What's new

The Greatest Generals of World

Alexander Macedonia became king at the age of 20 , when he turned 23 years old, he first conquered Greece and then entered in Turkey, then defeated Dara in Iran , and then he conquered Jerusalem and Babylon, and then went to Egypt, after Egypt he came to India and defeated king Porus.
He laid down the foundation of Phalia City in the memory of his beloved horse and then he ride back through Makran (in Pakistan) during his way back he was caught in fever and died in the palace of Bakht Nasr at the age of 33.
The world was told that he was a great General and a King and therefore the world knows and called him as a Alexander the Great.

Now in the 21st century we can put a question in front of Historians of the twenty-first century, was Alexander was a really a great General in front of the Hazrat Umar Farooq (RA). Just think when Alexander become king at the at of 20, the best Archers taught him archery and he was taught horse riding by the best experts, and got the teachers like Aristotle (Arostu).

On the other hand Hazrat Umar Farooq (RA), none of his last 7 generations was any King. He was grown up by browing camals, he didn't learned horse riding or art of Archery and sword from any teacher.
Alexander conquered 18,00,000 square miles area with a strong and organized army during his 10 years kingdom. On the Other hand Hazrat Umar Farooq (RA) conquered 22,00,000 square miles area without any trained army during 10 Years (Including Rome and Iran superpowers of that time.)
The whole region was conquered by horse back riding under the management of Hazrat Umar Farooq (RA) and he implemented that management in the best way.
Alexander assassinated numerous famous Generals during the war who fought against him, even his army refused to obey his orders and to march forward in India.
On the other hand none of any soldier of Hazrat Omar refused any order or disobeyed to him. He was a kind of leader that during the battlefield he order his great general Hazrat Khalid bin Waleed to resign from his leadership in the battlefield and Hazrat Khalid bin Waleed obeyed his orders. He dismissed Hazrat Saad bin Abi Waqas from the governors of KOFFA Iraq.
He withdrawn the governing from Hazrat Harith ibn Ka'b, he ordered to confiscate the property of governor Umro bin AlAas. He called back the governor of Hirs and as a penalty ordered him to look after camels.

But none of his decisions were challenged by anybody because everybody knew that those decisions were based on true justice.

Alexander conquered 18,00,000 square miles area but couldn't gave any system to this world. But Hazrat Omar gave many systems to this world which are still exists in many forms.

It was Harzt Omar who:
1 - Adopted the sentence أصلوأة خير من النوم (Prayer is Better than Sleep) in Fajar Prayer.
2 - During his tenure the Tarawee Prayer was started regularly.
3 - He gave the punishment for drinking of alcohol.
4 - He started and lay down the foundation of Islamic Hijri Year.
5 - He gave and started the salaries to Mozans (Who Say Azan for Prayers).
6 - He order to maintain light in all Mosques during night times.
7 - He adopted a complete court system where even he himself was answerable.
8 - He introduced the idea of Jail Systems for criminals.
9 - He introduced the Canal System for agriculture and irrigation system.
10 -He first time made the Army FOB's (Forward operating bases) and laid the foundation of a military departments and a complete organization system.
11 - He first time in the world ordered to gave funds and benefits and appointed regular salaries for infants and widows.
12 - He first time in the world introduced the Post office system.
13 - He first time ordered to wear uniforms for Police.

On his table there was never served two dishes for him he eated only one dish. He was used to lay down and rest during the travel on the earth and make a pillow of his elbow or bricks. There were many patches on this dress, he was used to wear thick and rough clothes.
Whenever he appointed any governor he advised him that never ride or sit on a Turkish horse (was used for a status symbol for rich peoples), and don't wear thin clothes , don't eat screened flour , do not keep guard on the door so he can't stop anybody coming for complaints - He was used to say that a leader who do justice sleep fearless-
On his official seal it was written.... "Umar - remember death is sufficient for Advice"

His words even today are kept meaning as Charter for Human Right Organizations, that "Children are born free from their mothers when you made the slaves ?"
When he was died he was under the debt and that debt was paid after selling his house.

If the historians of today compare the personalities of Alexander and Hazra Omar (RA). Alexander is like a stone in front of a mountain.

The empire of Alexandra was eliminated after 5 years of his death, But Omar conquered which areas and put the flag of Islam in the world, even today there are Islamic Govts. and audible voice of Allah Akbar is daily coming from mosques five times a day.

