What's new

Stranded Pakistanis in Bangladesh are forgotten victims

Status
Not open for further replies.

Black_cats

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Dec 31, 2010
Messages
10,031
Reaction score
-5
Stranded Pakistanis in Bangladesh are forgotten victims

Those stuck in Bangladesh since 1947 should be repatriated as a matter of priority

Published: August 07, 2021 10:44Tariq A. Al Maeena, Special to Gulf News
1.2278295-301114741


While Rohingya migrants have the world's attention, it has been a tragic state of affairs for the Biharis or Urdu-speaking people stranded in Bangladesh since partition

Image Credit: KM Asad/ZUMA Wire/REX/Shutterstock

Imran Khan, the Prime Minister of Pakistan faced many challenges when he took office. He has to turn his country around, a country that has suffered for decades under the ravages of unfettered looting which has crippled the economy and left the country in serious debt.

Ever since he assumed high office, Khan has been trying to fix things, much to the chagrin of his detractors and his efforts seem to be succeeding. Pakistan is returning to some form of economic stability and financial benchmarks are attesting to a positive change in Pakistan’s fortunes. Imran Khan had to tackle many fronts and while he stumbled on some, he managed to bring most of them back on track.

However, one area that continues to demand his attention is the fate of Pakistanis stuck in Bangladesh. Lost among the poor and oppressed of this world, including those in Palestine, Myanmar and elsewhere are more than a quarter million ghetto dwellers in squalid camps in Bangladesh. These are the forgotten remnants of the Indo-Pakistan partition, victims of a war imposed on them and there are very few voices that bring their destitute conditions to the fore.

While the United Nation Universal Declaration of Human Rights states every person has a right to nationality, these ‘stranded Pakistanis’ enjoy no such luxury. For the past 60 years, they have been spread across Bangladesh in 66 camps, each no bigger than a football field, with poor sanitation and shortages of running water.

Camp conditions are miserable, and large groups of families are often forced to share their living area with animals. They have no rights, limited job options and few economic prospects. They are refugees.

In pre-independence India, they were a Muslim minority in the region of Bihar. At the time of the partition in 1947, many moved to what was then East Pakistan. When civil war broke out between East and West Pakistan, the Biharis sided with the West. Subsequently in 1971, East Pakistan became the independent state of Bangladesh, and these Biharis who had been loyal to Pakistan were denied citizenship because they had “supported the enemy”.

Their first choice was to leave the new nation and go to the west, the part of Pakistan that still existed. They expected to be welcomed, and they waited. Almost four decades later, they continue to wait in silence and despair. Pakistan initially denied them permission to emigrate, fearing a massive influx could destabilise the country. The legal limbo they find themselves in predicts and even more despondent future.

There have been a few groups that have tried to break free this limbo and come up with a worthy solution. On of them was the Rabita Trust established in 1988 under the auspices of the then Pakistani President, the late Gen. Zia-ul-Haque, and the Muslim World League.

They put forth a proposal to organise the repatriation of the stranded Pakistanis. An estimated 40,000 homes were to be built and were to be freely allocated to those Bihari migrants in the Punjab province of Pakistan.

Over 3000 destitute families were issued Pakistani ID cards back in 1992 and over 1000 housing units were built in the Punjab to accommodate them. Unfortunately, funds were not very forthcoming, and the political changes in Pakistan over the last three decades had slowly pushed this issue on the back-burner.

The Pakistani Repatriation Council (PRC), an NGO who want to correct this travesty of justice has been busy since highlighting the stranded Pakistani issue to each successive government. In their recent proposal, they suggest the following:

The government of Bangladesh should be included as a partner in the negotiations.

Notwithstanding the fact that the Bangladeshi government had recently announced that they would selectively issue national passports for those born in the camps, their support in this matter of relocation is essential.

Those families who were previously issued Pakistani nationality cards and who still suffer in the camps should be repatriated as a matter of priority.

The Organization of Islamic Countries (OIC) should include this matter on their agenda and persuade national and international aid organisations to extend necessary sustenance allowances until they are repatriated.

Pakistan today faces many challenges. But one of them should be the protection of rights for all its constituents. While NGOs like the PRC are actively promoting the cause of these destitute mortals, it alone cannot do everything. It is also our moral obligation as citizens of this world not to ignore the forgotten.

