What's new

Ramdev keen to introduce yoga in Pakistan

mjnaushad...best answer to mr. sirius
....

No one is disputing that prayer is good for the body and mind. What you have stated is true for any religion or any prayer. I guess people were asking you for references of Namaz or prayer being "better" than yoga. I have not done a lot of it, but Yoga has a lot of specific medical benefits. Ramdev has his critics and skeptics, but that does not mean Yoga is unscientific or harmful. In contrast, prayers are more generic and for overall well-being and peace.

You god, religion or faith is not going to diminish because of your decision to practice yoga. Similarly, yoga is not going to diminish if you choose not to.
 
.

I see no harm in practicing it as long as you're not indulging in repeating verses associated with Hinduism

Actually, from what I have seen, one does not utter mantras while doing Yoga. The only word that one utters is "Om" (anglicized as 'Aum')

A t-shirt I love to wear often:


It may surprise you that though OM has ancient Hindu roots, it is thought to signify the one and only "Being". Some thing for thought.
Aum is commonly pronounced as a long or over-long nasalized close-mid back rounded vowel, [õːː]) though there are other enunciations pronounced in received traditions. It is placed at the beginning of most Hindu texts as a sacred exclamation to be uttered at the beginning and end of a reading of the Vedas or previously to any prayer or mantra. The Mandukya Upanishad is entirely devoted to the explanation of the syllable. The syllable is taken to consist of three phonemes, a, u and m, variously symbolizing the Three Vedas or the Hindu Trimurti or three stages in life ( birth, life and death ). Though ostensibly in some traditions it is polysyllabic and vocalized as a triphthong, the Omkara is held to move through and contain all vowels possible in human speech.[citation needed]. One important version has five components, flowing from h through a, u, oo to m.
The name Omkara, (Sanskrit: the syllable om) is taken as a name of God in the Hindu revivalist Arya Samaj. Similarly, the concept of om, called onkar in Punjabi, is found in Sikh theology as a symbol of God. It invariably emphasizes God's singularity, expressed as Ek Onkar ("One Omkara" or "The Aum is One"), stating that the multiplicity of existence symbolized in the aum syllable is really founded in a singular God.[1]
 
. .
It is even more stupid if one responds without reading properly.
Sirius is clearly asking luftwaffe, links which support his claim that Namaz is better than Yoga.

And some People are so much blinded by hate that they fail to realize that NAMAZ is not a Material thing for which you will find links for Comparison with something else.
 
.
I'm disappointed that pakistanis don't even know about whether yoga is allowed or not in pak -just for the record yoga is NOT banned in pakistan at all nor does anyone have a problem with it or tried to ban it infact there is often even yoga shows and segments on pakistani tv on major mainstream programmes and networks it's simply seen as a healthy form of exercise with no religious connotations.Pakistan in my opinions is intolerant in general but is still nowhere near as intolerant as indians like to believe it is.Yoga on pakistani tv :


http://yogiwajahat.net/indusyoga.html


 
Last edited by a moderator:
. .
If a Muslim pray five times a day with all the Sunnah and Nafil Rakats then no other exerciser needed to maintain a healthy life style. :tup:

If some one into intense training then I recommend martial art(Taekowndo, hapkido) with weight training otherwise those interested in meditation is better of with tai chi over yoga. :tup:

Ramdev character look very unpleasant. :tdown:
 
.
If a Muslim pray five times a day with all the Sunnah and Nafil Rakats then no other exerciser needed to maintain a healthy life style. :tup:

If some one into intense training then I recommend martial art(Taekowndo, hapkido) with weight training otherwise those interested in meditation is better of with tai chi over yoga. :tup:

Ramdev character look very unpleasant. :tdown:

I find this argument always pointless and ultimately fallacious. These views are entirely based on the fact that yoga originated in ancient India and is regarded by many as "Hindu" and denouncing it completely requires such justifications.

Religious prayers have their very own, unique and separate space and life and the exercise it provides can be soothing to many. Yoga is aimed at mental and physical relaxation and not aimed at teaching self defense. By viewing yoga inherently "Hindu", many people, like you, denounce it completely as unrequired. Had martial arts originated in India, you people would have claimed that they too were unnecessary.
 
.
.
If a Muslim pray five times a day with all the Sunnah and Nafil Rakats then no other exerciser needed to maintain a healthy life style. :tup:

If some one into intense training then I recommend martial art(Taekowndo, hapkido) with weight training otherwise those interested in meditation is better of with tai chi over yoga. :tup:

Ramdev character look very unpleasant. :tdown:

You have a valid point exercise-wise. But if this is for religious reasons, I hope you know martial arts were invented in India and most of these martial arts have Buddhist origins in the art of weaponless self-defense.
 
.
You have a valid point exercise-wise. But if this is for religious reasons, I hope you know martial arts were invented in India and most of these martial arts have Buddhist origins in the art of weaponless self-defense.

It is my understanding that all religions have a common origin either Hindu or Pre-Hindu and no wonder beliefs are so similar. If you read the link pasted above it shows the similarity between namaz and yoga.

It doesnt mean that they are linked directly but that opposition to yoga or any such wellness procedures or other philosophies have more to do with petty thinking window dressed as fundamentalism. The point isnt about Yoga but about its opposition on flimsy grounds.
 
.

He wasn't referring to all Kashmiris, but only to the small minority that supports violence.

But yes, his view is not correct - it is not genetics, but extremist indoctrination that is the cause of their behavior.
 
.
As a Hindu I find that persons such as Swami Ramdev who want to popularise yoga etc are indeed committing an unnecessary act. Yoga is indeed a Hindu spiritual act and without the mantras such as "OM" it is really pointless pursuing yoga. The movements of facing the east and paying penance to the sun is all important in the body purification process. I accordingly support the fatwa against yoga and hope that Muslims will refrain from practising a Hindu spiritual act as imo it does go against the teachings of Islam. I will likewise be offended if I was asked to perform namaaz at my sathsang or next temple prayer.

I however plan on taking Swami Ramdev's mission one step further. I plan on personally exhibiting and teaching women the important steps depicted in a very important book of Indian origin. Unlike Swami Ramdev, my services will be free and I am certain universally accepted. That book is called the Kama Sutra and involves much more bodily exercises than the yoga moves. Watch the internet for postings of my worldwide mission to promote these various exercises :azn::azn:
 
.
As a Hindu I find that persons such as Swami Ramdev who want to popularise yoga etc are indeed committing an unnecessary act. Yoga is indeed a Hindu spiritual act and without the mantras such as "OM" it is really pointless pursuing yoga. The movements of facing the east and paying penance to the sun is all important in the body purification process. I accordingly support the fatwa against yoga and hope that Muslims will refrain from practising a Hindu spiritual act as imo it does go against the teachings of Islam. I will likewise be offended if I was asked to perform namaaz at my sathsang or next temple prayer.

I however plan on taking Swami Ramdev's mission one step further. I plan on personally exhibiting and teaching women the important steps depicted in a very important book of Indian origin. Unlike Swami Ramdev, my services will be free and I am certain universally accepted. That book is called the Kama Sutra and involves much more bodily exercises than the yoga moves. Watch the internet for postings of my worldwide mission to promote these various exercises :azn::azn:


After this you may be universally accepted..but i doubt you will be accepted in your house?? :azn:
 
.
After this you may be universally accepted..but i doubt you will be accepted in your house?? :azn:

I know yaar. Hence my aim is to pack my bags and live like a Swami with a few bodyguards [to protect me against my wife] :rofl::rofl:
 
.
Back
Top Bottom