South China Sea Forum

[EastSea]

For the nth time read the title of the map.

It really is quite boring interacting with PDF Vietnamese as they can't even read Hanzi then expect Chinese to agree with them.

It is " full map " of China, kid.

 

[Grand Historian]

It is " full map " of China, kid.

This just proves you can't read Hanzi

 

[StarCraft_ZT]

This just proves you can't read Hanzi

Yes, they don't know Hanzi, but they want to study their history, what a joke.

 

[Grand Historian]

Yes, they don't know Hanzi, but they want to study their history, what a joke.

That's why they rely on internet fabrications because they can't even read their own history

 

[EastSea]

This just proves you can't read Hanzi

Yes, they don't know Hanzi, but they want to study their history, what a joke.

What is this 全圖 ? bullshxt ?

 

[NiceGuy]

For the nth time read the title of the map.

It really is quite boring interacting with PDF Vietnamese as they can't even read Hanzi then expect Chinese to agree with them.

We just let other nations can see ur real map during Qing dynasty. No U-shape that time . If u want a debate, then go to international court , lots of VNese can read Hanzi there.

Of course CHina dare not go to international court coz their history abt SCS(east sea) r all fake

 

[Grand Historian]

What is this 全圖 ? bullshxt ?

How hard is it to comprehend a simple title?

Why do you think that Northeastern and Western China are not fully included?

 

[xesy]

Yes, they don't know Hanzi, but they want to study their history, what a joke.

Our history is written by "Nom", not Hanzi. Even though Nom was based on Hanzi, it's fundamentally different. So of course we don't need to know Hanzi to study our history.

What is this 全圖 ? bullshxt ?

It means "full image".

That's why they rely on internet fabrications because they can't even read their own history

Oh, then you might say our textbooks are full of lies and our TV is just propaganda. We don't mind that. As everyday we can easily see historical sites and monuments around us about how our ancestors bravely fought invaders. And why do you care about our history while you have your own version of it? Believe yours, and leave us believe ours.

 

[Grand Historian]

Our history is written by "Nom", not Hanzi. Even though Nom was based on Hanzi, it's fundamentally different. So of course we don't need to know Hanzi to study our history.

These books are all in Hanzi ie 大越史記,大越史記全書,欽定越史通鑑綱目 if you can't read them that means you don't even understand your own historians.

Oh, then you might say our textbooks are full of lies and our TV is just propaganda. We don't mind that. As everyday we can easily see historical sites and monuments around us about how our ancestors bravely fought invaders. And why do you care about our history while you have your own version of it? Believe yours, and leave us believe ours.

Vietnamese have provided absolutely nothing that they ruled Southern China or that their precious Hung Kings existed,I don't believe in anything prior to Shang for the same reason.

Look at PDF Vietnamese posts and you can clearly see that they want to steal every aspect of Chinese history as their own.

The amount of fabrication is absolutely staggering,do you thieves have no shame?

 

[NiceGuy]

Look at PDF Vietnamese posts and you can clearly see that they want to steal every aspect of Chinese history as their own.

The amount of fabrication is absolutely staggering,do you thieves have no shame?

China history abt SCS(east sea) r all fake, if u r so confident abt ur history book, then why dont u come to international court and prove that SCS(east sea) belong to u ?? Dont just sit behind the monitor and talk nonsense.

 

[Grand Historian]

China history abt SCS(east sea) r all fake, if u r so confident abt ur history book, then why dont u come to international court and prove that SCS(east sea) belong to u ?? Dont just sit behind the monitor and talk nonsense.

Why should I prove anything?

I'm not a government entity nor am I a lawyer,unless you can prove that Qing era maps are fake your words mean nothing here.

History thieves like you are incapable and or simply too incompetent to defend their claims.

Now prove that the Li surname originated from Baiyue people,I'll be waiting.

Civilizational flow has been primarily one way,ie from China to Vietnam otherwise show what the Chinese adopted from the Vietnamese.

 

[NiceGuy]

Why should I prove anything?

I'm not a government entity nor am I a lawyer,unless you can prove that Qing era maps are fake your words mean nothing here.

History thieves like you are incapable and or simply too incompetent to defend their claims.
.

U r thief in SCS(east sea), lots of countries oppose u bcz u rob the international water, no one support ur baseless claim ..

Now prove that the Li surname originated from Baiyue people,I'll be waiting.

Civilizational flow has been primarily one way,ie from China to Vietnam otherwise show what the Chinese adopted from the Vietnamese

Why must I prove, The Li still living in HaiNan, our surname Le (Li) was taken from our Baiyue bro. U dont have any video clip to prove that Li surname was adopted from China. Dont use ur fake book to lie here.

Show some video clip, otherwise, get lost, liar .

 

[Grand Historian]

Why must I prove, The Li still living in HaiNan, our surname Le (Li) was taken from our Baiyue bro. U dont have any video clip to prove that Li surname was adopted from China. Dont use ur fake book to lie here.

Show some video clip, otherwise, get lost, liar .

You made the claim now prove it.

黎 is proven to exist in Northern China by artifacts and textual evidence.

It is mentioned by Shang Shu,Mozi,Chunqiu Zuozhuan.Lushi Chunqiu,Shuowen Jiezi,Shiji etc.

After being initially raided by grave robbers in 2005,archaeologist were able to piece together the leftovers of the cemetery of the fallen Li kingdom in 2006.

The inscription □侯宰□作寶壺永用 was found in the 8th pit on a bronze ding.

After meticulous study by Chinese specialists the first unclear word was found to be 楷.

In Old Chinese 楷 and 黎 were homonyms and experts such as Zhao Manfang(趙滿芳) and Zhang He(張頜) concluded that 黎 was originally written as 楷.

Further evidence is shown in the book 甲骨文字釋林 which shows that the word 楷 was used as a toponym in Northern China.

Article for those intrested:黎城西周古墓发掘始末_本地历史_黎城在线

 

[Zero_wing]

Wow see how filipino cry on uncle sam's lap.

Can any chinko chinamen back up there claims i guess not

 

[EastSea]

How hard is it to comprehend a simple title?

Why do you think that Northeastern and Western China are not fully included?

we don't care what your ancestor think about Northeastern and eastern territory of China in this map. The map of Man Qing stated " 全圖 " mean "full map " or " toàn đồ " in Vietnamese. There is last point of China's territory is Hannan Island.