what role has india played in afghanistan?

[Flash_Ninja]

China is only talking but in reality they have invested very little


Lol.
Praveen Sawhney
A guy who never got promoted beyond Major in the army despite him being a permanently commissioned officer

The Taliban went to China several times, the Afghan govt now looks to China as a peacebroker, they do joint-patrols with Afghans, building a base, building freight networks, created the QCCM, and is negotiating to bring Afghanistan under the BRI.

Yeah theres very little investment here all just talk

 

[BHarwana]

China is only talking but in reality they have invested very little


Lol.
Praveen Sawhney
A guy who never got promoted beyond Major in the army despite him being a permanently commissioned officer

Meri Jan the only stake India has in Afghanistan is in TTP which are just few thugs in Afghanistan. India don't has the means and capabilities to have any influence of TTA which is a 1000 times more bigger organisation. TTA is the only force which made the most powerful country in the world not win a war for 20 years. This is now world's longest war in world history.

 

[313ghazi]

He is right that India has no influence on Taliban but India has got unmatched influence on Afghan government, which is why RAW's closest ally in Afghanistan Amrullah Saleh is now all set to be Afghanistan's Vice President.

Meanwhile Pakistan has influence in Taliban but no influence on Afghan govt.

The government is temporary, the Taliban is permanent. At some point, they'll also be government.

 

[Path-Finder]

He is right that India has no influence on Taliban but India has got unmatched influence on Afghan government, which is why RAW's closest ally in Afghanistan Amrullah Saleh is now all set to be Afghanistan's Vice President.

Meanwhile Pakistan has influence in Taliban but no influence on Afghan govt.

kabul gov is just that limited to kabul. lets not call it afghan gov because its cant even control over kabul.

 

[Shah_Deu]

Afghan government controls 50-55% of territory whereas Taliban has only 10-15%.

so why the whole world superpowers US, Russia, China are so eager to talk to them?

You know there is a reason Gangudesh is not in the talks, world doesnt take your policy towards afghanistan seriously. They needed your money, they have it and since you cant do much on ground, you are useless for them!

 

[maximuswarrior]

Afghan government controls 50-55% of territory whereas Taliban has only 10-15%.
Rest of the area is contested.

Thus Taliabn is far far weaker compared to Afghan government.

That is as usual wishful thinking on your part.

Afghan government will come and go. Taliban is here to stay.

Just call it a day now fool. You lost.

 

[Goenitz]

A guy who never got promoted beyond Major in the army despite

so maj guarav arya is ok/professor/analyst?
anyway with having views like him, no wonder he didn't get promotion.

 

[maximuswarrior]

so why the whole world superpowers US, Russia, China are so eager to talk to them?

You know there is a reason Gangudesh is not in the talks, world doesnt take your policy towards afghanistan seriously. They needed your money, they have it and since you cant do much on ground, you are useless for them!

Gangus also think 27th humiliation never happened.

 

[Goenitz]

We owe Ganguz a Debt of PakBlood!

when... we need to avenge APS, karma, Sri lankan tam attack, and much more. we cannot inflict them as much as they did.. whether n 71 or for past decades

 

[Vasher]

In the past, we can say it was a significant enough with TTP and Terrorism in Pakistan. But the US finally bringing the Taliban to table. India lost a lot of leverage in this game.

 

[R Wing]

He is right that India has no influence on Taliban but India has got unmatched influence on Afghan government, which is why RAW's closest ally in Afghanistan Amrullah Saleh is now all set to be Afghanistan's Vice President.

Meanwhile Pakistan has influence in Taliban but no influence on Afghan govt.

It seems Pakistan backed the horse that's going to win as the Afghan govt wouldn't last a week without NATO --- and the US wants to leave.

 

[Taimoor Khan]

Not going to happen.
While some infighting still remains, Afghan political structure is far more stable than before.
The new young interior minister for security is very capable to

He got batter and narrow escaped death just recently. Since then, he is shaken and haven't raised his ugly head. Says a lot!

 

[JohnWick]

So that Afghans can live in peace.

With whom?

 

[Reddington]

Anyone who forgets it has the blood of those PakChildren on his/her hands...
We owe Ganguz a Debt of PakBlood!

Indeed! We have yet to take revenge from Bharat for this terrorist attack.

The only revenge that should be acceptable is that in case of war with India, Modi's homestate of Gujrat must be carpet bombed by PAF. Not a single gangoo rat must be left alive. For every child that was Shaheed in APS terrorist attack, 1000 gangoos should be slaughtered.

 

[Areesh]

Lol.
Praveen Sawhney
A guy who never got promoted beyond Major in the army despite him being a permanently commissioned officer

Much better than arya poonya type rats