During the partition of British Muslims in sub continent once peoples of Lahore threatened the British company and said "if we came out of houses, then you will remember what was a Genghis Khan"' .
And Juahr Lal Nehru said 'I am so sorry that Muslims forgot that they had a great leader like Umar Farooq ( RA) in their history.


Source: A Comparison between Alexander and Hazrat Omar RA (Fouth Khalifa of Islam)
 
. .
Alexander Macedonia became king at the age of 20 , when he turned 23 years old, he first conquered Greece and then entered in Turkey, then defeated Dara in Iran , and then he conquered Jerusalem and Babylon, and then went to Egypt, after Egypt he came to India and defeated king Porus.
He laid down the foundation of Phalia City in the memory of his beloved horse and then he ride back through Makran (in Pakistan) during his way back he was caught in fever and died in the palace of Bakht Nasr at the age of 33.
The world was told that he was a great General and a King and therefore the world knows and called him as a Alexander the Great.

Now in the 21st century we can put a question in front of Historians of the twenty-first century, was Alexander was a really a great General in front of the Hazrat Umar Farooq (RA). Just think when Alexander become king at the at of 20, the best Archers taught him archery and he was taught horse riding by the best experts, and got the teachers like Aristotle (Arostu).

On the other hand Hazrat Umar Farooq (RA), none of his last 7 generations was any King. He was grown up by browing camals, he didn't learned horse riding or art of Archery and sword from any teacher.
Alexander conquered 18,00,000 square miles area with a strong and organized army during his 10 years kingdom. On the Other hand Hazrat Umar Farooq (RA) conquered 22,00,000 square miles area without any trained army during 10 Years (Including Rome and Iran superpowers of that time.)
The whole region was conquered by horse back riding under the management of Hazrat Umar Farooq (RA) and he implemented that management in the best way.
Alexander assassinated numerous famous Generals during the war who fought against him, even his army refused to obey his orders and to march forward in India.
On the other hand none of any soldier of Hazrat Omar refused any order or disobeyed to him. He was a kind of leader that during the battlefield he order his great general Hazrat Khalid bin Waleed to resign from his leadership in the battlefield and Hazrat Khalid bin Waleed obeyed his orders. He dismissed Hazrat Saad bin Abi Waqas from the governors of KOFFA Iraq.
He withdrawn the governing from Hazrat Harith ibn Ka'b, he ordered to confiscate the property of governor Umro bin AlAas. He called back the governor of Hirs and as a penalty ordered him to look after camels.

But none of his decisions were challenged by anybody because everybody knew that those decisions were based on true justice.

Alexander conquered 18,00,000 square miles area but couldn't gave any system to this world. But Hazrat Omar gave many systems to this world which are still exists in many forms.

It was Harzt Omar who:
1 - Adopted the sentence أصلوأة خير من النوم (Prayer is Better than Sleep) in Fajar Prayer.
2 - During his tenure the Tarawee Prayer was started regularly.
3 - He gave the punishment for drinking of alcohol.
4 - He started and lay down the foundation of Islamic Hijri Year.
5 - He gave and started the salaries to Mozans (Who Say Azan for Prayers).
6 - He order to maintain light in all Mosques during night times.
7 - He adopted a complete court system where even he himself was answerable.
8 - He introduced the idea of Jail Systems for criminals.
9 - He introduced the Canal System for agriculture and irrigation system.
10 -He first time made the Army FOB's (Forward operating bases) and laid the foundation of a military departments and a complete organization system.
11 - He first time in the world ordered to gave funds and benefits and appointed regular salaries for infants and widows.
12 - He first time in the world introduced the Post office system.
13 - He first time ordered to wear uniforms for Police.

On his table there was never served two dishes for him he eated only one dish. He was used to lay down and rest during the travel on the earth and make a pillow of his elbow or bricks. There were many patches on this dress, he was used to wear thick and rough clothes.
Whenever he appointed any governor he advised him that never ride or sit on a Turkish horse (was used for a status symbol for rich peoples), and don't wear thin clothes , don't eat screened flour , do not keep guard on the door so he can't stop anybody coming for complaints - He was used to say that a leader who do justice sleep fearless-
On his official seal it was written.... "Umar - remember death is sufficient for Advice"

His words even today are kept meaning as Charter for Human Right Organizations, that "Children are born free from their mothers when you made the slaves ?"
When he was died he was under the debt and that debt was paid after selling his house.