Tariq A. Al Maeena is a Saudi sociopolitical commentator. He lives in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia. Twitter: @talmaeena

 
.
@The Eagle @waz

The Pajeet keeps on creating this thread again and again, about "Pakistani's in Bangladesh". Those Bihari's who shifted from India to West Pakistan are Bangladeshi's now, if they had moved to East Pakistan they would have been Pakistani now. It's plain, simple, and logical. Now can some mod stop this retard Pajeet from creating threads on this topic from time to time?

And no we are not going to take them, nor are we obligated to, so if any retard Bangladeshi or Pajeet thinks it otherwise he can go f himself. Plain, simple and if you want to strain the already strained relations between the two countries then yes you are doing a good job.

Retards crying about less than a million Rohingyas, don's even seen afghan refugees. We already have enough Indian spies in our country, now this Indian bootlicker nation wants to send some of its fresh homegrown lot just to please it's master. No fkin way.

I just hope that the current leadership grows some balls and cut all diplomatic ties with this pitthu nation, until they have some leadership change in their country and they get out of the influence of its current master, India.
 
.
@The Eagle @waz

The Pajeet keeps on creating this thread again and again, about "Pakistani's in Bangladesh". Those Bihari's who shifted from India to West Pakistan are Bangladeshi's now, if they had moved to East Pakistan they would have been Pakistani now. It's plain, simple, and logical. Now can some mod stop this retard Pajeet from creating threads on this topic from time to time?

And no we are not going to take them, nor are we obligated to, so if any retard Bangladeshi or Pajeet thinks it otherwise he can go f himself. Plain, simple and if you want to strain the already strained relations between the two countries then yes you are doing a good job.

Retards crying about less than a million Rohingyas, don's even seen afghan refugees. We already have enough Indian spies in our country, now this Indian bootlicker nation wants to send some of its fresh homegrown lot just to please it's master. No fkin way.

I just hope that the current leadership grows some balls and cut all diplomatic ties with this pitthu nation, until they have some leadership change in their country and they get out of the influence of its current master, India.

Without having little knowledge on topic don’t cry like babies. Biharis if they want can obtain Bangladeshi citizenship and there are no barriers to it and it is Supreme Court verdict. So how Bangladesh is sending them back?

It’s Biharis who are still not ready to accept Bangladeshi citizenship rather waiting to go back to Pakistan. As their ordinal citizenship was Pakistan still they are considered Pakistani or stranded Pakistani.

Many times Pakistani government promised to take them back but the promise have not been fulfilled.

Regarding Afghan refugees or displaced Rohingyas the comment that you have made is also not relevant as Biharis were always Pakistani citizen.

Based on your logic anyone who came to east Pakistan are not eligible for Pakistani citizenship? Is it your hate or out of touch with reality made you to say it?

Do you even know what Pakistani law says? Anyone even Bengalis who wanted to become Pakistani citizen until 1978 can obtain Pakistani citizenship.

Plus this news is posted in Gulf News not any Indian media nor written by an Indian. So stop whining about India every time when you can’t argue rationally.

The Biharis sided with Pakistan army and supported Pakistan till the last day east Pakistan fell on December 16, 1971. Still they have the desire to go back to Pakistan.

This is your moral obligation to take them back.
 
.
Without having little knowledge on topic don’t cry like babies. Biharis if they want can obtain Bangladeshi citizenship and there are no barriers to it and it is Supreme Court verdict. So how Bangladesh is sending them back?

It’s Biharis who are still not ready to accept Bangladeshi citizenship rather waiting to go back to Pakistan. As their ordinal citizenship was Pakistan still they are considered Pakistani or stranded Pakistani.

Many times Pakistani government promised to take them back but the promise have not been fulfilled.

Regarding Afghan refugees or displaced Rohingyas the comment that you have made is also not relevant as Biharis were always Pakistani citizen.

Based on your logic anyone who came to east Pakistan are not eligible for Pakistani citizenship? Is it your hate or out of touch with reality made you to say it?

Do you even know what Pakistani law says? Anyone even Bengalis who wanted to become Pakistani citizen until 1978 can obtain Pakistani citizenship.

Plus this news is posted in Gulf News not any Indian media nor written by an Indian. So stop whining about India every time when you can’t argue rationally.

The Biharis sided with Pakistan army and supported Pakistan till the last day east Pakistan fell on December 16, 1971. Still they have the desire to go back to Pakistan.

