What if China and Vietnam went to war?

[Haroon Syed]

China won't be in a position to hold Vietnam. Remember American-Veitnam war, it will be same but China will be fighting Vietnam and other powers will be behind Vietnam. China cannot afford to go on war with Vietnam at this point of time at least.

 

[vayuputhra]

Why do you think Vietnam would need Indian advisers in a war with China?

There are things which India knows better, and with special advise many things comes attached, we know many things about China on which we would like to advise, who knows India may give some strategic assets to our friends, as you give to Pakistan, and america has a tactical understanding with India on vietnam

 

[Dungeness]

There are things which India knows better, and with special advise many things comes attached, we know many things about China on which we would like to advise, who knows India may give some strategic assets to our friends, as you give to Pakistan, and america has a tactical understanding with India on vietnam

Anything that India knows about China that Vietnam doesn't?

 

[JohnyD]

lets discuss this scenario when Viet already posses the Nukes...may be 10 yrs from now? !

 

[vayuputhra]

[QUOTE="Dungeness, post: 7819587, member: 172203"anything that India knows about China that Vietnam doesn't?[/QUOTE]
Many many things, as our resources are huge and, your CPC knows it, we are developing our navy and air force rapidly, we are giving special training to Vietnamese navy, ex: providing satellite imagery of chinas strategic assets, providing secure communication net work, launching their spy SAT, and giving early warning of Chinese missiles, giving information of Chinese navy, tactically blocking Malacca straights with American help, giving access to our spy satellites etc.

 

[Dungeness]

[QUOTE="Dungeness, post: 7819587, member: 172203"anything that India knows about China that Vietnam doesn't?

Many many things, as our resources are huge and, your CPC knows it, we are developing our navy and air force rapidly, we are giving special training to Vietnamese navy, ex: providing satellite imagery of chinas strategic assets, providing secure communication net work, launching their spy SAT, and giving early warning of Chinese missiles, giving information of Chinese navy, tactically blocking Malacca straights with American help, giving access to our spy satellites etc.[/QUOTE]


Good! Sounds like a superpower!

 

[vayuputhra]

Many many things, as our resources are huge and, your CPC knows it, we are developing our navy and air force rapidly, we are giving special training to Vietnamese navy, ex: providing satellite imagery of chinas strategic assets, providing secure communication net work, launching their spy SAT, and giving early warning of Chinese missiles, giving information of Chinese navy, tactically blocking Malacca straights with American help, giving access to our spy satellites etc.

Good! Sounds like a superpower! [/QUOTE]
There is no super power in this, these are the fields India has advantage of, and those who think other wise are living in wonderland, and don't you think giving Vietnam HD pics of your assets will help them?

 

[Dungeness]

Good! Sounds like a superpower!

There is no super power in this, these are the fields India has advantage of, and those who think other wise are living in wonderland, and don't you think giving Vietnam HD pics of your assets will help them?[/QUOTE]

Well, that ability is not really unique to India. What help India can give to Vietnam that other countries can't? In fact, Vietnamese a war records that they can be proud of. What they need is not advise from anyone, but equipment and financial support,

Good! Sounds like a superpower!

There is no super power in this, these are the fields India has advantage of, and those who think other wise are living in wonderland, and don't you think giving Vietnam HD pics of your assets will help them?[/QUOTE]

It is, but this ability is not really unique to India. Vietnamese are pretty good fighters themselves, they die but they don't flee, and they fought more wars with big powers than India. I don't really see India has much to offer to Vietnam in terms of advise, but they can use some of your BraMos and Su-30MKI.

 

[vayuputhra]

There is no super power in this, these are the fields India has advantage of, and those who think other wise are living in wonderland, and don't you think giving Vietnam HD pics of your assets will help them?

Well, that ability is not really unique to India. What help India can give to Vietnam that other countries can't? In fact, Vietnamese a war records that they can be proud of. What they need is not advise from anyone, but equipment and financial support,

There is no super power in this, these are the fields India has advantage of, and those who think other wise are living in wonderland, and don't you think giving Vietnam HD pics of your assets will help them?[/QUOTE]

It is, but this ability is not really unique to India. Vietnamese are pretty good fighters themselves, they die but they don't flee, and they fought more wars with big powers than India. I don't really see India has much to offer to Vietnam in terms of advise, but they can use some of your BraMos and Su-30MKI.[/QUOTE]
What about our nukes?

 

[Luca1]

Why do you think Vietnam would need Indian advisers in a war with China?

To advise on what not to do. Vietnam will do opposit of what the Indian says. Actually, Vietnamese chances are good if they go with that strategy.

Anything that India knows about China that Vietnam doesn't?

Indians brag more?

Well, that ability is not really unique to India. What help India can give to Vietnam that other countries can't? In fact, Vietnamese a war records that they can be proud of. What they need is not advise from anyone, but equipment and financial support,

There is no super power in this, these are the fields India has advantage of, and those who think other wise are living in wonderland, and don't you think giving Vietnam HD pics of your assets will help them?

It is, but this ability is not really unique to India. Vietnamese are pretty good fighters themselves, they die but they don't flee, and they fought more wars with big powers than India. I don't really see India has much to offer to Vietnam in terms of advise, but they can use some of your BraMos and Su-30MKI.

What about our nukes?[/QUOTE]

Giving away nukes is no joke. If India give away nukes. America will ensure that India has no more nukes.

 

[Nilgiri]

Giving away nukes is no joke. If India give away nukes. America will ensure that India has no more nukes.

So you are saying US has already taken away Pakistan nukes because of AQ Khan?

Has US taken away Chinese nukes because China gave assistance to Pakistan?

US was never a world policeman to countries that could punch it effectively in the nose.

 

[Luca1]

So you are saying US has already taken away Pakistan nukes because of AQ Khan?

Has US taken away Chinese nukes because China gave assistance to Pakistan?

US was never a world policeman to countries that could punch it effectively in the nose.

If India willingly transfer a bomb as a country, than it deserve to lose its bombs. No other nuclear powers would stand for that. And India is not even an official nuclear state.

 

[Misay]

这帖子并不好，楼主小学生？

 

[Azadkashmir]

china offer soft loan and hand out gifts like tvs, laptop etc, one of those third world motorbikes and Vietnam will be happy. war game over.

 

[vayuputhra]

To advise on what not to do. Vietnam will do opposit of what the Indian says. Actually, Vietnamese chances are good if they go with that strategy.



Indians brag more?


What about our nukes?

Giving away nukes is no joke. If India give away nukes. America will ensure that India has no more nukes.[/QUOTE]
They tried it hard so that we don't have nukes but in vain they cannot, do you think we will give it with all fan fare, could the america take away nukes of north Korea, if such a small country cannot be done anything, India is a sub continent, with 4th largest army and has all kinds of weapons even Americans were surprised when we made the bang.and as for Vietnam is concerned India and america has an understanding with each other if the Chinese attacks Vietnam, both the countries will do what ever they can do.