran is declared Biraadar Islami Mulk who can send in drones to kill Pakistanis on will and pleasure.

 

[B.K.N]

Why don't you engage those people along the same lines as you engage people who respect Urdu as National Language and not treat as National Security Threat?

You mean people like Sindh darya etc there are two types of people at the western side of Sindh northerners are Desi Aryans but southern are not like that nationalist one southerners are more into haqoqs and I've seen a lot of them

 

[El Sidd]

You mean people like Sindh darya etc there are two types of people at the western side of Sindh northerners are Desi Aryans but southern are not like that nationalist one southerners are more into haqoqs and I've seen a lot of them

Is Sindhi spoken on both sides of the border or just in Pakistan?

 

[B.K.N]

Is Sindhi spoken on both sides of the border or just in Pakistan?

Yes it's spoken on both sides but other side is dessert so small population but not sure

 

[El Sidd]

Yes it's spoken on both sides but other side is dessert so small population but not sure

Watch this and come back to me again

 

[B.K.N]

Watch this and come back to me again

This documentary is about Thar dessert after watching the woman speak I think for me it wouldn't be difficult to learn sindhi

 

[El Sidd]

This documentary is about Thar dessert after watching the woman speak I think for me it wouldn't be difficult to learn sindhi

So why target Urdu only?

 

[B.K.N]

So why target Urdu only?

Who targeted urdu I just said Pakistan should replace Urdu with some other language to distance itself from India

 

[El Sidd]

Who targeted urdu I just said Pakistan should replace Urdu with some other language to distance itself from India

So you do believe it is a national security issue that Urdu is spoken in Pakistan? I can only wish you luck in your Persian endeavors.

 

[B.K.N]

So you do believe it is a national security issue that Urdu is spoken in Pakistan? I can only wish you luck in your Persian endeavors.

No no I am not saying this I said Pakistan should try to distance itself from India and I am not talking about Iran because Indian media films everything uses Urdu Pakistani media also uses same language and this needs to be changed

 

[El Sidd]

No no I am not saying this I said Pakistan should try to distance itself from India and I am not talking about Iran because Indian media films everything uses Urdu Pakistani media also uses same language and this needs to be changed

Why not Pashtu then? It is widely spoken and understood in Pakistan.