This is your moral obligation to take them back.
Jamaat e Islami, other RW parties sided with Pakistan

Are you planning to send them and their political base to Pak too?
 
.
Without having little knowledge on topic don’t cry like babies. Biharis if they want can obtain Bangladeshi citizenship and there are no barriers to it and it is Supreme Court verdict. So how Bangladesh is sending them back?

It’s Biharis who are still not ready to accept Bangladeshi citizenship rather waiting to go back to Pakistan. As their ordinal citizenship was Pakistan still they are considered Pakistani or stranded Pakistani.

Many times Pakistani government promised to take them back but the promise have not been fulfilled.

Regarding Afghan refugees or displaced Rohingyas the comment that you have made is also not relevant as Biharis were always Pakistani citizen.

Based on your logic anyone who came to east Pakistan are not eligible for Pakistani citizenship? Is it your hate or out of touch with reality made you to say it?

Do you even know what Pakistani law says? Anyone even Bengalis who wanted to become Pakistani citizen until 1978 can obtain Pakistani citizenship.

Plus this news is posted in Gulf News not any Indian media nor written by an Indian. So stop whining about India every time when you can’t argue rationally.

The Biharis sided with Pakistan army and supported Pakistan till the last day east Pakistan fell on December 16, 1971. Still they have the desire to go back to Pakistan.

This is your moral obligation to take them back.


The only ones who are crying are the retard Pajeet Bangladeshi's, Rohingya this, Rohingya that we can't have any refugees. Pakistan should take Bihari's because they moved from India to Bangladesh. Bla bla same old bullshit, sorry I meant cow shit. THEY MOVED TO BANGLADESH THEY ARE YOUR's. Whether they want Pakistani nationality, Bangladeshi nationality, American nationality is IRRELEVANT. THEY ARE YOU AND THEY ARE YOURs or india's if we stretch it back to roots. End of discussion.

There is no moral obligation, the only moral obligation is to reply a filthy pajeet in such colorful language that he understands this simple concept. They moved to Bangladesh they are yours. Now go f urself, bitching about it again and again won't CHANGE A SINGLE THING. The only thing it is doing and will do is create hostility. And no we won't take them, and no their is no "taking them back" Taking them back mean that they came here in the first place which they never ever fkin did. GET that through your dumb skull head you filthy cow dung sniffing pajeet.
 
Last edited:
.
Jamaat e Islami, other RW parties sided with Pakistan

Are you planning to send them and their political base to Pak too?

Bangladesh is not sending anyone plus Jamaat already obtained Bangladeshi citizenship even the pro Pakistani one. Trial is going on for the ones who committed war crimes and some are already punished.

Biharis have not obtained Bangladeshi citizenship yet. So both are not relatable.
 
.
Bangladesh is not sending anyone plus Jamaat already obtained Bangladeshi citizenship even the pro Pakistani one. Trial is going on for the ones who committed war crimes and some are already punished.

Biharis have not obtained Bangladeshi citizenship yet. So both are not relatable.
If they don't want Bangali citizenship

Than how's this our fault or responsibility to give them citizenship?
 
. .
Ch***, I know, but I replied to you in the context of your bitching. We hosted Afghanis, we never complained or bitched as much as Bangladesh does, and yes all that bitching would have been logical and made sense if it was only limited to Rohingya. But this whole rant about Biharis' in Bangladesh and calling them Pakistani's WHEN THEY NEVER EVER SET FOOT IN PAKISTAN is not a little retarded but magnanimous cow dung levels of retarded.


It's already fixed, you can shove those Bangladeshi up your a hole.

I guess you don’t even know what was the definition of Pakistan till 1971. Anyone who were in both east and west wing of Pakistan are considered Pakistani.

After partition of east Pakistan every citizen had the choice either to choose Pakistan or Bangladesh.

That’s how citizenship are determined everywhere when a country is divided.

Plus Pakistani law also allowed anyone to choose Pakistan until 1978, 7 years after independence of Bangladesh.

Biharis sided with Pakistani army and supported Pakistan all along. That’s why it is Pakistan’s legal and moral obligation to take them back.
Ch***, I know, but I replied to you in the context of your bitching. We hosted Afghanis, we never complained or bitched as much as Bangladesh does, and yes all that bitching would have been logical and made sense if it was only limited to Rohingya. But this whole rant about Biharis' in Bangladesh and calling them Pakistani's WHEN THEY NEVER EVER SET FOOT IN PAKISTAN is not a little retarded but magnanimous cow dung levels of retarded.


