What's new

SANEM’s Selim Raihan wants govt to rethink mega projects

bluesky

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jun 14, 2016
Messages
16,515
Reaction score
-4
Country
Bangladesh
Location
Japan

SANEM’s Selim Raihan wants govt to rethink mega projects

Published: June 07, 2022 12:08:13 | Updated: June 07, 2022 20:54:32

SANEM’s Selim Raihan wants govt to rethink mega projects

Dr Selim Raihan, the executive director of the South Asian Network on Economic Modeling, or SANEM, an economic think tank, has sought clear guidelines from the national budget to recover from the ongoing predicament of the economy, affected by the post-pandemic boom in demand and the inflation caused by supply inadequacy due to the Russia-Ukraine war in Europe, bdnews24.com reports.

The dual effect put Bangladesh’s economy into a spiral and the country, at this very moment, is facing a crisis, which, according to Dr Raihan, could very much push the economy into a recession, unless significant countermeasures are included in the national budget for the next fiscal.

In an interview with this news provider, highlighting inflation, volatility in the foreign exchange market, a surge in imports, and negative growth in remittances as the biggest challenges in Bangladesh’s economy now, he said: "Clear directions to recognise and address these issues must be included in the next fiscal’s national budget.”

Drawing examples from his own think tank’s calculations for the last 10/15 years, Dr Raihan said there is a difference of up to 25 per cent between the proposed budget and the implemented budget.

“The current monitoring or evaluation system to see how the national budget is being spent is very weak. As soon as the government will be able to set up a proper monitoring and analysis system, the issue of accountability and transparency will come forth.”

‘RETHINKING ABOUT MEGA PROJECTS NECESSARY’
Although at this very moment, Dr Raihan does not consider Bangladesh’s foreign debt as a “burning” matter, he is of the view that it is high time policymakers treaded cautiously moving forward.

"We need to reassess how much of this debt is being invested in the productive sectors and how much of it is bearing fruit."
As of last December’s data, Bangladesh’s foreign debt amounted to $91 billion.

Pointing toward the persisting problem of the difference between any mega project’s proposal and the reality, Dr Raihan said: “In Bangladesh, there is hardly any correlation between the feasibility study of a mega project and the reality on the ground during the implementation stage. The rise in overhead costs due to failure to meet deadlines has become a major cause for concern.”

He suggested that policymakers adapt to a new way of thinking about mega projects in the current context.

"We need to take stock of the ongoing foreign debt-based mega projects. It’s time to review what the feasibility studies say, the actual progress of the project to date, and how much things have changed.”

Admitting that the next budget cannot address all of these, he suggested the policymakers at least come up with a roadmap to undertake such reviews in future.

‘PLEASE ADMIT THERE IS A PROBLEM'
A SANEM survey before the last fiscal’s budget announcement revealed that in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, the percentage of people below the poverty level had increased from 20 per cent to nearly 40 per cent within a year.

The government categorically dismissed the data. Only recently, in some forums, Finance Minister Kamal has partially admitted the fact but insisted that the situation improved drastically since the lifting of pandemic-era restrictions.

The matter appears to be a sore subject for the University of Manchester-trained economist. The government first has to accept there is a crisis, otherwise there will be no solution,” Dr Raihan said.

The official position of the government and the analysts’ prognosis of the economy are identical at the moment as both sides have pointed out the threat of ongoing inflation and global recession, resulting in a surge in commodities prices which compounded sufferings of the middle-class.

“I highly doubt there will be any recognition of the new poor in this budget since the government did not even acknowledge them in the last one,” he said.

Dr Raihan wants a clear direction in the budget on how to bring the prices of essential commodities to a tolerable level.

He also said the budget should have guidelines on how to expand the social security programmes and allocations, which the finance minister already said that he will, and how to include those who are under new inflationary pressures.

‘REMOVE BARRIERS TO ATTRACT MORE FDIS’
His advice for the government includes reforming policies to create new jobs and incentives for small and medium enterprises.
"In the budget, the government must give special attention to micro and small enterprises and initiatives should be taken to increase investment and credit growth in the private sector,” he said.

He also said the government must find out why private sector investment is not growing. Citing the successes of India in the last year regarding foreign direct investment, Dr Raihan suggested removing investment barriers and improving the business environment.

"Policy-wise, India in last one year has improved significantly to facilitate new investment and the cost of doing business there has dropped significantly.

“It’s time we reevaluate existing commerce, banking, monetary and tax regulations and bring those to a level attractive to the foreign investors,” he said.
 
.
Our sole satellite turned out to be a white elephant project for us. Thanks to hasina didi and her bootlickers...
 
. .
‘REMOVE BARRIERS TO ATTRACT MORE FDIS’
His advice for the government includes reforming policies to create new jobs and incentives for small and medium enterprises.
"In the budget, the government must give special attention to micro and small enterprises and initiatives should be taken to increase investment and credit growth in the private sector,” he said.
No, the govt will keep on borrowing and wasting money on mega projects. So what? BD has become a very famous country already.

BD will become more famous when it would be unable to repay the borrowed money on time.
 
.

SANEM’s Selim Raihan wants govt to rethink mega projects

Published: June 07, 2022 12:08:13 | Updated: June 07, 2022 20:54:32

SANEM’s Selim Raihan wants govt to rethink mega projects

Dr Selim Raihan, the executive director of the South Asian Network on Economic Modeling, or SANEM, an economic think tank, has sought clear guidelines from the national budget to recover from the ongoing predicament of the economy, affected by the post-pandemic boom in demand and the inflation caused by supply inadequacy due to the Russia-Ukraine war in Europe, bdnews24.com reports.

The dual effect put Bangladesh’s economy into a spiral and the country, at this very moment, is facing a crisis, which, according to Dr Raihan, could very much push the economy into a recession, unless significant countermeasures are included in the national budget for the next fiscal.

In an interview with this news provider, highlighting inflation, volatility in the foreign exchange market, a surge in imports, and negative growth in remittances as the biggest challenges in Bangladesh’s economy now, he said: "Clear directions to recognise and address these issues must be included in the next fiscal’s national budget.”

Drawing examples from his own think tank’s calculations for the last 10/15 years, Dr Raihan said there is a difference of up to 25 per cent between the proposed budget and the implemented budget.

“The current monitoring or evaluation system to see how the national budget is being spent is very weak. As soon as the government will be able to set up a proper monitoring and analysis system, the issue of accountability and transparency will come forth.”

‘RETHINKING ABOUT MEGA PROJECTS NECESSARY’
Although at this very moment, Dr Raihan does not consider Bangladesh’s foreign debt as a “burning” matter, he is of the view that it is high time policymakers treaded cautiously moving forward.

"We need to reassess how much of this debt is being invested in the productive sectors and how much of it is bearing fruit."
As of last December’s data, Bangladesh’s foreign debt amounted to $91 billion.

Pointing toward the persisting problem of the difference between any mega project’s proposal and the reality, Dr Raihan said: “In Bangladesh, there is hardly any correlation between the feasibility study of a mega project and the reality on the ground during the implementation stage. The rise in overhead costs due to failure to meet deadlines has become a major cause for concern.”

He suggested that policymakers adapt to a new way of thinking about mega projects in the current context.

"We need to take stock of the ongoing foreign debt-based mega projects. It’s time to review what the feasibility studies say, the actual progress of the project to date, and how much things have changed.”

Admitting that the next budget cannot address all of these, he suggested the policymakers at least come up with a roadmap to undertake such reviews in future.

‘PLEASE ADMIT THERE IS A PROBLEM'
A SANEM survey before the last fiscal’s budget announcement revealed that in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, the percentage of people below the poverty level had increased from 20 per cent to nearly 40 per cent within a year.

The government categorically dismissed the data. Only recently, in some forums, Finance Minister Kamal has partially admitted the fact but insisted that the situation improved drastically since the lifting of pandemic-era restrictions.

The matter appears to be a sore subject for the University of Manchester-trained economist. The government first has to accept there is a crisis, otherwise there will be no solution,” Dr Raihan said.

The official position of the government and the analysts’ prognosis of the economy are identical at the moment as both sides have pointed out the threat of ongoing inflation and global recession, resulting in a surge in commodities prices which compounded sufferings of the middle-class.

“I highly doubt there will be any recognition of the new poor in this budget since the government did not even acknowledge them in the last one,” he said.

Dr Raihan wants a clear direction in the budget on how to bring the prices of essential commodities to a tolerable level.

He also said the budget should have guidelines on how to expand the social security programmes and allocations, which the finance minister already said that he will, and how to include those who are under new inflationary pressures.

‘REMOVE BARRIERS TO ATTRACT MORE FDIS’
His advice for the government includes reforming policies to create new jobs and incentives for small and medium enterprises.
"In the budget, the government must give special attention to micro and small enterprises and initiatives should be taken to increase investment and credit growth in the private sector,” he said.

He also said the government must find out why private sector investment is not growing. Citing the successes of India in the last year regarding foreign direct investment, Dr Raihan suggested removing investment barriers and improving the business environment.

"Policy-wise, India in last one year has improved significantly to facilitate new investment and the cost of doing business there has dropped significantly.

“It’s time we reevaluate existing commerce, banking, monetary and tax regulations and bring those to a level attractive to the foreign investors,” he said.

Another amateur talking head seeking attention!

These geniuses opposed building of nuclear power station lol

Given the current state of fossil fuel supply - Hasina proved to be Nostradamus!

Our sole satellite turned out to be a white elephant project for us. Thanks to hasina didi and her bootlickers...

You mean allowing our educational establishment access to our own satellite is foolhardy?

How else are we supposed to develop?

No, the govt will keep on borrowing and wasting money on mega projects. So what? BD has become a very famous country already.

BD will become more famous when it would be unable to repay the borrowed money on time.

You were wrong on covid and ukbengali was right.

Hence I will listen to him for now.

Your track record on predictions is pretty poor.
 
.
BD spend on infrastructure is long overdue.... cost overruns are an international fact...this is not unique to BD.

I agree we are currently treading choppy economic scenario. Every investment descision should be fully costed.

Global recession is a fairly certain. BD needs to perhaps pause on any new projects that require foreign inputs. Use funds that can be undertaken by our people completely.

There is massive scope to improve road networks, build bridges, dredge the water ways, build mini damns etc that can be done using own resources and will act to cussion the impact of global recession.
 
.
BD spend on infrastructure is long overdue.... cost overruns are an international fact...this is not unique to BD.

I agree we are currently treading choppy economic scenario. Every investment descision should be fully costed.

Global recession is a fairly certain. BD needs to perhaps pause on any new projects that require foreign inputs. Use funds that can be undertaken by our people completely.

There is massive scope to improve road networks, build bridges, dredge the water ways, build mini damns etc that can be done using own resources and will act to cussion the impact of global recession.
Although we're defenitely not on debt risk, but proper planning is important. Most of the projects in Bangladesh are transportation and energy based.

We should avoid taking any more power plants as 6-7 major plants are already in construction. 2nd nuclear plant isn't happening before 2035 anyway (if it ever sees daylight), so that's not gonna be a big problem.

I think we should go slow on the subway project unless it's built on ppp basis. The metro project should continue as it is. Of the rail projects kuakata rail and dhaka-chittagong chord line should not be delayed. And govt might shelve the bullet train project as they already declared to go slow on it. And the 5+ regional road projects shouldn't be delayed either.

Of the bridges the most important ones are chandpur-shariatpur bridge, bhola bridge and multiple small bridges in barishal divison should be priotised.
 
.
BD spend on infrastructure is long overdue.... cost overruns are an international fact...this is not unique to BD.

I agree we are currently treading choppy economic scenario. Every investment descision should be fully costed.

Global recession is a fairly certain. BD needs to perhaps pause on any new projects that require foreign inputs. Use funds that can be undertaken by our people completely.

There is massive scope to improve road networks, build bridges, dredge the water ways, build mini damns etc that can be done using own resources and will act to cussion the impact of global recession.

Every project has a feasibility study done in Bangladesh. However I think 100 crores spent on some projects (just for feasibility) was corruption (pukur-churi) on a massive scale.

You will see some AL IT-cell workers green-flag everything here, but we all know that you don't need 100 crores to do a feasibility study.

So - one major thing a feasibility study does is find out the return-on-investments (ROI) scenario. Every MBA student knows how to figure this out.

If the projects do NOT have a nice ROI factor, then why do them, spending thousands of crores (just to create avenues of graft and churi)?

I can see widening roads to facilitate flow of passenger and cargo traffic (for exports) giving nice ROI, even for long term. We should definitely support those as the net benefit is quite long term. Those are even recommended by major organizations like World Bank and IMF.

Ditto with Metro, Dhaka flyovers and expressways, and container handling facilities (road, rail, river) for export activity.

However - the questionable ones are Bangabandhu satellite, Bullet train and other frou-frou projects. I'd say money on those are and will be not well spent.
 
.
You mean allowing our educational establishment access to our own satellite is foolhardy?

How else are we supposed to develop?



Again an inability to see the bigger picture here.

Not every project will give an immediate ROI.

If every country thought like this then pretty much the modern world would not exist as we know it.

Some will take decades before it happens and the satellite gets BD into the space arena. This has already trained hundreds of BD'shis to varying degrees in this important arena.
 
.
Again an inability to see the bigger picture here.

Not every project will give an immediate ROI.

If every country thought like this then pretty much the modern world would not exist as we know it.

Some will take decades before it happens and the satellite gets BD into the space arena. This has already trained hundreds of BD'shis to varying degrees in this important arena.

Useless waste of money.

Just like Indian Mars Mission and Moon Mission.

Showcase projects.

No clear ROI scenario, nothing. What benefits have these satellite links given us so far? Watch more Star Plus?

Just another avenue for AL people to do more churi and graft.
 
.
Useless waste of money.

Just like Indian Mars Mission and Moon Mission.

Showcase projects.

No clear ROI scenario, nothing. What benefits have these satellite links given us so far? Watch more Star Plus?

Just another avenue for AL people to do more churi and graft.

It pulls talents into your academia.

Which then pulls them up the rankings. In turn generates funds for research.

Our academia is very low grade.

We need to provide them with opportunities for research.
 
.
I think you have too high a hope for the inhabitants of a country like ours... look at this event that happened earlier this week. I have no words. @bluesky bhai take a look...

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Brazil-Argentina clash in Fatullah, 20 injured​

Staff Correspondent | Banglanews24.com
Update: 2118 hours, June 8, 2022

Brazil-Argentina clash in Fatullah, 20 injured
Clashes between Brazil and Argentina supporters in Fatullah

Narayanganj: Fighting erupted between supporters of Brazil and Argentina over a football match in Fatullah, Narayanganj. At least 20 people, including the female vice chairman of Sadar Upazila Parishad, were injured.

The incident took place in Aliganj area of Fatullah on Wednesday (June 6) afternoon.

One group was led by Fatema Monir, the female vice chairman of Sadar Upazila Parishad, and the other group was led by a man named Nasir Uddin.

Witnesses said that a football match between Brazil and Argentina was held two days ago. Tensions between the two groups have been rising for two days now. The two groups clashed on Wednesday afternoon. The houses of both the groups were vandalized in repeated attacks. At that time 20 people including Fatema Monir were injured. The injured have been treated at different places.
 
.
No clear ROI scenario, nothing. What benefits have these satellite links given us so far? Watch more Star Plus?



Did you even read my post?

Hundreds of BD'shi technicians and scientists have been trained in different areas of satellite technology because of this satellite already

It also provides the following services:

"Bangabandhu 1 provides broadcasting and telecommunication services to rural areas in Bangladesh. It also supports profitable services, including direct-to-home (DTH) services."

Saving 14 million US dollars a year in satellite rental and so the cost is not as much as some assume.


Like I say look at the big picture. It takes decades to get an ROI on something like this and the other benefits like educating and inspiring the next generation of engineers and scientists cannot be quantified

Bangabandhu-2 is due for launch in 2023 and that will be a Low Earth Orbit (LEO) observation satellite. It will be tailored towards environmental monitoring, meteorology, cartography, and defence purposes.


Both satellites serve both a training and practical purpose and that is why BD was right to go ahead with them.


Next step is to get BD universities and companies involved in at least designing and manufacturing some parts of the next generation of BD satellites.
 
.
However - the questionable ones are Bangabandhu satellite, Bullet train and other frou-frou projects. I'd say money on those are and will be not well spent.
Bangabandhu 1 cost the country $248 million and the earning in the last three year period is only Tk300 Crore. It is about $11 million per year.

So, it will take 30 years to recoup the investment.

I am happy that the GoB did not listen to the great idea of @UKBengali and started building $16 billion Dhaka-Chittagong bullet train lines.

I personally do not have objections on any mega project if they are built by our own money. But, borrowing foreign flavorous Ghee to mix with smelly PantaBhat does not make economic sense.

Brazil-Argentina clash in Fatullah, 20 injured
Clashes between Brazil and Argentina supporters in Fatullah
Argentine or Brazil people do not even know where BD is located, but here our people fight for their teams. We are a very strange nation with a bottomless mind.

People should remember that it is not Dr. Kissinger who coined this Bottomless Mind. It is me who coined it.
 
Last edited:
.
We need to gradually move away from this model of govt borrowing money for infrastructure projects.
1. Increase govt revenue by punishing tax dodgers and raising personal income tax rates on the wealthy (annual income over BDT 10 million)
2. Allow foreign and local private companies to build and operate infrastructure under the BOOT model
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom