Top 7 reasons why this Pakistani serial is a big hit in India

[Pakistani till death]

24 was 1000 times better than any other indian shit no doubt but its not original,,,just a licenced version of original 24 which i never liked btw.

but yeah it was an awesome start,,,lets hope for more to come



and that fills u with pride??
ur own national anthem in foreign language??

man thats disgusting

Cant you read?! Our anthem is fully in urdu im only bringing that up is to show that how different urdu and hindi really are!! If you cant read and understand my statement then its better you dont comment!

 

[Mike_Brando]

24 was 1000 times better than any other indian shit no doubt but its not original,,,just a licenced version of original 24 which i never liked btw.

but yeah it was an awesome start,,,lets hope for more to come

Paaji i was literally amazed after watching the first episode of the Hindi 24.I hope that more and more Hollywood soaps like Supernatural,White Collar,Homeland etc get made in Indian languages.I just love each one of these soaps

 

[Pakistani till death]

You mean muhajirs in Karachi speak the Urdu similar to your national anthem or the Urdu spoken by them is similar to the Hindi spoken by Indians. Do you watch Persian movies or Bollywood movies.

Im only commenting here is because some people call urdu as being a dialect of hindi! I fully agree that over the years due to bollywood urdu has become more similar to hindi rather than persian. Thats all im saying!!

 

[Multani]

Either you are unaware or you are an idiot to accept the fact. Urdu came from the region of Ganga Jamuna and it is considered origin for that. Hindi was there already even before Islam came in that region. It was more pure and referred as Devnagari similar to Paali in Bengal both originated from Sanskrit. When Persian came to the region, they called the language as Hindi as they refer geo political region as Hindustan and people as Hindus.

The lingo in the region of Eastern UP(Lucknow, Faizabad, Allahabad, Kanpur etc) is Avadhi and with the influence of Mughals, Little Arabic and more Persian came in the language. Read sometimes about Amir Khusrow when he started writing in Persian+Hindi and his Tomb is still in Allahabad. The language grew in Time and even Mughals left Persian/Turkic/Arabic and started using this in empire. And, if You really understand grammar then can you tell me from where this grammar comes in Urdu?

You must also know that only 4% Urdu speaking population was there in Pakistan in 1947? And mostly it was Mohajirs from UP/Bihar who brought the language. When Urdu came from Central Asia then why not Afghanistan, Current Pakistan was speaking Urdu?

urdu has been the religious language of the Muslims of Pakistan for hundreds of years

 

[he-man]

Cant you read?! Our anthem is fully in urdu im only bringing that up is to show that how different urdu and hindi really are!! If you cant read and understand my statement then its better you dont comment!

ur anthem is not in urdu dude
is that urdu to u??

 

[Pride]

urdu has been the religious language of the Muslims of Pakistan for hundreds of years

Seriously?? Einstein rightly pointed out that Stupidity is infinite. You are the one, he was talking about. :facepalm:

 

[Indischer]

Ok the structure is from sanskrit but im saying its different from hindi. You referred to them as just different dialects which im objecting to im not objecting it roots that are from persian, arabic, sanskrit, punjabi

Once the grammer is the same, if you replace Persian loanwords with Sanskrit loanwords, you're effectively switching over from Urdu to Hindi. That's how different(or same) they really are.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

ur anthem is not in urdu dude
is that urdu to u??

Just bcoz you can't understand it doesn't mean it's not Urdu .. Some call it persianised Urdu .. But in reality it's Urdu ..pure grammar.

 

[INDIC]

Im only commenting here is because some people call urdu as being a dialect of hindi! I fully agree that over the years due to bollywood urdu has become more similar to hindi rather than persian. Thats all im saying!!

The truth is over the year Urdu in Pakistan became more Persian as Pakistani government tried to introduce more Persian to it.

 

[Multani]

It's sad that every tom,dick and harry is talking about what constitutes a language without having even the basic knowledge of linguistics.Verbs and only the verbs and their inflections make up a language.Now the question arises,Do Urdu and Hindi have different verbs?or atleast are their verbs derived from 2 different languages?No.not even a single verb or tense did.all the verbs and pronouns are direct derivatives of Sanskrit.ex:peee,khaa,maar,likh,padh,uth etc and pronouns like hum,mein,tum are derived from Sanskrit.
No matter how many loan words you have in a language,as long as it sticks to its original grammar it can't be called another language.
Ex:mera brother six oclock sleep se Uth ke breakfast karke,car mein apne college ko gaya.(my Hindi isn't very gud)

There are seven English words and seven Hindi words in the above sentence.even a person who never attended a school will tell you that the language spoken was Hindi and not English inspite of having 7 English words.how?bcoz the verbs prepositions and pronouns used were Hindi.That is how a language is judged.No matter how many nouns of Turkish,Arabic and Persian origin Urdu has,it can't be called a separate language from Hindi as long as both have same grammar and verbs and their inflections.

urdu is certainly another language

 

[Pakistani till death]

ur anthem is not in urdu dude
is that urdu to u??

Yes that is urdu and now you have gotten my point does this sound hindi to you? No it doesnt and it proves my point and to further do that here it is
Pak sar zameen shad bad- urdu
Kishwar e haseen shad bad- urdu
Tu nishan e azme aali shan-urdu
Arze e pakistan-urdu
Markaz e yakeen shad bad-urdu
Pak sar zameen ka nizam-urdu
Quwat e akhuwat e awam-urdu
Qoum mulk saltanat-urdu
Painda tabinda bad-urdu
....
This is all fully urdu the urdu in which iqbal wrote the urdu in which faiz wrote. This had however been lost over the years but i can guarantee this is urdu. You only think what people from up speak is urdu however that is more or less hindi. If you dont think this is urdu then i dont know why are you even commenting

However my point proven urdu is not a dialect of hindi yay

 

[Indischer]

Thank you for a detailed reply
I'll give a short one. Please listen to the pakistani anthem or if not just read the lyrics and see if you can understand it. I can bet a million pounds that you can't but on the otherhand every pearsian speaker that is every iranian would be able to without and problem. Do reply whem u have heard or read it. Thank you

Precisely. The Quami Tarana is basically Persian as it's full of Persian loanwords. Which are the 'Urdu' words in that anthem?

 

[he-man]

Just bcoz you can't understand it doesn't mean it's not Urdu .. Some call it persianised Urdu .. But in reality it's Urdu ..pure grammar.

cut the crap,,,its not urdu,period.
shame on u to not even accept a very simple and obvious fact.

there is a limit to bias too dude,for once stop bullshitting

Precisely. The Quami Tarana is basically Persian as it's full of Persian loanwords. Which are the 'Urdu' words in that anthem?

i am really appalled by their replies on the anthem.
i mean does that sound urdu by any stretch of imagination??

 

[Pakistani till death]

cut the crap,,,its not urdu,period.
shame on u to not even accept a very simple and obvious fact.

there is a limit to bias too dude,for once stop bullshitting

What are you man this is urdu!! You dont soeak urdu then how come you are commenting all these words are from urdu

 

[Pakistani till death]

cut the crap,,,its not urdu,period.
shame on u to not even accept a very simple and obvious fact.

there is a limit to bias too dude,for once stop bullshitting



i am really appalled by their replies on the anthem.
i mean does that sound urdu by any stretch of imagination??

Even the words qaumi tarana are urdu when qaumi being national and tarana being anthem