Sikhs are not Hindus - White House petition calls Obama to seek explanation from Modi.

[pursuit of happiness]

Dharmic is generic classification of religions that originated in the sub continent, similar to the concept of Abrahamic religions such as Judaism, Christianity. Even if there are similarities in basic tenets and share common root etc , they exist and function as separate religions.



well every revolution has a humble start

---
yes..
Revolution for waht .?
Punjab is one of most wealthy state in india..
Pujabis have major stake in indian high ranks in politics, military ... media.. and indian scoierty..
part of bollywodd is unimaginabe wihout kapoors.. the ......( uday sheety line in welcome movie)
see the luxary.... even sedan class guy in city will

--
so please explain revolution for what

 

[Stephen Cohen]

@KingMamba @farhan_9909

Why do you think SIkhs DID NOT trust Pakistanis and join Pakistan in 1947

Hindus did not force them to join India

Secondly given the current environment in Pakistan ; Sikhs too would have suffered the
same fate as Christians and Hindus

Basically your problem is that Punjab and Bengal got divided and you got a
moth eaten Pakistan

 

[Srinivas]

Dharmic is generic classification of religions that originated in the sub continent, similar to the concept of Abrahamic religions such as Judaism, Christianity. Even if there are similarities in basic tenets and share common root etc , they exist and function as separate religions.
well every revolution has a humble start

The difference is that Abrahamic religions are intolerant towards others faiths, Jews hate Christians and call Christianity is an abomination, Christians hate Muslims and say that Jesus is a god. Muslims hate Jews and Christians and think they can hijack the above two faiths.

The scenario is not like this in India, Hinduism is a broader faith not a conservative one the actual name is Dharma, In the clause Hinduism means people following Dharmic faith.

 

[farhan_9909]

@KingMamba @farhan_9909

Why do you think SIkhs DID NOT trust Pakistanis and join Pakistan in 1947

Hindus did not force them to join India

Secondly given the current environment in Pakistan ; Sikhs too would have suffered the
same fate as Christians and Hindus

Basically your problem is that Punjab and Bengal got divided and you got a
moth eaten Pakistan

Sikh or Muslims,they were left on purpose that too in this large numbers,so that we don't have to take tension aur tum logo ka apne hi mulk ma jeena haram kr de

Jaise maine pehla kaha tha,Tum logo parr aisa wakt ayega k last time to tehreek chali thi,is dafa tum log musalmano ko khud majboor karogay k apna liye line laga lo india main,jaha chahe mulk bana lo lekin hamain chor do

 

[manlion]

---
yes..
Revolution for waht .?
Punjab is one of most wealthy state in india..
Pujabis have major stake in indian high ranks in politics, military ... media.. and indian scoierty..
part of bollywodd is unimaginabe wihout kapoors.. the ......( uday sheety line in welcome movie)
so please explain revolution for what

the video I posted had a reason -1984 Sikh genocide and the need for freedom from Indian rule. The Constitution of India, declaration of Sikhs as Hindus is never acceptable. Sikhs with their separate identity - language, culture, religion have the right to self autonomy to preserve their identity, justifying the need for a revolution

 

[Stephen Cohen]

Sikh or Muslims,they were left on purpose that too in this large numbers,so that we don't have to take tension aur tum logo ka apne hi mulk ma jeena haram kr de

Jaise maine pehla kaha tha,Tum logo parr aisa wakt ayega k last time to tehreek chali thi,is dafa tum log musalmano ko khud majboor karogay k apna liye line laga lo india main,jaha chahe mulk bana lo lekin hamain chor do

You are fully entitled to your dreams and delusions

 

[farhan_9909]

You are fully entitled to your dreams and delusions

waise maine bhi tumse koi ijazar nahin mangi

 

[Sneaker]

'WAS'. Emphasis on 'was'. This is important unless you too , in typical Hindutva fashion are denying the Sikh community their individual place in the pantheon of Indian religions. And those people who converted to Sikhism were locals and not imported from hundreds of miles away in India.
And what was the dominant religion anyways, you tell me?



Sir Ji, they do have problems with it even in India.
Sikhs in the Indian Constitution | The Langar Hall

Were locals but not Indians? who were they, martians? If emphasis is on "was" why are you whining about?

 

[pursuit of happiness]

the video I posted had a reason -1984 Sikh genocide and the need for freedom from Indian rule. The Constitution of India, declaration of Sikhs as Hindus is never acceptable. Sikhs with their separate identity - language, culture, religion have the right to self autonomy to preserve their identity, justifying the need for a revolution

--
see videoo..
1984 riots had political angle in it..
unfortunatley people who are responsbile still free
--
indian cosntituin and sikh as hindu
can you give me authethic and reputed source which deny this
---
every indian state all tha you mentioned..
--
you are from which country.. as your flags not shown so asked..
--
if you tell me becuase 1984 they wnt freedom..

 

[gslv]

This perhaps will remain a mystery for me always,

Sikh by default are pakistanis,how the hell they accept being called indians

yeah thats why Milkha Singh never wanted to go to pakistan bcoz of your love.

 

[manlion]

The difference is that Abrahamic religions are intolerant towards others faiths, Jews hate Christians and call Christianity is an abomination, Christians hate Muslims and say that Jesus is a god. Muslims hate Jews and Christians and think they can hijack the above two faiths.

The scenario is not like this in India, Hinduism is a broader faith not a conservative one the actual name is Dharma, In the clause Hinduism means people following Dharmic faith.

Hinduism has its share of abomination e.g caste system which is justified as law in Manu Sastra, just because some perceive Hinduism to be " tolerant " of other religions doesn't give Hindus the mandate to lump Sikhism as Hinduism.

 

[Force-India]

Sikh or Muslims,they were left on purpose that too in this large numbers,so that we don't have to take tension aur tum logo ka apne hi mulk ma jeena haram kr de

Jaise maine pehla kaha tha,Tum logo parr aisa wakt ayega k last time to tehreek chali thi,is dafa tum log musalmano ko khud majboor karogay k apna liye line laga lo india main,jaha chahe mulk bana lo lekin hamain chor do

Coming from 'Waitingforamiracle'istan LOL. Btw did you know praying bad for someone has no meaning and wrong deeds kills you like slow poison and funny thing is yoy don't even get ro know what you did. This is Karma for you

 

[Srinivas]

Hinduism has its share of abomination e.g caste system which is justified as law in Manu Sastra, just because some perceive Hinduism to be " tolerant " of other religions doesn't give Hindus the mandate to lump Sikhism as Hinduism.

You are not getting the point here, the word Hinduism is not found any where in Dharmic scriptures, for foreigners people living east of Indus practice a faith called Hinduism.

regarding caste system, smritis and shastras are not the word of GOD.

 

[Narashima]

sikhs are treated as equal to hindus(and other Indians) by our constitution something that pak minorities can only dream of.

 

[manlion]

You are not getting the point here, the word Hinduism is not found any where in Dharmic scriptures, for foreigners people living east of Indus practice a faith called Hinduism.

regarding caste system, smritis and shastras are not the word of GOD.

you are just nit picking to divert the issue - smritis , Hinduism etc . Hinduism encompasses everything Shruthis, smrithis puranas, shastras,etc "sruti-smriti-puranadi-pancaratra-vidhim vina aikantiki harer bhaktir "

If not Hindu then tell me what name you want me to address your lot ?