Two Pakistani transgenders tortured to death in Saudi Arabia

[Mentee]

RIP

@2800 @Erl @Zarvan @The Eagle is there any such restriction in Islam that Transgenders could not visit The Sacred Sites ?

 

[Eagle_storm]

I don't know whats wrong with saudi arabia and for transgender there are also right given.once a transgender came infront of prophet s.a.w and start parodying of a women then prophet order not to let them enter your house but it doesn't mean that we should hate them or torture them if it was then why prophet didnt? And this hadith was also was taken by imam shafi imam malik and the father of fiqah imam abu hanifa. For proof you can see kitabul wadilyah babun nikah.further more the law of inheritance is also included for transgender i have to read when i read i will share. And i don't know what's wrong with saudi first they did cruelty with Pakistani labourers and now with transgender.

 

[YeBeWarned]

their kings and queen are fcuking Russian and other white Wh()res in Behrain and UAE .. and they try to pretend to be thekedaar of Islam .. WAH bhae WAH

 

[terry5]

good move Saudi
Men dressed as women is against the religion of Islam and must be dealt with harshly just like sodomites death is the cure if your a nasty freak

Dirty freaks taking there nastiness to the holy land

 

[Irfan Baloch]

good move Saudi
Men dressed as women is against the religion of Islam and must be dealt with harshly just like sodomites death is the cure if your a nasty freak

tell you what
man love is big issue in Saudi Arabia because of their harsh conservative society
so I dont know why they decided to beat these two Pakistanis .

RIP. Saudi Arabia kills more people then ISIS. And yet USA deals with them differently.

American leaders are bigots. ISIS is their own war toy.

 

[Russell]

Instead of condemning the savage, uncivilized and illegal conduct of the Saudi police - members here are asking the secondary question. "What were they doing there".

Because EVERYONE and I mean EVERYONE knows this is what you'd expect to happen in KSA. The country thinks women driving alone is going to set back Islam...How do you expect it to treat transgenders?

I know it sounds like blaming the victim - but, it's not.

 

[Kabira]

good move Saudi
Men dressed as women is against the religion of Islam and must be dealt with harshly just like sodomites death is the cure if your a nasty freak

Dirty freaks taking there nastiness to the holy land

I don't know what Islam says about transgenders but no harm should be done to them.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

Because EVERYONE and I mean EVERYONE knows this is what you'd expect to happen in KSA. The country thinks women driving alone is going to set back Islam...How do you expect it to treat transgenders?

I know it sounds like blaming the victim - but, it's not.

MMMMmm. You know it is not often I am stuck for a reply. Guess what? Your right. These trannies should have stayed in Pakistan. Money can be source of so much evil. But money in hands of ignorants like Saudi's is source of nothing but evil.

 

[Djinn]

This is outrageous! If they think they were guilty of violating any Saudi laws then they should have been tried according to the laws. Rather they were thrown into bags and beaten to their deaths. Equally disgusting will be the Pakistani state response which we all know will actually be NOTHING. What a shame and then people say, you should take pride for being a Pakistani.

 

[Eagle_storm]

good move Saudi
Men dressed as women is against the religion of Islam and must be dealt with harshly just like sodomites death is the cure if your a nasty freak

Dirty freaks taking there nastiness to the holy land

See saheh bukhari see kitabul wadiliyah and see the books of your imam on inheritance then do it.

RIP

@2800 @Erl @Zarvan @The Eagle is there any such restriction in Islam that Transgenders could not visit The Sacred Sites ?

In manyy hadith kitabul wadilayah and mand many books of imam abu hanifa no restriction upon them but they have been restricted from other home entry. See babun nikah in kitab bul wadilyah and also qudiri jild no 3

 

[The Eagle]

RIP

@2800 @Erl @Zarvan @The Eagle is there any such restriction in Islam that Transgenders could not visit The Sacred Sites ?

Firstly, the kingdom law to be followed by the visitors like whatever, restrictions are as being the law of their land however, in Islam naturall transgender is not cursed nor prohibited to visit holy places.