It's already fixed, you can shove those Bangladeshi up your a hole.

@waz can you please take action against this poster. He is using profanity non stop.
 
.
I guess you don’t even know what was the definition of Pakistan till 1971. Anyone who were in both east and west wing of Pakistan are considered Pakistan.

After partition of east Pakistan every citizen had the choice either to choose Pakistan or Bangladesh.

That’s how citizenship are determined everywhere when a country is divided.

Plus Pakistani law also allowed anyone to choose Pakistan until 1978, 7 years after independence of Bangladesh.

Biharis sided with Pakistani army and supported Pakistan all along. That’s why it is Pakistan’s legal and moral obligation to take them back.


THOSE WHO CHOSE PAKISTAN at the time of separation, already came to Pakistan, those who stayed were left behind in Bangladesh, there is 0 responsibility on Pakistan to cater to those after 50 years. Whether they want to be in Pakistan or not it doesn't matter now. They have lived their whole lif in either India or Bangladesh. Pakistan has NO SPACE, NO MORAL OBLIGATION and NO NEED for them. So the delusional Bangladeshi's can keep on thinking they are Pakistani's or Amercians if they want and they Pajeets can keep affirming their delusion if they want to. BUT IT IS NOT GOING TO CHANGE A THING, THEY ARE YOURS LIVE WITH IT AND STOP BITCHING ABOUT IT, from time to time.

If no other news comes up same old randi rona of rape and genocide of '71 or the same retarded topic of biharis in Bangladesh.
 
.
The only ones who are crying are the retard Pajeet Bangladeshi's, Rohingya this, Rohingya that we can't have any refugees. Pakistan should take Bihari's because they moved from India to Bangladesh. Bla bla same old bullshit, sorry I meant cow shit. THEY MOVED TO BANGLADESH THEY ARE YOUR's. Whether they want Pakistani nationality, Bangladeshi nationality, American nationality is IRRELEVANT. THEY ARE YOU AND THEY ARE YOURs or india's if we stretch it back to roots. End of discussion.

There is no moral obligation, the only moral obligation is to reply a filthy pajeet in such colorful language that he understands this simple concept. They moved to Bangladesh they are yours. Now go f urself, bitching about it again and again won't CHANGE A SINGLE THING. The only thing it is doing and will do is create hostility. And no we won't take them, and no their is no "taking them back" Taking them back mean that they came here in the first place which they never ever fkin did. GET that through your dumb skull head you filthy cow dung sniffing pajeet.





Dude, I think you are not listening to the point being made.

BD has offered all of them citizenship but some of them would like to go to Pakistan as they consider themselves Pakistani. BD cannot force them to give up this thought of theirs.

Please just take a chill pill here as no idea why this bothers you so much.
 
.
@waz can you please take action against this poster. He is using profanity non stop.

There are already threads about this topic "Biharis in Bangladesh" and not just one but multiple of them. If the profanity which you surely and definitely deserve needs to be removed then all your threads should be removed or merged on this topic and you should be warned about creating spam and multiple threads on the same topic.

You are the one who is antagonizing here, by creating a thread on an irrelevant topic, which already has multiple threads. If we go by the rules, your spam needs to removed and my "so called profanity" will automatically get removed with it.
 
.
Did you even read the news? Or has any knowledge on the subject matter? If not please stop blabbering same thing again and again without knowing the facts on the ground.

Bangladesh is not involved here anyway. It’s Biharis who still consider themselves as Pakistani and waiting to go back and not ready to accept Bangladeshi citizenship.

Rohingyas are displaced and persecuted people and has no origin in Bangladesh. Myanmar is their homeland and Bangladesh is trying to make sure they can live there a happy and free life.


They are Pakistani citizen all along. Their citizenship has never been revoked. Only repartition has not been done which Pakistani government promised so many times in the past.

Plus this is Pakistani law that anyone wanted to be Pakistani citizen until 1978 can do so that includes Bengalis.

Not only Pakistan promised to take them back, they were also provided with funds from Saudis and UAE to settle the refugees in Pakistan.

In any case, his posts clearly exhibit the prevalent sentiments against the Muhajir community in Pakistan.
 
. .
Since PK doesn't want its Wafadar Bigaris, we might as well heavily promote birth control in the slums inhabited by these creatures..

Assimilate or Perish.. Your masters have foresaken you..
 
.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom