UN Security Council (P5) Unspoken Superpower Requirements

[ChineseTiger1986]

This guy deserve a credit for the China seat.

We have secured our UNSC seat with this, not by begging.

 

[Jlaw]

The seat will come to you when you are poweful enough.

maybe, non voting. Or in an alternate universe.

 

[Magi Brahmin]

Haha, a crafted wishful post.
same for pakistan !
If this is your criteria then add the following in your list.. For India, they also hold true.

• All the countries who are super powers worship pedopiles - holds true for pak
• All super-powers are in one way or the other occupants of a territory - holds true for pak
• All super-powers had at-least one prime minster who used to **** hoes holds true for pak
• All super-powers have been beaten by at-least two neighbours - holds true for India
• All super-powers have inferiority complex - holds true for pak 100%.

4 and list goes on and on .

 

[Magi Brahmin]

The seat will come to you when you are poweful enough.

+1 I don't know why modi is begging for seat. he should try to make india more powerful first.

 

[TaiShang]

Yes UNSC must remain a elite institute except that there are 3 losers who were saved by USA and USSR sitting and doing nothing all these years.

France, perhaps, although they also paid dearly, and more importantly, they were on the winning camp. The rest did their part of fighting pretty well, although, I would say, US was the luckiest because they joined late but determined heavily the end of the war.

And their homeland remained unscathed.

 

[Economic superpower]

India has no business being in the UNSC let alone given veto power.

A country with no independent foreign policy has no business being in the UNSC.

 

[Mughal-Prince]

India suffers blow as US, Russia, China oppose UNSC reform talks | Asia Times

I don't believe it! Is this serious!
It's like something a benchmark to achieve which is rather ridiculous to me as I think it's more of an obligation then a privilege because great power comes with great responsibility. In recent past we have seen what Indians have done in their neighbouring countries and when it comes to super powers they didn't compliance with their need 100% although to some extent they stand with them but India as a country in nature don't bow to others unconditionally and try to keep their status neutral but not always and not everywhere.

As the face of world realities are about to change soon and a huge discomfort is about to arise from the Middle East and other places world need someone to do some jobs for them in this changing scenario and they think Pakistan fits in this frame perfectly so all the world powers despite of India (which is a huge huge economy) not taking a risk of losing Pakistan. But their is a big big problem which has been over seen by big powers as they are over confident due to their past experiences with Pakistan is that Pakistan is changing demographically it's now seems very difficult to bring in one man govt in Pakistan and in case of democratic govt it's a chaos if they did something against people's will so it's becoming a double edge sword.

So in current world scenario it's becoming very difficult for world powers to take steps although they still have privilege and they have the power to take these steps but even if they took it it would be with reluctance and not with firm belief as no one knows what may happen in post world.

 

[xunzi]

There was only 1 criteria to be a part of the P5, and that was to have been a "major independent power" on the allied side of WW2.

Though it is interesting to note that the P5 are also the only 5 recognized nuclear powers in the world by the NPT, and the only 5 nations with thermonuclear weapons and ICBMs.

The P5 are also currently recognized as the "Great powers" of the world, along with Germany and Japan.

Great power - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Dark blue = Great powers with UNSC permanent seats

Light blue = Great powers without UNSC permanent seats

And Germany is recognized in the P5+1.

The only Great power left out is Japan, likely because it still has active territorial disputes with 2 of the P5 members (China and Russia).

In the Great Power theory, India is more of a regional power than a great power and that's why it is hard to put them in the UNSC.

As far as great power today, it's P5 + 1 (Germany) exactly the one who negotiated the Iran nuclear deal.

 

[IR-TR]

My god this thread is sheer BS. Somebody made the requirements as to only fit the big 3. What kind of nonsense is that? By this logic the entire EU couldn't get a seat (not enough landmass). Try again.

 

[Luca1]

Ok, let him keep begging or as you say 'courting' publicly the big powers for a UNSC P5.seat then. We will see if his method is better than that of Germany and Japan.

Also it IS true that India got freedom through begging ........ call it whatever you want (Non co op etc etc) and that is exactly why it did not get it on its own terms.

The theme of this thread I'd about India begging. But the mods changed my post from using the word "begging" to "asking". Maybe I should ask the mods to change it back.

 

[rott]

Yes UNSC must remain a elite institute except that there are 3 losers who were saved by USA and USSR sitting and doing nothing all these years.

Your post simply shows your, "ignorance, arrogance, hateful and butthurt" attitude.

Last but not the least, "begging" attitude. Lol...

 

[Srinivas]

Your post simply shows your, "ignorance, arrogance, hateful and butthurt" attitude.

Last but not the least, "begging" attitude. Lol...

Asking for elite seat in UNSC is not begging, but comes under diplomacy. India is not desperate ..... kid.

Begging is some thing which is done when you are desperate and cannot sustain.

 

[rott]

Asking for elite seat in UNSC is not begging, but comes under diplomacy. India is not desperate ..... kid.

Begging is some thing which is done when you are desperate and cannot sustain.

True. You just answered your own question. You aren't begging but simply butthurt and it's on fire.

 

[Srinivas]

True. You just answered your own question. You aren't begging but simply butthurt and it's on fire.

For what??

India is rising and closing the gap with the leading countries.

 

[Rocky25]

The theme of this thread I'd about India begging. But the mods changed my post from using the word "begging" to "asking". Maybe I should ask the mods to change it back.

Retard minds cannot understand non-violent movements.... How on earth is Non-cooperation movement and Quit India movement was ever "begging"?

Indian independence movement - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Have you ever seen a movie Gandhi... You really feel the people are beggars??

Ah forget, you can never understand!

For what??

India is rising and closing the gap with the leading countries.

Till the time it is risen and be a bad ***..... STFU and do the work...

I love the Israeli in this, they seldom don't care and they keep concentrating on themselves.