Reasons Why PTI lost in Karachi - Facts

[Ssan]

This is where you are wrong. PTI and JI together can do a lot now.

KMC will be under PTI and JI if they become ally.

PPP and all have less number for kmc together

total need 184 and pti and ji together have 193 so they can form mayor and have KMC under them.

Let’s say they get the KMC- what can KMC do with provincial govt?

 

[AZ1]

Let’s say they get the KMC- what can KMC do with provincial govt?

all comes under under kmc and many town offices with JI

Departments

 

[AgNoStiC MuSliM]

I can post video of PPP working in my area just 2 days before the election.

What constitutional mechanism allows the PTI to ‘work’ in a province where they do not have control of either local governments or provincial governments?

Are you suggesting that the PTI (before it was removed from the Federal Government) should have allocated Federal development funds to the PTI MNA’s elected from Karachi?

That (development funds handed out to MNA’s/MPA’s) is a policy I strongly disagree with since it opens the potential for abuse and then you’ll have every MNA/MPA demanding the same.

Additionally, even if the Federal Govt allocated funds to MNA’s, do they need the Sindh provincial government to agree and authorize initiation of projects and spending?

 

[Ssan]

all comes under under kmc and many town offices with JI

Departments

Sorry typo- what can KMC do without he provincial govt?

 

[AZ1]

What constitutional mechanism allows the PTI to ‘work’ in a province where they do not have control of either local governments or provincial governments?

Are you suggesting that the PTI (before it was removed from the Federal Government) should have allocated Federal development funds to the PTI MNA’s elected from Karachi?

That (development funds handed out to MNA’s/MPA’s) is a policy I strongly disagree with since it opens the potential for abuse and then you’ll have every MNA/MPA demanding the same.

Additionally, even if the Federal Govt allocated funds to MNA’s, do they need the Sindh provincial government to agree and authorize initiation of projects and spending?

I understand that pti didnt have authority 18th amendment and sont know the reason of not imposing governor rule when they could but JI didnt have that either but they did work too from their political funds, they active political workers and fix small issues, raise voiced on karachities common issue.

They opened office by having 120 sq yard house inside every small city while PTI office is far away and pti workers are mostly ghair mokami too.

For localbodies, they should have local people come forward, give them funds from their own party to fix the issues. Check this and then leadership in karachi

https://twitter.com/x/status/1615375172214603779

Sorry typo- what can KMC do without he provincial govt?

Roads, sewerage, bridges monitor and maintenancd etc. Provincial govt will have to provide funds no matter what otherwise it will go on court, protest etc

 

[AZ1]

ہماری دو سیٹیں واپس آگئیں سات کا انتظار ہے۔ ہماری بات ثابت ہوگئ کہ ہم جائز بات کررہےہیں۔ آراوز سے نتائج جاری کروادیں ہم بات چیت شروع کردینگے۔ میئر تو... | By JI Karachi Media Cell | Facebook

40K views, 1.5K likes, 289 loves, 65 comments, 533 shares, Facebook Watch Videos from JI Karachi Media Cell: ہماری دو سیٹیں واپس آگئیں سات کا انتظار ہے۔ ہماری بات ثابت ہوگئ کہ ہم جائز بات کررہےہیں۔...

fb.watch

 

[SIPRA]

We, as a nation, don't deserve a leader like IK. Criminals like Sharifs, Zardaris, Altafs etc. etc. are most appropriate for us.

 

[N.Siddiqui]

This is where you are wrong. PTI and JI together can do a lot now.

KMC will be under PTI and JI if they become ally.

PPP and all have less number for kmc together

total need 184 and pti and ji together have 193 so they can form mayor and have KMC under them.

Even if the JI and PTI selects the Mayor and deputy mayor and heads the local govt., The PPP govt in Sindh with Zardari mafia calling the shots and PMLN/PDM at the center, the development funds for the Karachi city will be hard to come by, and they will be curtailed or stopped.

 

[AZ1]

Even if the JI and PTI selects the Mayor and deputy mayor and heads the local govt., The PPP govt in Sindh with Zardari mafia calling the shots and PMLN/PDM at the center, the development funds for the Karachi city will be hard to come by, and they will be curtailed or stopped.

then JI will do what needs to be done along with PTI. PDM at the center right now but for how long? already punjab and kpk assembly dismissed total 500 seats vacant so how long it will take for general election to be called i think matter of weeks or few months.

 

[fitpOsitive]

So localbodes elections are completed and result is expected as i already predicted.
You can see PTI supporters overseas and other part of pakistan are angry on karachities to why they didnt vote for PTI in this election. Here are the reasons based on facts and anyone who living in karachi will admit this.

PPP Rigged the election there is no doubt and 30% of voters area changed or lost they couldn't even vote. Vote of pti went to Jamat Islami. Because whenever people of karachi ask PTI they said they don't have rights due to 18th amendment and no proper local party structure.



- In 4 years of PTI era what karachities got from pti despite full support to PTI without even their campaign in 2018

PM announces Rs1.1 trillion 'historic' package for Karachi's transformation

Federal and Sindh governments decided to deal with Karachi's problems "together" following negotiations, says PM.

www.dawn.com

Minister says over 60% of Karachi's Rs1.1 trillion transformation package from central budget

ISLAMABAD: Planning and Development Minister Asad Umar said on Sunday that 62 percent of Karachi's Rs1.1 trillion development package will come from the central budget, a day after opposition Pakistan People's Party (PPP) chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari alleged that the provincial government...

www.arabnews.pk

Asad shares funds detail for Karachi uplift projects

ISLAMABAD: Sharing the details of funds to be spent on Karachi uplift projects under the Karachi Transformation Plan, Planning and Development Minister Asad Umar said on Monday that Rs46 billion have

profit.pakistantoday.com.pk

Local work 1 time in 4 years

Pti work in karachi #PTI #ImranKhan #BehindYouSkipper #PTIMediaCellTeam #PTICentralKHI PTI Media Cell PTI Karachi | By GeoSiasat | Facebook

Pti work in karachi #PTI #ImranKhan #BehindYouSkipper #PTIMediaCellTeam #PTICentralKHI PTI Media Cell PTI Karachi

fb.watch

Only one time MPA visited my area and that is on Nov 2021 and after that till today no visit nada nothing no where to be found.





While PPP has done this according to one of the jiyala spreading this to get votes


1- peoples bus service started
2 - Orangi line about to start
3- 1122 operational
4- rehabilitation and renovation of double road from Qayumabad to Baloch Pull soon
4- underpass under construction at Johar chorangi
5-Rehabilitation of Mewa shah graveyard road and surrounding area soon
6- Improvement of Roads from MA Jinnah road to I I Chandrigarh road
7- Street lights of Mai Kolachi road
8- Development at Gizri football ground
9- Development at Kakri ground Lyari
10- Renovation of Landi kotal chorangi to 5 star chorangi
11- Malir Expressway under construction
12- Rehabilitation of Jahangir road
13- Rehabilitation of city railway station bridge
14- 13km road from Machli chowk to kannap under construction
15-3rd Autism rehabilitation Center in Korangi
16- KMDC will be University
17- rehabilitation of Empress market
18- Rehabilitation of Mir Karam Ali Talpur road
19- Development of Shahr e Noor Jahan district central
20- Food street at Boat Basin
21- 4 Parks in Clifton block 5
22- Rehabilitation of road outside Jinnah hospital
23- Rehabilitation of roads outside civil hospital
24- Renovation of bridge Sir Shah Suleman road,east
25- Reconstruction of 1600 & 9000 road in Korangi
26- construction of linar park
27- Development of Pahari ground and family park in Korangi
28- Construction of Abshar Park ,Shaheen Park ,Madina Park ,Library ,football ground ,cricket ground in Malir
29- Solid waste Management operational in Korangi and Central
30- construction of Ibrahim Hyderi and Majuhid Baloch football grounds, construction of road Omer colony to Korangi creek
31- development of Beautiful road from Gul bai to Hawksbay beach
32- construction of Chakiwara road
33- construction of Mehran highway Malir
34- construction of sports complex star ground,Benazir Bhutto family Park,road connecting to star ground Sherpao colony Malir
35- Construction of road Hamdard university to Surjani
36- 17 new road in SITE area
37- Construction of Maulana Shaukat Ali road Orangi town
38- BRT red line under construction From Malir halt to Numaish
39- 5 acre Ama Nasima Park developed adjacent to Lyari expressway
40- reconstruction of Johar road connecting Tipu Sultan with Ameer khusro
41- construction of Metrovell road ,district west
42- Rehabilitation of road from UBL sports complex to Piyala hotel central district
43- Rehabilitation of burns garden
44- Rehabilitation of Amjad Sabri underpass
45- Rehabilitation of Bagh e Rustum
46- Reconstruction of Ziauddin road to Shah Wali Ullah road 5.5km
47- Rehabilitation of Nazimabad underpass
48- construction of Yusuf Ludhyani road G.Johar and road carpeting bridge view apartments
49- Rehabilitation of Qaddafi town bridge
50- Construction of Manora Beach
51- Rehabilitation of Jheel Park
52- Rehabilitation of terrace garden Shah Rasool colony
53- Improvement of kidney Hill Park
54- Rehabilitation of dual carriageway from kalaboard to Saudabad chorangi
55-Development of RCD ground and open public space in Malir
56- Deena Mistri urban forest Clifton
57- Development of Shaheed Abdul Rind community Center Lyari
58- construction of karbala road kiamari
59- Construction of road from Babe Khyber to Hazara chowk district west
60 - Development of Ghulam Muhammad Marwat family park Lyari
Road carpeting in different districts
East - 36
South - 10
Central - 22
Korangi/Malir - 12
District west -13
Bridge/underpass - 10
Over all Parks Renovated and Inaugurated
DMC central -30 Parks
DMC south -13 Parks
KMC overall - 15 Parks


Till Last day of local body election they kept on working.


Still people of karachi rejected PPP and PTI still getting votes and if PTI wants to win from karachi they need proper local structure otherwise they will not win.

Whats your opinion about this.
@Areesh @PaklovesTurkiye @fitpOsitive



Everyperson who are bashing on social media about karachi giving votes to Jamat Islami should given these answers to them.

Why PTI lost in karachi? Because PTI did the same as Ppp or noon league, i.e brought non local people. All sorts of cheemas, butts, kakars were their candidates. I mean the PTIs approach towards local population is more dangerous. PTI just want support from us, but we are equally bad for them.

PTI used us.

 

[S.Y.A]

What constitutional mechanism allows the PTI to ‘work’ in a province where they do not have control of either local governments or provincial governments?

Are you suggesting that the PTI (before it was removed from the Federal Government) should have allocated Federal development funds to the PTI MNA’s elected from Karachi?

That (development funds handed out to MNA’s/MPA’s) is a policy I strongly disagree with since it opens the potential for abuse and then you’ll have every MNA/MPA demanding the same.

Additionally, even if the Federal Govt allocated funds to MNA’s, do they need the Sindh provincial government to agree and authorize initiation of projects and spending?

agreed, but the thing is that PTI could still have launched federal funded PSDPs, which they failed to do.

a lot of PTI MNAs, and MPAs live in DHA/clifton, and never once visited their constituencies (mostly middle and lower middle income areas). imran ali shah, from district central, just used to arrive twice a year to offer eid prayers in his land cruiser, and then used to speed away to his house in KDA-1. the only PTI guy living among the people was Alamgir Khan.

they could have at least protested for Khi (electricity issues, encroachments, infra etc.), they didnt even do that.

 

[AZ1]

Why they cant make fixit type office every other city in karachi?

 

[S.Y.A]

Why they cant make fixit type office every other city in karachi?

because fixit is/was supposed to be apolitical. rest of the PTI guys simply dont care as they are enjoying life in their bungalows and land cruisers.

 

[fatman17]

Rigging of elections is a PPP DNA since the days of ZAB. It will not change.

 

[AZ1]

You lost me at PPP's contribution. lol

Agar PPP ne ye saari khidmat ki he karachi ki, like you said, to phir karachi ki gaa*d kis ne mari he?

Corruption is in ppp blood now

https://www.facebook.com/video.php?v=905793924109234