Baloch Pakistani
FULL MEMBER
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2015
- Messages
- 760
- Reaction score
- 0
- Country
- Location
Brother your approach as to what is bid'ah or not is a bit off. First of all, as I imagine that you are a well informed person and when we speak about innovation in religion, it is innovation in religious matters opposed to using mobile phone or driving a car which is a baseless argument. The religion has been sealed since the time of the prophet and no new things can be introduced in 'religion'. We follow the example of the prophet and then the example of the rightly guided companions.
Secondly, the answer to your question is Yes it is an innovation or Bid'ah to touch Ka'baa or kiss it in order to seek closeness to Allah especially during tawaf. This is not proven by the prophet or his companions and whatever has been left in ibada by him should be left as well. He was the best of the people and he didnt do it was a proper sign to avoid it as well. The prophet only touched the yemeni corner and the black stone during tawaf and this is what is proven from him. Tawaf is part of Ibada and a matter of religion to which we cannot add anything without the consequence being added to it as well. If someone cannot touch it due to the issues these days is excused from it as we know the consequence to it and is excusable.
As for kissing the maqam e Ebrahim box is also an innovation and not even a part of religion. Cannot even be considered as a good deed and a useless thing to do. The prophet avoided any and everything from which shaitaan can find ways to distract a muslim unless he starts worshipping the Ka'baa instead of Allah and the foot marks of Ebrahim instead of sunnah of the prophet.
Lastly, the concept of reciting fatiha on graves is an innovation in itself. If you would know the meaning of what you are reciting over the graves you will never do that. When you recite fatiha you are asking for yourself instead. Visiting graves is a good thing it softens the heart and reminds one of death and there is also no harm in praying from Allah for the forgiveness of the person whether it be at home or anywhere. But reciting fatiha is neither proved from the sunnah of the prophet or the companions nor it makes any sense if you have a little knowledge of Arabic and Quran.
1. If the religion was sealed by Muhammad SAW then who gave the authority to our second calif to start tarawih prayer in mosque since Prophet SAW stopped performing it in mosque and started it in his house alone. He offered 13 rakats then no one pray even one rakat more or one rakat less otherwise its bidat.
2. If the religion was sealed then who gave the right to Hazrat Umar RA to give 80 lashes to a drinker since Prophet SAW gave just 40 lashes, is not also bidat. Saudi government just gave 350 lashes to a guy for that thing.
3. If i touch kabaa or maqam e ibrahim then you are saying that that guy who stood there by the authority of saudis to call me a Mushrik? He called haram haram shirk shirk. Just prove me that doing so is shirk or haram since i touched it when i was not even performing tawaf or umrah. And who told them i am touching it as a aqeedat or am i touching it as sawab? Do they read minds and hearts and then call shirk shirk to me? Does have that right to call me mushrik for touching that box?
You go and first do research before talking thrash I am no lover of Yazeed but I bother to do research not act like people like you. Several Sahabas had done bait of Yazeed he wasn' t that corrupt as promoted and lied about. So bother to do research before talking. Mr as for Yazeed I don't weather he would be in heaven or not but he was part of that lashkar who Hazoor SAW predicted would go to heaven. The laskar which attacked contastinople .Many do if you don't know that I can do nothing about that many start asking Kaba to reward them . What you think those who do Sajdas to grave here won't do this . Those bidat the bidat which is worse than known sins and leads to hell calling Wahabis who follow nothing but Quran and Sunnah is is irony and shows ignorance of those calling wahabi idiots. But those following bidat will keep defending bidat and Haram @Baloch Pakistani
If bidah is bidah then call hazrat umar too as bidati (Nauzubillah) who gave 80 lashes.
Answer to that false hadith the aqeeda of wahabis. Molana ishaq is Ahle hadith.