Tata gun, swadeshi bofors are different products: Gun Carriage Factory chie

[ramu]

Well dude, the TATA howitzer and OFB howitzer are also foreign designs!

One is derived from Denel T5-52,
another comes from FH-77B Bofors.

There is one difference. Money paid to TATA will be pruned back into India

 

[Omega007]

That gun is the original Bofors.

The OFB-built Bofors version is different, here is a pic of it at a DEFEXPO -


Look at the different muzzle design.

You are dead wrong.The picture you posted is not of a FH77B but that of Russian M 46 howitzer upgraded to 155mm L45 'Metamorphosis' gun.The barrel was supplied by Soltam and now by Kalyani group.
Between 600-750 M 46s has been upgraded to'Metamorphosis' standard.

 

[zaxcolix]

You are dead wrong.The picture you posted is not of a FH77B but that of Russian M 46 howitzer upgraded to 155mm L45 'Metamorphosis' gun.The barrel was supplied by Soltam and now by Kalyani group.
Between 600-750 M 46s has been upgraded to'Metamorphosis' standard.

Image is that of indianised Bofors.

This is what M-46 looks like

Russian gun is M-46 and the new name is Metamorphosis IOB M46 FG........180 of which was upgunned by Soltam.

Its undergoing trials so no new order of upgrade has been placed.

 

[The A-5]

You are dead wrong.The picture you posted is not of a FH77B but that of Russian M 46 howitzer upgraded to 155mm L45 'Metamorphosis' gun.The barrel was supplied by Soltam and now by Kalyani group.
Between 600-750 M 46s has been upgraded to'Metamorphosis' standard.

Nope, you are wrong

Here I give you a pic of the original FH77B and compare it to the Indian-version given above -



The upgraded M46 variant from OFB looks completely different at the other hand as shown in the picture
above.

 

[scarcry]

You are dead wrong.The picture you posted is not of a FH77B but that of Russian M 46 howitzer upgraded to 155mm L45 'Metamorphosis' gun.The barrel was supplied by Soltam and now by Kalyani group.
Between 600-750 M 46s has been upgraded to'Metamorphosis' standard.

Please show your source regarding numbers. I will be glad.

 

[PRINCE_THE_SHOWSTOPPER]

ok can anyone tell me plz about the difference between a 39cal,45cal & 52cal rounds???? which one is better??? do we need all of them???

 

[Mech]

ok can anyone tell me plz about the difference between a 39cal,45cal & 52cal rounds???? which one is better??? do we need all of them???

Yes, one for my left pocket, the other for my right pocket. I can balance the 52 on my head.

 

[trinity]

Yadav said, “GCF, don’t forget, has 109 years of experience in artillery manufacturing and others including Tata are just entering the field.





Plz after all these yrs, our PSU's have very little to show for. They are scared of competition which will only benefit the main user, which is the Indian Military




All these pictures made me more confused. COuld someone label which one is our and which are foreign

 

[Water Car Engineer]

Well dude, the TATA howitzer and OFB howitzer are also foreign designs!

One is derived from Denel T5-52,
another comes from FH-77B Bofors.

Yes, but he likes the fact it's being produced in India. And could be a solid foundation for future artillery(or branch off to something else) projects from those companies.(why u should support) The M777 is buying out of the self I believe.