If the historians of today compare the personalities of Alexander and Hazra Omar (RA). Alexander is like a stone in front of a mountain.

The empire of Alexandra was eliminated after 5 years of his death, But Omar conquered which areas and put the flag of Islam in the world, even today there are Islamic Govts. and audible voice of Allah Akbar is daily coming from mosques five times a day.

During the partition of British Muslims in sub continent once peoples of Lahore threatened the British company and said "if we came out of houses, then you will remember what was a Genghis Khan"' .
And Juahr Lal Nehru said 'I am so sorry that Muslims forgot that they had a great leader like Umar Farooq ( RA) in their history.


Source: A Comparison between Alexander and Hazrat Omar RA (Fouth Khalifa of Islam)

Just curiousity: don't want to interrupt your thoughts, but why would Muslims invoke Genghis Khan?

When did the people of Lahore threaten the British (company, was it?) and for what?

As far as I know, Hazrat Omar did not fight a battle, or wage a war; his generals did, great generals, especially Khalid bin Walid, but he didn't. So why is he being mentioned here? Alexander fought his battles himself, and planned his campaigns himself.

Whether he eated one dish or two, it isn't clear how his generalship was affected.

Don't bother to reply this, please; it is too perfect a description of too perfect a general, and nothing anyone, anywhere writes will make a difference to a true believer, so save it to cool your coffee.

Gen. JFR Jacob.

Fastest surrender post WW2.

You'll see him second from right in the picture that is my avatar. He was the staff officer and planned the entire campaign. Whom would you hold responsible for Tannenberg: Hindenburg or Ludendorff? Just asking.

This has become a really stupid thread.
 
.
Zia Ul Haq, German Minstein, and Hitler were the greatest generals I knew off.

He was one of the greatest Kings and Military strategists in India.

But not always he participated in wars.

His key to success were proper planning, innovating thinking and perfect execution of plan.
 
.
He was one of the greatest Kings and Military strategists in India.

But not always he participated in wars.

His key to success were proper planning, innovating thinking and perfect execution of plan.

Who he?
 
. .
He was one of the greatest Kings and Military strategists in India.

But not always he participated in wars.

His key to success were proper planning, innovating thinking and perfect execution of plan.

Oh have a heart. This guy was a dacoit whom Hindu historians and now politicians have puffed up into a god!!!
 
.
Oh have a heart. This guy was a dacoit whom Hindu historians and now politicians have puffed up into a god!!!

I disagree with this peevish and silly, juvenile response.

There is undoubtedly an excessive 'cult' of Shivaji built around culture and religion. That should not blind us to the genuine military qualities of this ruler of superior skills and military competence, while not being sufficient for anyone to descend to hero worship of the man. He was a very effective guerrilla leader and was the first to mobilise the military qualities of the hillmen of his area. Both Maratha light cavalry and Maratha light infantry were first deployed by this king who fought his own battles - unlike some of the hilarious inappropriate characters named in earlier posts. Later Maratha military capability built very largely on Shivaji's military organisation.

Have a heart indeed.
 
.
Oh have a heart. This guy was a dacoit whom Hindu historians and now politicians have puffed up into a god!!!
Yeah, Bangladeshis have produced great military generals who have put Shivaji to shame.
 
.
Great generals according to my view are
(1) KHALID BIN WALEED (RA)
(2) MUHAMMAD BIN QASIM
(3) HAIDER ALI
 
.
Yeah, Bangladeshis have produced great military generals who have put Shivaji to shame.
Actually we did sort out the lot of Maratha robbers that used to come to plunder us.Nawab Alivardi Khan had put an end to this treacherous lot when he paid Bhashkar Pandit in the same coin.
 
.
Actually we did sort out the lot of Maratha robbers that used to come to plunder us.Nawab Alivardi Khan had put an end to this treacherous lot when he paid Bhashkar Pandit in the same coin.
Really? Is that why Bengal became a tributary of the Marathas?
 
. . .
Not to forget one top officer in the shape of Air Marshal Nur Khan, no one has done what he did for Pakistan.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom