Ram Mandir in Ayodhya

[Indischer]

Understanding Dharma and Abiding by Dharma is TWO DIFFERENT things. I know of only ONE person who did EVERYTHING by Dharma and that is Sr. Ramchndra ji who's temple we are discussing.

Then there was DharmRaj Yudhistir who did everything as per dharma except speak one lie. There was Raja Harishchandra etc.

The world always had "staggering shades". Right from the days of Sri. Ram till the days of Sri. Rahul Gandhi ........... only thing that has not changed is Dharma. That has remained almost constant all this time.

Demolishing the Mosque without offering an alternative was wrong, which is why the effort is on to provide them with one in a different place. However it was done ONLY after prolonged negotiations which gave no result. It was the muslims who delayed the building of new mosque by indulging in litigation which funnily enough strengthened the Hindu case.

This is the third time I am answering the same question. Next time read all my answers again if you have any more questions.


As to the question of who is the arbitrator of Dharma in Hinduism, its the Shankaracharya. Or you can refer it back to you own Guru if you have one. But I guess you use you imagination and wikipedia

Your reply seems to assume that Muslims are wrong for protesting about the demolition of their mosque. Don't agree with that notion either. But you have every right to your opinion, and they're none of my business.

As for the bold part, don't be so sure. In spite of there being many Shankaracharyas from various major and minor peethas, lots of Hindus in my part of the woods also consult the Dharmadhikari of Dharmasthala, who happens to be a Jain.

 

[DesiGuy]

It is not just hinduguy, it is every secular on this thread who opposes Ram Mandir in service of Islam and secularism. These are the people who have been made to eat their hats in every single term. From their hatred of Hindutva to their hatred of the mass murderer Modi to their hatred of Ram Mandir or their support for the Aam Admi Party and Kejriwal as the new messiah, every single verdict in India has gone against them and what they stand for. India keeps turning more and more Hindu every single day and these guys are exposed and ridiculed and shamed for what they stood for.

Nowadays these Sickulars are claiming Modi as the champion of secularism. From that @Ravi Nair who assures people that Modi is going to disappoint his bhakts to the seculars on this thread who seek to assure Muslims that Modi is opposed to the temple building. These are dickheads who will never learn and no one should expect them to ever learn.

The only solution is to send all of these "secular" to one of muslims nations and see if they still stick to their secular views. If they do, they are indeed seculars...and if don't...they are bunch of cowards hiding behind secularism.

(I already know the answer)

 

[possumlot]

lolz... where does so much anger come from..
you will cool down once you get kids...

Where does the gumption for such brazen lies come from ? ........ you will stop lying once you stop being a kid and grow up.

 

[livingdead]

Where does the gumption for such brazen lies come from ? ........ you will stop lying once you stop being a kid and grow up.

i dont lie..
i recognize you now.. you were banned twice at least.. cant remember ids...

 

[Indischer]

The only solution is to send all of these "secular" to one of muslims nations and see if they still stick to their secular views. If they do, they are indeed seculars...and if don't...they are bunch of cowards hiding behind secularism.

If only someone really sponsored this trip. But alas, nobody wants to conduct such good experiments these days.

 

[possumlot]

Your reply seems to assume that Muslims are wrong for protesting about the demolition of their mosque. Don't agree with that notion either. But you have every right to your opinion, and they're none of my business.

Wow ....at least you had the decency to use the word "assume" before spinning this strawman.

As for the bold part, don't be so sure. In spite of there being many Shankaracharyas from various major and minor peethas, lots of Hindus in my part of the woods also consult the Dharmadhikari of Dharmasthala, who happens to be a Jain.

I don't think there would be much difference between what the Shankracharya would say and what the Dharmadhikari would say on Dharma and Righteousness, as far as normal living is concerned. They would only differ on religious practices.

Value systems between most Dharmic religions is very similar for most parts.

 

[DesiGuy]

If only someone really sponsored this trip. But alas, nobody wants to conduct such good experiments these days.

how many you think will volunteer...before they come with their bloody excuses? such as family responsibilities, etc..?

These people are more danger to their own's than themselves. Lets hope BJP ensures that none of them is put into lead role for India...for the next 20 years.

 

[abjktu]

lolz... where does so much anger come from..
you will cool down once you get kids...

same with Christian nuns..Some times their anger seems inhuman...

 

[Indrani]

The only solution is to send all of these "secular" to one of muslims nations and see if they still stick to their secular views. If they do, they are indeed seculars...and if don't...they are bunch of cowards hiding behind secularism.

There is nothing secular about these guys, there never was. They are cowards and have always been cowards.

 

[livingdead]

same with Christian nuns..Some times their anger seems inhuman...

hain? were you abused in catholic school

 

[Indischer]

Wow ....at least you had the decency to use the word "assume" before spinning this strawman.



I don't think there would be much difference between what the Shankracharya would say and what the Dharmadhikari would say on Dharma and Righteousness, as far as normal living is concerned. They would only differ on religious practices.

Value systems between most Dharmic religions is very similar for most parts.

Thanks for the clarification. I'm glad that you don't think the Muslims were wrong in protesting the destruction of their mosque.

I didn't say there would be much difference between their counsel. Just that Shankaracharyas aren't the sole arbiters on Dharma, in Malnad and coastal Karnataka at least. The Lingayats and Kurubas too consult seers of their respective Mathas on such matters. So there are multiple sources for arbitration.

 

[abjktu]

hain? were you abused in catholic school

i know...
My aunt is a nun....hehe....

 

[Tridibans]

The only solution is to send all of these "secular" to one of muslims nations and see if they still stick to their secular views. If they do, they are indeed seculars...and if don't...they are bunch of cowards hiding behind secularism.

(I already know the answer)

Well we are a nation of one billion plus people. I don't mind the sickulars as there are bound to be some rotten apples in a full basket. I am happy that atleast most of the nation is now aware of these extremists and these so called self appointed secularists (Teesta seetalvad, Burkha dutt, etc.). Look at the comments section of any news related to these acts in the past few months. Most have realised the pseudo-secularism of Congress and caste based parties.

I was very sckeptical of BJP but to tell you the truth, they DID manage to win majority and that means a lot in a democracy so fragmented as India.

hain? were you abused in catholic school

Its very easy to judge sitting at far away places my friend. You may have your pov but seems more often than not you outright dismiss these allegations as right wing Hindutva.

 

[Indischer]

how many you think will volunteer...before they come with their bloody excuses? such as family responsibilities, etc..?

These people are more danger to their own's than themselves. Lets hope BJP ensures that none of them is put into lead role for India...for the next 20 years.

I can't speak for anyone else, but I'd definitely volunteer if someone were to take care of expenses. Life is all about experiences, some good, some bad, some ugly. A good story is the only reward of a life well-spent.

 

[Indrani]

Where does the gumption for such brazen lies come from ? ........ you will stop lying once you stop being a kid and grow up.

He is 5 feet 3 inches tall. He is not going to grow up anymore. May be that is where his hatred of India comes from, he feels like a midget among the Brits, has difficulties finding a girl for himself, and spends all his time blaming India and Hindus for everything.