PTI will be buried forever in 2023: Shahbaz

[M. Sarmad]

Only Sindh should hold elections as dictated by timeline.

Karachi should be separated from the Sindh presidency

 

[El Sidd]

Karachi should be separated from the Sindh presidency

Ever since Jinnah liberated Sindh from Bombay presidency, fake Jinnahs have risen.

Can Multan be separated from Lahore presidency? Why do you intend to play divide and conquer beyond Punjab?

 

[M. Sarmad]

Can Multan be separated from Lahore presidency? Why do you intend to play divide and conquer beyond Punjab?

Central Punjab has 82 NA seats, Sindh (including Karachi) has 61
Even a trifurcation of Punjab is not going to change much
Stop looking at everything through an ethnic lens
Karachi deserves better

 

[El Sidd]

Central Punjab has 82 NA seats, Sindh (including Karachi) has 61
Even a trifurcation of Punjab is not going to change much
Stop looking at everything from an ethnic lens
Karachi deserves better

Karachi is lifeline to whole of Sindh. It is a matter of justice and moral responsibility of an administrative unit to regulate the resources which priorities the weakest first. A city's problem cannot be alleviated to more than what they are, a city's problem.

what are these terms central south north, they all sit in one provincial assembly don't they? overseer in Lahore caters for them all.

 

[M. Sarmad]

Karachi is lifeline to whole of Sindh. It is a matter of justice and moral responsibility of an administrative unit to regulate the resources which priorities the weakest first. A city's problem cannot be alleviated to more than what they are, a city's problem.

what are these terms central south north, they all sit in one provincial assembly don't they? overseer in Lahore caters for them all.

Karachi is a lifeline to whole of Pakistan, not just Sindh
The city itself is mini-Pakistan representing all Pakistani ethnicities and (sub-)cultures

Subah Multan had been historically distinct from Subah Lahore. The British Punjab stretched from Jalalabad (Afghanistan) to Delhi (India), and from Himalayas in the North to the deserts of Sindh and Rajasthan in the South. Punjab is not just Lahore

 

[El Sidd]

Karachi is a lifeline to whole of Pakistan, not just Sindh

that lifeline runs through Sindh before it reaches Islamabad if you need reminding.

Subah Multan had been historically distinct from Subah Lahore. The British Punjab stretched from Jalalabad to Delhi, and from Himalayas in the North to the deserts of Sindh and Rajasthan in the South. Punjab is not just Lahore

Punjab can be of any size of shape, it's beating heart will always be Lahore.

The city itself is mini-Pakistan representing all Pakistani ethnicities and (sub-)cultures

That can be easily said for any city in Sindh.

Why do you think Sindhis say Pakistan Khappay?

 

[M. Sarmad]

that lifeline runs through Sindh before it reaches Islamabad if you need reminding.

And all rivers run through KP and Punjab before reaching Sindh. We are a federation, such things don't matter

Punjab can be of any size of shape, it's beating heart will always be Lahore.

Lahore, being the largest and the most historically significant city in the region for the last 1000+ years, enjoys a unique status. Lahore is the beating heart of Pakistan, not just Punjab

That can be easily said for any city in Sindh.

No, that can not be said about any other city of Pakistan (let alone Sindh), including Lahore. Islamabad may be an exception though

 

[El Sidd]

And all rivers run through KP and Punjab before reaching Islamabad

Frontier undefined.

We are a federation, such things don't matter

For any federation or republic, fair distribution of wealth and resource forms fundamental building blocks of governance.

Lahore is the beating heart of Pakistan, not just Punjab

Hence it presides over Multan.

 

[M. Sarmad]

Hence it presides over Multan.

Not just Multan, entire Punjab
Karachi OTOH doesn't preside even over itself but is dependant upon Sindh presidency based out of Larkana

 

[El Sidd]

No, that can not be said about any other city of Pakistan (let alone Sindh), including Lahore. Islamabad may be an exception though

Larkana, Sukkur, Hyderabad and Mirpur Khaz disagree with you.

I told you yesterday Sind civilisation is light years ahead in accommodating muliculturist ideologies than any other administrative unit.

Not just Multan, entire Punjab
Karachi OTOH doesn't preside even over itself but is dependant upon Sindh presidency based out of Larkana

Rightly so.

Larkana is traditional region where seat of power lay for Sindh. The federal abandoned territory is being catered for at a pace in tune with rest of the country.

 

[M. Sarmad]

Larkana, Sukkur, Hyderabad and Mirpur Khaz disagree with you.

I told you yesterday Sind civilisation is light years ahead in accommodating muliculturist ideologies than any other administrative unit.

Anyone can disagree. But FACTS remain unchanged.. All of these cities (with the exception of Hyderabad) are essentially Sindhi cities.....
And Sindhis may be tolerant and inclusive, but Punjabis are in another league altogether when it comes to accomodating others

 

[El Sidd]

Anyone can disagree. FACTS remain unchanged.. All of these cities (with the exception of Hyderabad) are essentially Sindhi cities

Feel free to disagree.

 

[El Sidd]

And Sindhis may be tolerant and inclusive, but Punjabis are in another league altogether when it comes to accomodating others

This is now propaganda and fallacy.

 

[Path-Finder]

moohdhi league nawaj/**** movie leak network is betting on judgja badmash/qazi easy paisa too!!

 

[M. Sarmad]

This is now propaganda and fallacy.

No, it's not .. But you calling Larkana a multi-ethnic and multi-cultural city and claiming that Sindhis are light years ahead as compared to others sure is