Rakhigarhi: Indian town could unlock mystery of Indus civilisation

[Levina]

@Levina on the IVC origins etc either but you need to put forth your case better

That's a weekend troll.
No use drilling sense into him.


And it's not IVC, it's SSC- Sindhu Saraswati civilisation.

 

[Kabira]

but according to her and some other Indians of Ganga delta and South India they packed their bag and migrated to These places so they are real descenders of IVC people, you are not

There is no sign of south indian civilization before brahmins from north moved there.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

Btw I have proved my point beyond doubts, but you sir, don't budgeAnd it's not IVC, it's SSC- Sindhu Saraswati civilisation.

No you have not. You think you have, which is not the same as proved it. For now we can agree to disagree. Sort of fatigue syndrome setting in - I am getting too old to argue about same thing all the time.

Saraswati is a pipedream. A religious pipedream like mullah Zarvan and co peddle.

 

[Levina]

I am getting too old to argue about same thing all the time.

Huh?
Don't give me excuses. Lol

Saraswati is a pipedream.

wake up and smell the coffee.

 

[Swastika]

Inferior or not, they belonged to civilization with whom 1.2 billion somehow want to associate. That's more than enough reason for me to take pride on my ancestors.

no they are Iranians,Arabs,Turks and C Asians not Real people(unmixed) of IVC like South Indians.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

But before I go. I will say it unabashedly. All the good stuff comes from the North West of South Asia. That is the way it was and way it will be .....

You can choose to give the north west whatever name you want - the present permutation being Pakistan but this where all the action is.

coffee

I hate coffee. Good old smell of chai for me ...

 

[Swastika]

I think that the aryan invaded their lands and declared them shudras and they declared themselves to be higher castes ofcourse their might be alternative theories to who the natives were and why did such an advance civilization disappear

nope, Many people of IVC joined these Aryans Tribes my Friend. also look at mape of Rig Vedic Aryavrata and IVC

 

[Levina]

All the good stuff comes from the North West of South Asia. That is the way it was and way it will be .....

That is INDIAN subcontinent.

I hate coffee

I thought you loved it like all the other Brits.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

nope, Many people of IVC joined these Aryans Tribes my Friend. also look at mape of Rig Vedic Aryavrata and IVC

You need to look at this.

south asia | Harappa Ancestry Project
http://www.cell.com/ajhg/abstract/S0002-9297(13)00324-8

That is INDIAN subcontinent.

I thought you loved it like all the other Brits.

No. I never caught the coffee bug. Contrary to what people say tea is still big in UK. I think fashion is drawing people to coffee. Tea is boring coffee is seen as fashionable.

the good stuff comes

But there are exceptions. Levina being one .......

 

[Swastika]

@Swastika You need to tone down your language. I don't agree with @Levina on the IVC origins etc either but you need to put forth your case better.

And it perhaps is not the best thing to do be using "Swastika" as your handle and saying what your saying. I know Swastika has a pedigree far beyond Nazism.

how can i be Nazi sir ? i am not white or German. everybody knows and accepted that Brahmins and (most)Kshatriya (and many many Pakistanis and Afghans) are descenders of Aryans, who Moved or Migrated to India as different Tribes some were White,some were Brown, some were Iranic etc etc.
this is the place they created Vedas and besically whole Vedic Culture.

these people united as one after Fighting with Each other and Invented Vedas, Sanskrit and well, basically whole Vedic Culture and they created Caste system and placed themselves on Top of it. so we can both upper two caste is descenders of Aryans. (just like Rajputes are descenders of Hunnic and Kshatriya and Jatts are descenders of Saka tribes that Invaded India.

and Oldest name of India is "Aryavrata"

so base is Clear. now look at her posts.

you think??? AIT is rubbish.
The inhabitants of IVC/SSC moved to greener pastures in the west due to cataclysmic event (in this case drying up of river Saraswati). Aryans or the so called newcomers came in towards the end of late Happan period- around 1000BC. Unlike Harappans, these newcomers used to live in circular huts, and had inferior wares.

so she called our ancestors Inferior wares
My Ancestors :
at time of Migration (tribal period)

Medical surgery :

Veda,Yoga, Sanskrit even writing Skills, Music, Maths, Science you name it (basically whole Vedic culture.)
Her Ancestors :

ofcourse it is.
There was no "invasion"...just a few nomads who had started using the place after Harappans left. (I am talking about Dholavira in this case).

so here she calls my Ancestors Nomeds

My Ancestors :

Her Ancestors :

Thanks but I think you have misunderstood the word migrants/ nomads in my previous post. I do not believe in AIT (invasion) or AMT(migration) theory.
It's true that the places earlier inhabited by Harappans were later used by people who used very inferior wares, and who had no knowledge of the sophisticated technology used by Harappans.

now she called my Ancestors Inferior

My Ancestors :

Her Superior Ancestors :
@waz @WAJsal i only know you guys, she insulted my Ancestors clearly 3 times and i just posted reality of that time here

 

[Swastika]

 

[Levina]

You need to look at this.

south asia | Harappa Ancestry Project
http://www.cell.com/ajhg/abstract/S0002-9297(13)00324-8

That guy should also take a look at this

Aryan-Dravidian divide a myth: Study - The Times of India

And this

https://genetics.med.harvard.edu/reich/Reich_Lab/Press_files/Fountain Ink - December 2013 - Cover.pdf

Lolzz

I never caught the coffee bug. Contrary to what people say tea is still big in UK. I think fashion is drawing people to coffee. Tea is boring coffee is seen as fashionable.

Blame it on Costa and Starbucks.

Her Superior Ancestors :

Superior ???


Only those who suffer from inferiority complex have this urge to prove themselves superior...someone like you.
Btw if you look at those pics, you will realise my ancestors came on earth much before "yours".
Conclusion: my ancestors were your ancestors.
Now chill!

Edit:

ut there are exceptions. Levina being one

You bet!!! hehe
The country I belong to is an exception too.

 

[Swastika]

@Atanz you are Discussing with wrong person here, as you can see...

her 2 Gems from this thread, shes not a historian shes here to derail the thread and mock my Ancestors because her own ancestors were unable to Create Rival of IVc and Vedic Civ in south India. so now she's claiming Pakistan's and North west Indias History. it's not Claiming for me, it's stealing. @Atanz and @save_ghenda . shes hard core Nationalist (not a historian) sre so sh can not accept these facts.

and mods should take Action here now because she already Insulted my Ancestors 3 times and she's also posting one liners and derailing this thread based on her own Nationalist Agenda.
@waz @WAJsal @Horus

ofc i can be popular like her too by posting thousands off 1 liners but i mostly keep my mouth shut because i don't like to Derail or post worth less dump based on my Nationalist views on PDF.

 

[Levina]

she called my Ancestors Inferior

Comprehension issues???
Read my post again, I said this....

It's true that the places earlier inhabited by Harappans were later used by people who used very inferior wares, and who had no knowledge of the sophisticated technology used by Harappans.

Inferior wares means UTENSILS!!!!
Gosh!!
Harappans used wares which were well baked and were distinctively red and black. But those who migrated to their abandoned cities used "inferior" as in not so well baked utensils.

Omg!! I will die laughing.

@Atanz you are Discussing with wrong person here, as you can see...

her 2 Gems from this thread, shes not a historian shes here to derail the thread and mock my Ancestors because her own ancestors were unable to Create Rival of IVc and Vedic Civ in south India. so now she's claiming Pakistan's and North west Indias History. it's not Claiming for me, it's stealing. @Atanz and @save_ghenda . shes hard core Nationalist (not a historian) sre so sh can not accept these facts.

and mods should take Action here now because she already Insulted my Ancestors 3 times and she's also posting one liners and derailing this thread based on her own Nationalist Agenda.
@waz @WAJsal @Horus

ofc i can be popular like her too by posting thousands off 1 liners but i mostly keep my mouth shut because i don't like to Derail or post worth less dump based on my Nationalist views on PDF.

Hahaha
You gotta be kidding me.
@WAJsal and other mods I am really sorry you got pulled here.

 

[Kabira]

@Atanz you are Discussing with wrong person here, as you can see...

her 2 Gems from this thread, shes not a historian shes here to derail the thread and mock my Ancestors because her own ancestors were unable to Create Rival of IVc and Vedic Civ in south India. so now she's claiming Pakistan's and North west Indias History. it's not Claiming for me, it's stealing. @Atanz and @save_ghenda . shes hard core Nationalist (not a historian) sre so sh can not accept these facts.

and mods should take Action here now because she already Insulted my Ancestors 3 times and she's also posting one liners and derailing this thread based on her own Nationalist Agenda.
@waz @WAJsal @Horus

ofc i can be popular like her too by posting thousands off 1 liners but i mostly keep my mouth shut because i don't like to Derail or post worth less dump based on my Nationalist views on PDF.

You are overreacting, Levina is good poster. I don't see on what basis mods should take action. You don't have to agree with everything she say.