Now look at the same through another point of view that what if they were involved in some kind of illegal activities hence, apprehended by law of the land. Authorities here, must share details of their visit with purpose as it shouldn't be business I hope.

Yet whatsoever the charge is, still does not justify their killing without due process so let's wait for the story from their side as well.

Now out of this story, note the pattern of this transgender issue that previously we saw protesters in KpK as one was murdered there and then the so-called activists, mostly supported by beloved foreign NGO friends from Western countries, made it sky high for the defame and more than Justice. Now here is another Islamic country that will be once again cursed and what not for the same which is not for the Justice as it should be but there are other relations as well.

Most of these transgenders are not born as same but huge number transform for many other personal affairs etc so cannot be trusted hence, many in society do not treat them as natural transgender. There are many apprehended by law, found in illegal activities from thefts etc so cannot be treated as innocent but due process be followed.

Still, the killing is not justified like this and Islam does not permit as such. However, the time is too sensitive and crucial w.r.t. special campaigns against specific countries/societies to sabotage and lead them to total destruction by any means that includes such type of NGOs human rights etc promoting inhumane and unethical culture. Just read, observe, take note, don't follow the wrong but keep an eye and move-on. Firstly need to wait for details and must ask LISA authority for extrajudicial killing because, it was not an encounter with Terrorists after all.

(Pardon any typo, using cell phone)

 

[BATMAN]

I think may be for Umra

Why you think so?

Transgender or not.... Riyadh is not the place for Umra.

News says... those were dressed as women, i can safely assume they put on burqa to be at place forbidden to men... beaten to death in public by Saudi police where are the videos?

 

[MultaniGuy]

good move Saudi
Men dressed as women is against the religion of Islam and must be dealt with harshly just like sodomites death is the cure if your a nasty freak

Dirty freaks taking there nastiness to the holy land

Agreed with you

 

[Mentee]

Firstly, the kingdom law to be followed by the visitors like whatever, restrictions are as being the law of their land however, in Islam naturall transgender is not cursed nor prohibited to visit holy places.

Now look at the same through another point of view that what if they were involved in some kind of illegal activities hence, apprehended by law of the land. Authorities here, must share details of their visit with purpose as it shouldn't be business I hope.

Yet whatsoever the charge is, still does not justify their killing without due process so let's wait for the story from their side as well.

Now out of this story, note the pattern of this transgender issue that previously we saw protesters in KpK as one was murdered there and then the so-called activists, mostly supported by beloved foreign NGO friends from Western countries, made it sky high for the defame and more than Justice. Now here is another Islamic country that will be once again cursed and what not for the same which is not for the Justice as it should be but there are other relations as well.

Most of these transgenders are not born as same but huge number transform for many other personal affairs etc so cannot be trusted hence, many in society do not treat them as natural transgender. There are many apprehended by law, found in illegal activities from thefts etc so cannot be treated as innocent but due process be followed.

Still, the killing is not justified like this and Islam does not permit as such. However, the time is too sensitive and crucial w.r.t. special campaigns against specific countries/societies to sabotage and lead them to total destruction by any means that includes such type of NGOs human rights etc promoting inhumane and unethical culture. Just read, observe, take note, don't follow the wrong but keep an eye and move-on. Firstly need to wait for details and must ask LISA authority for extrajudicial killing because, it was not an encounter with Terrorists after all.

(Pardon any typo, using cell phone)

Sir g whatever the reason was , two Pakistanis were lynched without any trial and here we are giving justifications based on their gender and other hypothetical scenarios Ena no lamea'n pao jinaa saaday bnday maray NY . Why this criminal silence on this issue ? Sarkari babu or foreign office kaha'n hain

 

[BATMAN]

Firstly, the kingdom law to be followed by the visitors like whatever, restrictions are as being the law of their land however, in Islam naturall transgender is not cursed nor prohibited to visit holy places.

I would not believe in presence of such law in Saudi, even worse confirming it, unless i ensure about it.