The End of the Indian Idea

[magra]

indians are united on BJP, Modi, and Hindutva. you are the black sheep among the indians.

Even if I am the only black sheep, I will paint the other sheep coming in contact with me black.

 

[hussain0216]

I still see some Hindus in Paksitan, any special planing of exterminating them??

CAA could have worked out but some of them are coming back now

 

[magra]

Exactly Indian leaders were fools

Rather then listen to the brilliance and wisdom of Jinnah, they tried to convince massive amounts of Indian Muslims to remain in a united India

What's happening today is EXACTLY due to the mistakes of Indian leaders

India may have had to give up a little more land but south Asia would be at peace and be able to move forward, instead because of India's actions we have had decades of conflict in South Asia

Land was divided by British based on the religious composition. You would not have got any more land regardless of the stance of Indian leaders.

 

[PakistaniAtBahrain]

Gandhi-Nehru promised muslims that India would protect them and they need not leave.

that is working out so well

Indian leaders were forced to agree to partition after 'Direct Action' day announced by Jinnah led to 1946 Calcutta communal riots.

so they agreed

We wanted to respect the will, hence J&K was handed over to Sheikh Abdullah. And we wanted to do plebiscite, but Pak never vacated J&K as per UN resolution to allow for plebiscite.

yes, the way to do this is lockdowns, communication blackouts, kidnapping, rapes, killings, pellet guns, employment discrimination, arresting politicians, banning political parties, etc.

If you won't let me present to you Idea of Pakistan via Pakistani muslim..
Plj read..
Hindus, Sikhs and Muslims in pre-1947 Lahore | India of the Past

so you accept that you are a liar? and that Sindh, Lahore and Bangladesh were muslim majority?

Even if I am the only black sheep, I will paint the other sheep coming in contact with me black.

lol, good luck, and enjoy the true face of India, the hindu rashtra.

 

[magra]

Exactly Indian leaders were fools

Rather then listen to the brilliance and wisdom of Jinnah, they tried to convince massive amounts of Indian Muslims to remain in a united India

What's happening today is EXACTLY due to the mistakes of Indian leaders

India may have had to give up a little more land but south Asia would be at peace and be able to move forward, instead because of India's actions we have had decades of conflict in South Asia

Jinnah's wisdom caused upheavel of 10 million people and death of a million. Plus a lifetime of enmity. A loud clap to such a wisdom.

 

[PakistaniAtBahrain]

Jinnah's wisdom caused upheavel of 10 million people and death of a million. Plus a lifetime of enmity. A loud clap to such a wisdom.

india turning into a hindu rashtra shows that Jinnah was right all along. you are right to applaud Jinnah's wisdom.

 

[hussain0216]

Land was divided by British based on the religious composition. You would not have got any more land regardless of the stance of Indian leaders.

If Indian Muslims were on board and not having bullshit smoke about a wonderful united India blown up their *** then they would and should have gotten their own areas

Sikhs needed a Khalistan not be a tiny minority in a sea of Hindus


Indian Christians needed a state too

Certain Indian ethnicities like Tamils might have preferred independence


But everyone was so concerned about getting everyone stuck in the same shit state they forgot what happens if like today a specific group like the hindutva begin to grow and rule

 

[gulli]

CAA could have worked out but some of them are coming back now

Still no Indian muslim will ever cross the border

 

[magra]

that is working out so well
so they agreed

Better than many more people dying while leaving behind their homes and migrating thousands of miles.
Agreeing for partition to stop bloodshed is not equivalent to agreeing to a stupid religious theory.

 

[hussain0216]

Jinnah's wisdom caused upheavel of 10 million people and death of a million. Plus a lifetime of enmity. A loud clap to such a wisdom.

Buddy, Jinnah was right all along the consequences of partition showed how much hatred was their between different people's

We would all be stuck together if not for partition


The reason for such conflict and hatred in South Asia is INDIA

 

[gulli]

so you accept that you are a liar? and that Sindh, Lahore and Bangladesh were muslim majority?

Atleast show some census record to prove me wrong first, m humble enough to accept my mistake

 

[magra]

india turning into a hindu rashtra shows that Jinnah was right all along. you are right to applaud Jinnah's wisdom.

India becoming intolerant is obviously not a good scenario. But tell me how many are dying due to this?
A very very small fraction of those that died in an avoidable partition induced violence.

 

[hussain0216]

Still no Indian muslim will ever cross the border

They are not welcome

Pakistan is only for Pakistanis

If Indians hate each other then partition India

 

[magra]

Buddy, Jinnah was right all along the consequences of partition showed how much hatred was their between different people's

We would all be stuck together if not for partition

The reason for such conflict and hatred in South Asia is INDIA

You guys hated India long before BJP came into the national scene. So I dont buy your logic at all. You guys hate India because 2 nation hate theory was the basis of your nation coming into existence.

 

[tower9]

There is no doubt that India's diversity hobbles the country's ability to work efficiently. However, I think the geographic contiguity of India and the fact that these regions have largely been politically and economically integrated for centuries will ensure it will stay united.