Same song sung by Korean and Chinese teams; which is better?

[fly2012]

A great song reveals true feelings from deep in your heart. For instance, the following song was written by the famous Taiwan female poet Xi Murong (席慕&#23481, who is an ethnic Mongolian who grew up in Taiwan. This is the song written after she visited Inner Mongolia for the first time. She bursted into tears when she kissed her motherland and I was into tears by the lyrics even I am not Mongolian. A great song goes beyond ethnic boundaries.

Look at those K-pop singers, one keep wonders whether they've been castrated. The "Korean" guy once boasted that Korean culture belongs to the "Siberian culture", and in true Siberian culture, these singers will probably get strangled to death.

Father's meadow mother's river by Ximurong:

 

[below_freezing]

Both sound bad, IMO.

Even in pop music category, they don't sound as good as independent artists like 徐良.

This is just my personal opinion.

[video]http://v.youku.com/v_show/id_XMjcyMDY0NzQ0.html[/video]

 

[Roybot]

Korean is definitely better. Mandarin is just not meant for singing, the words are not rhythmic

 

[NeutralCitizen]

Korean Justin Bieber terrible singing.

 

[Sonyuke_Songpaisan]

Korean wants to sieze Chinese market by using some Chinese guys. Hangen is not in the team now. he has a better future in his own market now.

 

[ImperatorDragon]

too gay. Current popular east Asian pop music are too feminine. That's the reason Korean dramas and China's own Hunan TV programs that focusing on girl contests are more and more rejected in China (together called 胡韩 Hunan-Korea), we need things that glorify nature and bravery. That's the reason I personally like ethnic Mongolian signers like Tengger and some Tibetan singers. People live in big cities don't have true feelings on nature. They are only good at sappy love songs.

Tengger's Mongolian People (In Mongolian, subtitled - Mandarin Chinese):

Tibetan Plateau by Soniam Wangmo (In Tibetan-Mandarin Chinese)

I agree with you, the best music comes from the heart, both videos are of a Korean pop band, one was dubbed with mandarin and Korean thinks it's fair to compare this way, but the song is so bad to begin with. here are some other Chinese music videos sung from the heart <3

Long live Beyond

 

[RazPaK]

prepubescent girls may like these. Real boys like vedic rock !

This sounds equally as gay dude.

---------- Post added at 09:56 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:55 PM ----------

From the videos posted, I personally like the Chinese music better. Indians can hate and suck my ****. I am merely giving my opinion.

 

[Edevelop]

The name of this thread sounds Korean anyways: "same song sung..."

 

[Korean]

Look at those K-pop singers, one keep wonders whether they've been castrated.

Yet those castrated singers sleep with 100 times more Chinese girls than you and I will in life time, so you too would want to get castrated if that gets you fame, money, and girls.

Korean wants to sieze Chinese market by using some Chinese guys. Hangen is not in the team now. he has a better future in his own market now.

Hangen is finished, he didn't seem to be doing too well the last time he was on TV. Must be having a regret leaving Super Junior now.

Henry and Zhou Mi who stayed got to tour the world including the Madison Square Garden NYC. It is in a way sad that in order for a Chinese singer to tour the world, they must work for Korean agengies since the Chinese ones can't send them.

I agree with you, the best music comes from the heart, both videos are of a Korean pop band, one was dubbed with mandarin and Korean thinks it's fair to compare this way

Exo (band) - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Xiu Min &#49884;&#50864;&#48124; Kim Min Seok &#44608;&#48124;&#49437; 176 cm March 26, 1990 (age 21) Lead Vocalist January 25, 2012
Lu Han &#47336;&#54620; Lu Han &#40575;&#26199; 178 cm April 20, 1990 (age 21) Lead Vocalist, Lead Dancer December 27, 2011
Lay &#47112;&#51060; Zhang Yi Xing &#24352;&#33402;&#20852; 179 cm October 7, 1991 (age 20) Vocalist, Main Dancer January 17, 2012
Chen &#52408; Kim Jong Dae &#44608;&#51333;&#45824; 178 cm September 21, 1992 (age 19) Main Vocalist December 29, 2011
Tao &#53440;&#50724; Huang Zi Tao &#40644;&#23376;&#38892; 183 cm May 2, 1993 (age 18) Rapper December 27, 2011

Korean version is performed by D.O and Baek Hyun. Chinese version is performed by Lu Han and Chen.

 

[ChineseTiger1986]

Those Korean type of rap musics hurt my ears, i prefer our Chinese-Korean folk dance/song, far original and better than you westernized South Koreans.

 

[below_freezing]

I predict that this band will flop, based on the extremely low amount of registered fans on Baidu forums: only 16000.

exo

There's also very few registered fans of Lee Jung Hyun: 3000.

ÀîÕêÏÍ°É_Ìù°É

Compare to the 180,000 registered fans of Zhang Jie.

ÕŽܰÉ_Ìù°É

 

[ImperatorDragon]

Yet those castrated singers sleep with 100 times more Chinese girls than you and I will in life time, so you too would want to get castrated if that gets you fame, money, and girls.

Hangen is finished, he didn't seem to be doing too well the last time he was on TV. Must be having a regret leaving Super Junior now.

Henry and Zhou Mi who stayed got to tour the world including the Madison Square Garden NYC. It is in a way sad that in order for a Chinese singer to tour the world, they must work for Korean agengies since the Chinese ones can't send them.



Exo (band) - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Xiu Min &#49884;&#50864;&#48124; Kim Min Seok &#44608;&#48124;&#49437; 176 cm March 26, 1990 (age 21) Lead Vocalist January 25, 2012
Lu Han &#47336;&#54620; Lu Han &#40575;&#26199; 178 cm April 20, 1990 (age 21) Lead Vocalist, Lead Dancer December 27, 2011
Lay &#47112;&#51060; Zhang Yi Xing &#24352;&#33402;&#20852; 179 cm October 7, 1991 (age 20) Vocalist, Main Dancer January 17, 2012
Chen &#52408; Kim Jong Dae &#44608;&#51333;&#45824; 178 cm September 21, 1992 (age 19) Main Vocalist December 29, 2011
Tao &#53440;&#50724; Huang Zi Tao &#40644;&#23376;&#38892; 183 cm May 2, 1993 (age 18) Rapper December 27, 2011

Sorry, i watched 1 minute of both videos before i have to turn it off because the music hurts my ears, anyways they both put on such heavy make up and white paste on their face that they essentially all look the same, I really don't find the K-pop trend entertaining at all.

 

[Korean]

I predict that this band will flop, based on the extremely low amount of registered fans on Baidu forums: only 16000.

16000 is not a bad start for a team that launched today.

 

[below_freezing]

16000 is not a bad start for a team that launched today.

Lee Jung Hyun isn't doing so hot (3000 registered fans) in 10 years, why would EXO be any different? The initial fanbase signs up and nothing happens afterwards.

 

[Korean]

I really don't find the K-pop trend entertaining at all.

Better get used to it.

Italian Remake

The Original

French Remake. No need to post the original on this one.

This one's quite tricky as they did wrote the song but never released it themselves and sold it to a Korean agency. They too began to perform after it took off in Asia.

The first version.

---------- Post added at 10:55 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:53 PM ----------

why would EXO be any different?

EXO is positioned as the successor of Super Junior.