Possible Russian S-400 sale to India and Pakistan's Response.

[Maarkhoor]

Possible Russian S-400 sale to India and Pakistan's Response

India seals Rs 70,000 cr missile deal with Russia

 

[Maarkhoor]

@The Deterrent @Bratva @Indus Falcon @Oscar

As per my personal opinion the most logical way to counter S-400 is MaRV and MiRV warheads for our Shaheen series. There is no credible defense available against MiRV missile attack.

 

[Indus Falcon]

@The Deterrent @Bratva @Indus Falcon @Oscar

As per my personal opinion the most logical way to counter S-400 is MaRV and MiRV warheads for our Shaheen series. There is no credible defense available against MiRV missile attack.

Why? when you can use MAR-1 & AGM-88 HARM against them.

 

[Stag112]

Kid these types of post consider trolling and next will be report.

Without going into the utter hilarity of YOU calling others trolls, how was it trolling? The only two cases a war can start is

1. Another terrorist attack by Pakistani terrorism factory on Indian soil, warranting a response
2. Another military misadventure by Pakistan like Kargil, Operation Gibraltar etc

Once Pakistan desists from the above two, they have effectively countered all Indian weapons, Triumf included.

 

[banvanaxl]

Kid these types of post consider trolling and next will be report.

He is right Abu Namr. No terrorism on Indian soil equates no Indian response. The S-400s and Ghauris can be given a peaceful burial and we can all hold hands and sing kumbaya.

 

[Blue Marlin]

there no response for pakistan yet, the hq-9 series is ok, but i heard the eurosam consortium may be offering a solution.
hence the army chief was looking at italian sam's whilst on his visit to italy. it's a ground based aster 30 variant

 

[NKVD]

@Ifrit

babur is old generation subsonic cruise missile comparable to kh-55 of russia both are based on later 70's Era Technology.Meanwhile many of the advanced defence systems have been developed to Counter even more sophisticated Cruise missiles like Brahmos

Defense systems like Aster-30 & Barak-8 can easily take on Supersonic cruise missile threats.
Leave subsonic threats aside .

 

[Ragnarok connection]

Mar-1 and even Ra'ad / Babur cruise missiles can easily penetrate any known SAMs.

Wrong, S-400 is designed to intercept anti-radiation and non-supersonic cruise missiles. And btw, how will the aircraft carrying the Mar-1 even get close enough to launch the missile ?

 

[Zarvan]

@Ifrit

babur is old generation subsonic cruise missile comparable to kh-55 of russia both are based on later 70's Era Technology.Meanwhile many of the advanced defence systems have been developed to Counter even more sophisticated Cruise missiles like Brahmos

Defense systems like Aster-30 & Barak-8 can easily take on Supersonic cruise missile threats.
Leave subsonic threats aside .

Babur is latest technology and more advance versions are coming.

 

[Maarkhoor]

@Ifrit

babur is old generation subsonic cruise missile comparable to kh-55 of russia both are based on later 70's Era Technology.Meanwhile many of the advanced defence systems have been developed to Counter even more sophisticated Cruise missiles like Brahmos

Defense systems like Aster-30 & Barak-8 can easily take on Supersonic cruise missile threats.
Leave subsonic threats aside .

Babur is old tech Ok and you fail to produce one (nirbhay) and tell me Brahmos is more sophisticated Ok when your able to produce more sophisticated cruise missile why the hell you fail to produce less capable missile.
Brahmos is merely a copy of Russian missile.

dont forget they have DSI tech in there frontline aircrafts and no SAM system can beat DSI anabelled fighter jets

@waz
Pls check this troll

 

[[Bregs]]

These are the type of deal which Russia needed from India at a time when its under stiff sanctions from west n US, this will reduce the coldness in relations which was there since past 2 yrs because India's continued contracts of defense items to Israel for anti tank missiles, France for Rafale n Possible more scorpene orders and with US for chinook, Apache. No west country or US will ever offer such a critical advanced game changer system to us apart from Russia

 

[Vyom]

Babur is old tech Ok and you fail to produce one (nirbhay) and tell me Brahmos is more sophisticated Ok when your able to produce more sophisticated cruise missile why the hell you fail to produce less capable missile.
Brahmos is merely a copy of Russian missile.

This thread is for discussing S400 countermeasures only. It has nothing to do with the failure of Nirbhay. you may open a separate thread if you want to discuss nirbhay's failure. please stay on topic. Post reported for off topic.

 

[Death In Fire]

S-400 Will enable India to enforce a no-fly zone over large parts of Pakistan.

S-400 Will be the death blow to Pakistani AWACS.They will be shot down over their own base.

All PAF bases near India border will be obsolete.

 

[Maarkhoor]

S-400 Will be the death blow to Pakistani AWACS.They will be shot down over their own base.
S-400 Will enable India to enforce a no-fly zone over large parts of Pakistan.

All PAF bases near India border will be obsolete.

upon adopting a single system you can't claim air superiority or no fly zone their are lot of counter measures available to neutralize the threat.

 

[Indus Falcon]

there no response for pakistan yet, the hq-9 series is ok, but i heard the eurosam consortium may be offering a solution.
hence the army chief was looking at italian sam's whilst on his visit to italy. it's a ground based aster 30 variant

Well at the cost of upsetting you, Aster 30 is actually quite a formidable system. IF inducted, it would definitely be a big leap in the capabilities of the air -defence sector!