Rani Padmini and four other Hindutva history myths exploded

[Jayanta]

I was expecting some real mind blowing revelation....all I read was some mental masturbation. I would expect some sort of reference... at least one published in one of the low ranking journals somewhere. The tall claims with no reference is like me standing and declaring that sun rotates around the earth....I say so because....if the earth was spinning people would be flying around.

 

[MULUBJA]

There is nothing in article which proves story of Padmin either false or anything otherwise.

 

[Levina]

The first person to discover this language family, William Jones, suggested back in 1786 that Sanskrit, Latin and Greek, “have sprung from some common source, which, perhaps, no longer exists”. He was exactly right. That source is now called proto-Indo-European, and is considered to have been spoken in the vicinity of the Black Sea around 5,500 to 6,000 years ago.
In India, though, the idea is anathema that an ancestor of Sanskrit was spoken by pastoral nomads living in what is modern-day Turkey and Ukraine. For that would make Sanskrit essentially a language like many others. Which is what it is.

I speak and understand many Indian languages and I find sanskrit very close to Tamil and malayalam. This comes from my personal experience. And no matter how many sources (from world wide web) are presented to me I would have a tough time accepting it any other way.
If it was true that sanskrit is a close cousin of a proto-Indo-European language then why do the other european languages (other than German) dont have anything in common???

 

[jamahir]

India is a 5000 years old civilization .It is proven by tons of evidence.

when you say that, please discount hinduism.

I was expecting some real mind blowing revelation....all I read was some mental masturbation.

don't use that phrase if you don't want to be taken as delusional and rude... 2017 will bring the 100th anniversary of the russian revolution... would you use your phrase for the beginnings of even this too?? or for islam or for prophet jesus or for buddha for far away to any preacher and prophet??

like any reactionary and regressive, rss and the entire sangh cannot string together a coherent and sensible sentence... no society in the world accepts the blatherings of these theocratic/capitalist anti-humans nor do they have a universal ideology ( which is why they stick to bharat ).

why do you want to stand beside these prime fools??

 

[pakdefender]

India is a big fake myth , even the PM is deluded when he says that indians did plastic surgery to attach elephant trunk to man's nose and make their god ganesh , that's just crazy stuff

 

[WAR-rior]

India is a big fake myth , even the PM is deluded when he says that indians did plastic surgery to attach elephant trunk to man's nose and make their god ganesh , that's just crazy stuff

We don't expect you to believe our understand facts. After all you are a kaum who believe that invaders were saviours. Such destructive effect on your mentality by those brutal massacre and rape that any understanding of local history and facts based on archaeology and documents is unexpected of Pakistanis. It's better you try to be arabs for next coming centuries.

 

[Jayanta]

when you say that, please discount hinduism.
don't use that phrase if you don't want to be taken as delusional and rude... 2017 will bring the 100th anniversary of the russian revolution... would you use your phrase for the beginnings of even this too?? or for islam or for prophet jesus or for buddha for far away to any preacher and prophet??

like any reactionary and regressive, rss and the entire sangh cannot string together a coherent and sensible sentence... no society in the world accepts the blatherings of these theocratic/capitalist anti-humans nor do they have a universal ideology ( which is why they stick to bharat ).

why do you want to stand beside these prime fools??

Neither am I delusional nor am I rude. I comment on merit of the article. Any article related to science or history is based on something called as "EVIDENCE"....if you want something to be taken seriously, you should get it published and site proper references. The article was filled with claims....but had no evidence to substantiate the claims.

As far as Abrahamic religion is concerned the notion that...a PERFECT human be it Jesus, Prophet Muhammad etc. wrote a PERFECT book 2000 years back....that should be followed blindly without QUESTIONING or REVISION is something I call DELUSIONAL.
1. There are no perfect HUMAN.
2. There is no perfect book...all books needs revision with time.
3. One should be able to think rationally and be able to question what he is doing and why??

 

[Rau]

I speak and understand many Indian languages and I find sanskrit very close to Tamil and malayalam. This comes from my personal experience. And no matter how many sources (from world wide web) are presented to me I would have a tough time accepting it any other way.
If it was true that sanskrit is a close cousin of a proto-Indo-European language then why do the other european languages (other than German) dont have anything in common???

Even after one year its hard for me pronounce Tamil...though I know Sanskrit.
About OP he is completely delusional...I don't think in his whole life he read Sanskrit...grammar of Sanskrit too much perfect considering time its evolved..no other European language can came nearer to it..

 

[Styx]

article dated Dec 31, 2014, looks like the PDF management's bot is getting desperate.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

To explode a myth, you need to present a counter narrative ,and back it up with facts.

All I see here is raving and ranting of a compulsive madman, who shouts liar liar at people he does not agree with (Kejariwal effect anyone?) from online marxist brothel named scroll.in . It is a weblog pretty much like Defence.pk, and has even lower quality than this site.


I do not understand why Omidyar media investment has not got same treatment as Ford foundation. This media investment group has a reputation of providing seed capital to ultra-left group worldwide to start their drivel mill.

Don't know why BJP idiots are never proactive and only wakes up when damage is already done by foreign funded NGOs?

Girish Sahane is an Islamist Marxist. Check the rest of his posts. Extremely interesting.

 

[Rau]

@levina what is obssetion of tamil people regarding long name like "Mundagakanniamman Koil" station ....How to pronounce it....I tried three but before I could pronounce local always moves away...

 

[wolfschanzze]

when you say that, please discount hinduism.



don't use that phrase if you don't want to be taken as delusional and rude... 2017 will bring the 100th anniversary of the russian revolution... would you use your phrase for the beginnings of even this too?? or for islam or for prophet jesus or for buddha for far away to any preacher and prophet??

like any reactionary and regressive, rss and the entire sangh cannot string together a coherent and sensible sentence... no society in the world accepts the blatherings of these theocratic/capitalist anti-humans nor do they have a universal ideology ( which is why they stick to bharat ).

why do you want to stand beside these prime fools??

Started your communist mental Masturbation already?

 

[SrNair]

when you say that, please discount hinduism.



don't use that phrase if you don't want to be taken as delusional and rude... 2017 will bring the 100th anniversary of the russian revolution... would you use your phrase for the beginnings of even this too?? or for islam or for prophet jesus or for buddha for far away to any preacher and prophet??

like any reactionary and regressive, rss and the entire sangh cannot string together a coherent and sensible sentence... no society in the world accepts the blatherings of these theocratic/capitalist anti-humans nor do they have a universal ideology ( which is why they stick to bharat ).

why do you want to stand beside these prime fools??

Dont need that.It was also a primitive Hinduism.

 

[Levina]

@levina what is obssetion of tamil people regarding long name like "Mundagakanniamman Koil" station ....How to pronounce it....I tried three but before I could pronounce local always moves away...

Yudhistra, Dronacharya, Suyodhan, Aashritha etc are no easy names either.
Each name has a meaning and many names are a combination of 2 words. (Mungakanni + Amman where Amman should mean a relation usually uncle). And since you're not used to pronouncing tongue twisting words, you would find it difficult to pronounce it. And it's fine. I'm sure when I go to China and when France I might face the same issue.
Btw the name you have posted seems to be a place, koil means a place/house or something to that effect.

 

[Rau]

Yudhistra, Dronacharya, Suyodhan, Aashritha etc are no easy names either.
Each name has a meaning and many names are a combination of 2 words. (Mungakanni + Amman where Amman should mean a relation usually uncle). And since you're not used to pronouncing tongue twisting words, you would find it difficult to pronounce it. And it's fine. I'm sure when I go to China and when France I might face the same issue.
Btw the name you have posted seems to be a place, koil means a place/house or something to that effect.

Its a Chennai local train stop after Chennai beach...which stuck for years on name issue....tongue twisting...initially it looks I enroll for tongue twisting competition,its really hard pronounce it....Tamil is way different than Marathi..