What's new

Welcome To India

Can anybody confirm whether all iplayer videos are not available outside uk? I have posted many of them here, but nobody pointed that out. I feel like stupid now. :)

It's not available outside of the UK.

However, the full episode can easily be downloaded from any file-sharing sites.

And that is what the BBC is all about too. They will always show India as poor, as full of slums etc., Granted that India is still 60% villages, they will hardly concentrate on India's scientific achievements. They will always downplay it. It has been one of the biggest criticisms of the BBC. They have this colonial hangover mindset :lol:

I saw a bit of the documentary.

It is definitely some kind of colonial mindset, it was as if they were deliberately looking for the worst things in India to show. Some parts were really awful, this is not something you should watch during dinner.
 
. .
It's not available outside of the UK.

However, the full episode can easily be downloaded from any file-sharing sites.


yes some of the images are as bad as this video fom your neighbourhood mr. cd
I saw a bit of the documentary.

It is definitely some kind of colonial mindset, it was as if they were deliberately looking for the worst things in India to show. Some parts were really awful, this is not something you should watch during dinner.

yes some of the images are as bad as this video fom your neighbourhood mr. cd


it literally made me puke, thouhg ive eaten an hour back or so.


part of regular chinese nutrition ???
 
Last edited by a moderator:
. .
I was supporting you by saying it was a biased documentary, dumb Indian. :rolleyes:

Thanks for 'support', but BBC generally is balanced in view, and I dont think it specifically wants to show India in bad light. There are many other BBC programs which shows other aspects of India. This one has a different theme.
 
.
Thanks for 'support', but BBC generally is balanced in view, and I dont think it specifically wants to show India in bad light. There are many other BBC programs which shows other aspects of India. This one has a different theme.

It is called "Welcome to India", which implies giving a general picture of India the country.

So your suggestion of it being a specific theme is nonsensical. The title implies a general picture of the country, yet it is focusing on all the worst parts including manual scavenging and the most deprived regions of the country.

I agree that the BBC is usually neutral, but this documentary is not.
 
. .
Criticism of the BBC - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Indophobia
In 2008, the BBC was criticised by some for referring to the men who carried out the November 2008 Mumbai attacks as "gunmen" rather than "terrorists".[97][98][99] This follows a steady stream of complaints from India that the BBC has an Indophobic bias that stems from a culturally ingrained racism against Indians arising from the British Raj.[citation needed] Rediff reporter Arindam Banerji has chronicled what he argues are numerous cases of Indophobic bias from the BBC regarding reportage, selection bias, misrepresentation, and fabrications.[citation needed]
In protest against the use of the word "gunmen" by the BBC, journalist Mobashar Jawed "M.J." Akbar refused to take part in an interview following the Mumbai terror attacks,[100] and criticized the BBC's reportage of the incident.[101] British parliamentarian Stephen Pound has supported these claims, referring to the BBC's whitewashing of the terror attacks as "the worst sort of mealy mouthed posturing. It is desperation to avoid causing offence which ultimately causes more offence to everyone."[102]
Writing for The Hindu Business Line, reporter Premen Addy criticises the BBC's reportage on South Asia as consistently anti-India and pro-Islamist,[103] and that they underreport India's economic and social achievements, as well as political and diplomatic efforts, and disproportionately highlight and exaggerate problems in the country. In addition, Addy alludes to discrimination against Indian anchors and reporters in favour of Pakistani and Bangladeshi ones who are hostile to India.
Writing for the 2008 edition of the peer-reviewed Historical Journal of Film, Radio and Television, Alasdair Pinkerton analyzes the coverage of India by the BBC since India's independence from British rule in 1947 until 2008. Pinkerton observes a tumultuous history involving allegations of anti-India bias in the BBC's reportage, particularly during the cold war, and concludes that the BBC's coverage of South Asian geopolitics and economics shows a pervasive and hostile anti-India bias due to the BBC's alleged imperialist and neo-colonialist stance.[104]
[edit]Anti Hindu bias
Hindu groups in the United Kingdom have accused the BBC of anti-Hindu bigotry and whitewashing Islamist hate groups that demonise the British Indian minority[105]
In 2005, the Vivekananda Centre London and the Hindu Council(UK) reported an institutional anti Hindu bias and stated that "Anything that may show Hinduism in a poor light is immediately picked up by the BBC programme makers, while anything that may show Hinduism in a glorious light remains ignored by the BBC."[106]
In March 2012, the BBC referred to the Hindu festival of Holi as "****** festival". The Webster new world dictionary defines "******" as "full of *****, disgustingly foul; grossly obscene; morally vicious or corrupt". The BBC has since apologized for the offense caused.

------------------------------

Haven't seen the documentary but i don't expect any better from BBC .
 
.
Whatever that help leftists sleep well at night.
 
.
Some of you are commenting on the subject without having the benefit of viewing it, Welcome to is a serial of documentaries which in the past have covered other countries also. As for India, it shows resilience of common man in his daily survival chores, it portrays the term, need is the mother of creation. If the BBC telecast lifestyles of say Ambanis, it may make the Indians look and feel good but is that the common theme for individuals on street life. !!
 
.
Some of you are commenting on the subject without having the benefit of viewing it, Welcome to is a serial of documentaries which in the past have covered other countries also. As for India, it shows resilience of common man in his daily survival chores, it portrays the term, need is the mother of creation. If the BBC telecast lifestyles of say Ambanis, it may make the Indians look and feel good but is that the common theme for individuals on street life. !!

We care about how the country is portrayed outside India. We should learn from China in that respect. Its not about feeling good or whatever.

As for the reality check, we dont need white folks to tell us about it :lol: We BELONG here. And we already know.
 
.
:lol: You see dirt and I see gold

Do you proud of the showing things?
About that boy's story, he lives in dust and dirt, he digs in canals to collect dirty mud seeking the gold, wishing to become a master of that business someday, but again BBC shows the gold making owner who lives with dirt most of the day even he has money.
 
.
Some of you are commenting on the subject without having the benefit of viewing it, Welcome to is a serial of documentaries which in the past have covered other countries also. As for India, it shows resilience of common man in his daily survival chores, it portrays the term, need is the mother of creation. If the BBC telecast lifestyles of say Ambanis, it may make the Indians look and feel good but is that the common theme for individuals on street life. !!

Changing tracks!!!!! This coming from you would indeed be considered as blasphemy by your fans, Mr. Jammer. Anyway, glad to know that you are willing to see things in the right perspective.
 
.
Do you proud of the showing things?
About that boy's story, he lives in dust and dirt, he digs in canals to collect dirty mud seeking the gold, wishing to become a master of that business someday, but again BBC shows the gold making owner who lives with dirt most of the day even he has money.

Yes, I am very proud of it.

The world knows about Tatas, Amabanis and Birlas and how they are making Indian Inc a force to reckon with

The world knows how enterprising middle class Indians are: from starting businesses to making their marks everywhere across the world.

This document shows how enterprising Indian poor can be. The world is not for people who sit and comment, but for people who can dig gold from the dirt. It shows how resilient Indians can be. Enterprising is in Indians' DNA
 
.
Yes, I am very proud of it.

The world knows about Tatas, Amabanis and Birlas and how they are making Indian Inc a force to reckon with

The world knows how enterprising middle class Indians are: from starting businesses to making their marks everywhere across the world.

This document shows how enterprising Indian poor can be. The world is not for people who sit and comment, but for people who can dig gold from the dirt. It shows how resilient Indians can be. Enterprising is in Indians' DNA

Cheers then for 'Welcome to India'!
 
.
Back
Top Bottom