Each of these we have people in the political system and hierarchy, well known names and families....that speak up about the human rights and issues of their people and over-action and even evil by the state's forces in the area.
Kashmir case for example I can name you a dozen or so big names.... want me to? They continually and openly criticize Indian security forces measures and actions....and bring all manner of cases to Indian court system. This is the underlying reason there never was and never will be mass scale incarceration and "re-education" and stripping of basic culture in Indian Kashmir.
This is the fundamental reason I and many other Indians here will also say there have been and continue to be grievous human rights situation inside Kashmir come about from one end by the national and state apparatus policy...that there is context, but also a better objective and result to achieve....and it is very very imperfect right now.
Will any (PRC) Chinese member here do likewise? You tell me. You just clam up.... into hands over ear mode and go"lalalala" "can't hear you"... if you are not busy shouting red book of the day quotes over it.....over and over.
After all name me one,
just one uighur allowed the same in China? Much less one inside the CCP "political system".
Understand this is the
basic basic difference in credibility on these issues. They are systematic...they are deep, they are intrinsic now this far downstream from original conception and aegis.
You have to understand that no one that has basic sound intelligence outside China.... takes
anything the CCP asserts credibly on just about anything ....not without having the other side of the story presented credibly by those facing and experiencing it on ground....and large enough persistent, credible and organised voices of their to present it.
Definitely we cannot give even one benefit of the doubt to CCP ....not with this level of opaqueness, obfuscation and shielding CCP runs on this matter....and not with the CCP own history in its own country in the past on multiple matters of even far larger scale.
Simply the case is CCP is monolith with uni-dimensional account....and naturally intelligent people on other hand know (by real life experience) monolith accounts are
fundamentally faulty. What of this is hard to understand for you? i.e the basic difference between democracy and a totalitarian state? Tell me one major check and balance (with real example to credit to it) that lies outside of CCP party control in China....name me just one.
Not many in this forum know what China is and what CCP/PRC is....
what the difference really is. It is all made quite clear when you have to deal with official govt thugs from CCP/PRC face to face..their attitude and mannerisms (contrasted to that part of China where CCP has no scope and presence)...at various duration of time and bristling intensity....but you also know what the larger China is past that in time and space...studied it, grounded in it from its own multi-perspective it once had within it at notable scale...and lived at length in a long formative time around majority chinese populations to permeate it within the mind, heart and soul.
Not many non-chinese get that experience...they don't know of it....but I do. CCP is engaging in much evil, it is not learning...it is only getting emboldened...I don't know how else to put it....I don't think it can be put another way increasingly. It seems to think whole of China is its birthright...and its alone. I fear and am saddened for the larger China....and can only hope it stays above the CCP, sees the CCP through... and not lose too much to it....if it hasn't already.
A great Civilisation that once developed and enshrined the concept of Yin and Yang.....now having a bunch of power hungry thugs and cabals asserting a total stark monolith of "might = right" in every discipline of national ethos.... tragic.
@Joe Shearer @T-123456 @VCheng @Nike @Indos @xenon54 @Krptonite @Reashot Xigwin @saiyan0321 @Hamartia Antidote @Vergennes @Gomig-21 @dbc @gambit
