The Islamic World's Outrage Against India Won't Protect the Country's Muslims

[HydraChess]

Enjoy!

It only shows intra caste marriages and caste codification happened around same time. Its proof of time when caste came into being. Not linking caste purely to Hinduism exclusively or caste identity itself to genetics.

 

[Kingdom come]

Errr... just one issue. Its not "We Muslims". Its more like Persians with some parts from India (Brahmagupta), ancient Babylonian and Greeks and Ancient Egyptians. Omar Khayyam, Musa Al-Khwarizmi and Sharaf al-Din al-Tusi were main inventors and re-discoverers. Muslim is a very wide group of people.


PEW are not pollsters. Neither their survey is opinion poll.

His data set is 571 people lol that's why people who don't know biology should not comment
To learn about population history in India at higher resolution than was previously possible, we assembled genome-wide data for 571 individuals from 73 well-defined ethno-linguistic groups from South Asia (71 Indian and 2 Pakistani groups

Genetic Evidence for Recent Population Mixture in India

Most Indian groups descend from a mixture of two genetically divergent populations: Ancestral North Indians (ANI) related to Central Asians, Middle Easterners, Caucasians, and Europeans; and Ancestral South Indians (ASI) not closely related to groups outside the subcontinent. The date of mixture...

www.cell.com

Dude!

India doesn’t have a class system. It has a caste system.

And no, Muslims don’t practice the caste system.

Genetic makeup of Hindu castes has been constant for about 3000 years.

Brahmins and Sudras, for example, have distinct genetic makeup. Which has remained constant for millennia.

You can identify a Indian person’s caste just by looking at their DNA. It’s freakishly accurate!!!

No such pattern found in Muslims of South Asia.

@Indos
@Bilal9
@Homo Sapiens

3000 years even your fake non peer reviewed paper says it's 1900

@HydraChess

 

[BananaRepublicUK]

It only shows intra caste marriages and caste codification happened around same time. Its proof of time when caste came into being. Not linking caste purely to Hinduism exclusively or caste identity itself to genetics.

You are now disputing extensive peer reviewed DNA research endorsed by Harvard. And taught at Harvard and other Ivy League universities!

That’s Trumpian level of trolling and denialism!!!!

@Bilal9
@UKBengali
@Homo Sapiens

 

[BananaRepublicUK]

His data set is 571 people lol that's why people who don't know biology should not comment
To learn about population history in India at higher resolution than was previously possible, we assembled genome-wide data for 571 individuals from 73 well-defined ethno-linguistic groups from South Asia (71 Indian and 2 Pakistani groups

Genetic Evidence for Recent Population Mixture in India

Most Indian groups descend from a mixture of two genetically divergent populations: Ancestral North Indians (ANI) related to Central Asians, Middle Easterners, Caucasians, and Europeans; and Ancestral South Indians (ASI) not closely related to groups outside the subcontinent. The date of mixture...

www.cell.com

3000 years even your fake non peer reviewed paper says it's 1900

@HydraChess

Started 3000 years ago and codified a millennia ago.

Stop denying science!!! You superstitious troller!

 

[HydraChess]

You are now disputing extensive peer reviewed DNA research endorsed by Harvard. And taught at Harvard and other Ivy League universities!

No, I am just writing what that research says. I agree with that research. It just does not support what you are trying to make it support.

 

[BananaRepublicUK]

Nonsense on love jihad. Terrorism bug is introduced because there is a flaw

Show me one caste war or a revolt based on caste before say 1000ad... you won't find any because therr was no discrimination

We cannot definitively because Hindus never kept written history.

But passed it through orally through primitive songs and dances!

 

[Kingdom come]

Thats fun. I have yet to see a peer reviewed and proper caste based DNA genome database or research. Do you have one with you? If not, you are wrong about the above assertion. If you have one share it.

BTW, here is what a recent PEW poll discovered about Caste system in India.

0. Muslims adhare to caste system in India more stringently than Hindus. Eg, greater percentage of Muslims do not want their men and women to marry out of caste and do not have friends outside their caste. ie, in India, caste is NOT just a feature of Hinduism, its wide spread across all religions.
Source : https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2021/06/29/attitudes-about-caste/

1. Indians in lower castes largely do not perceive widespread discrimination against their groups
Source : https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2021/06/29/attitudes-about-caste/

2. Most Indians do not have recent experience with caste discrimination
Source : https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2021/06/29/attitudes-about-caste/

3. Most Indians OK with Scheduled Caste neighbors
Source : https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2021/06/29/attitudes-about-caste/

4. Indians generally do not have many close friends in different castes
Source : https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2021/06/29/attitudes-about-caste/

5. Large shares of Indians say men, women should be stopped from marrying outside of their caste
Source : https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2021/06/29/attitudes-about-caste/


So leaving marriage and friendship (which are personal matters anyways), across different religions, most Indians (that includes Dalits, SC, ST and OBC) do not see much negative effect of caste system in India.

I guess its outsiders who are more concerned about Caste system in India than even Indian SC/ST/Dalits/OBCs.

@HydraChess even though half of it is false and psedo science try to read it

https://www.cell.com/action/doSearch?ContribAuthorRaw=Thangaraj%2C+Kumarasamy

Peer reviewed lol

 

[Indos]

Nonsense on love jihad. Terrorism bug is introduced because there is a flaw

Show me one caste war or a revolt based on caste before say 1000ad... you won't find any because therr was no discrimination

The flaw is not in Islam, but on those terrorist low intellectuality and understanding about Islam. In general, highly intellectuals people will likely rule their group of community, so in Muslim world we see government and Islamic scholars and scholars in general control the society for centuries. Quran needs to be translated by people who has high IQ and good thinking ability since Quran is made by God, the One who creates intellectuality among human.

When bomb and assault rifle are present in modern world, as well as media coverage is already penetrating this globalized new world, it is easier to conduct terrorism with profound impact as individuals alone can create huge damage. We cannot easily prevent some dumb people with huge cash create a small cells within our society. Particularly with Muslim living as minority in Western world, their psychology makes them fragile to be penetrated by messages created by AQ and ISIS, since many of them are already a depressed people who face discriminatory experiences there, where AQ and ISIS leaders live in authoritarian Middle East countries where violence revolt is the only means to get power.

----------------------------------------------------

There is no revolt in Indian history maybe because Dalit is so submissive

Any way, people in South India can revolt in other way, which is by accepting Islam which is the case of what happen in South Asian region. Easy invasion means the local population prefer the invader and despise their current social and political system. This is also why Islam can easily kick out Roman and Persian rule in Middle East since the general Arab people living in that period prefer to be ruled by Muslims

 

[Faqirze]

caste became a real problem only after the British came to india. Prior to that there was no real issue with caste and people did what they did for a living

Nepal was never colonized yet they still have caste

 

[hussain0216]

Indian Muslims are truly turning a corner

The poison in India will tear India apart, hindutva truly is our best weapon against India

Everything they do from bulldozing a couple of homes to the rampant poison on social media now chips away at India


To all Pakistani Patriots, this is the time to spend some time helping to destroy India

5th gen is on

 

[WotTen]

Expats who took part in Fahaheel demonstration to be deported

KUWAIT CITY, June 11: Instructions were issued to arrest and bring in expats from Fahaheel area who organized an demonstration after Friday prayers in support ...

www.arabtimesonline.com

Kuwaiti kicking out expats due to the Muhammad controversy

Nothing makes you appreciate Western democracies more than watching these repressive regressive dictatorial regimes in action. No amount of money is worth working there unless you are desperate.

 

[Binod]

Indian Muslims are truly turning a corner

The poison in India will tear India apart, hindutva truly is our best weapon against India

Everything they do from bulldozing a couple of homes to the rampant poison on social media now chips away at India


To all Pakistani Patriots, this is the time to spend some time helping to destroy India

5th gen is on

Many have come and gone dreaming to tear India apart in their life time. I am sure many will come in future to.you have to live in India to understand how India functions.

 

[hussain0216]

Many have come and gone dreaming to tear India apart in their life time. I am sure many will come in future to.you have to live in India to understand how India functions.

India has been torn apart multiple times, now the division and poison has torn apart the very social fabric of india

 

[Faqirze]

there is no discrimination in Nepal. it was an Indian society in all religions.
also you need to learn the varna system. that is the real categorisation of people and had nothing to do with caste birth or discrimination. it had to do with the duties they performed. its like Quran tries to be a good book but since muslims dont implement it properly islam gets a bad name. the varnashram was not adhered to properly after the advent of invasions which led to discontent and issues we see today.

If caste really wasn't a thing before the 19th century, so many Hindus probably wouldn't have converted to begin with.

 

[xeuss]

Many have come and gone dreaming to tear India apart in their life time. I am sure many will come in future to.you have to live in India to understand how India functions.

But no one has been as successful as Modi has been in tearing apart the country.