Possibility of Guerilla Warfare Against Israel?

[MuhammedAli]

hamas is doing it

Would you just stand by while other people come and take your house.
View attachment 744030

I would like to live n make sure my fam lives. If situation was same as what plastinians face i would pack my bags n leave. Its called Hijrah. There is no shame in it. Allah instructed it and Allahs Messenger left barbarity of Mushrikeen for safety of Madinah. You put too much emphasis on land property house ... I rather loose my house land money then hair finger life of my child family member. I value what matters in reality. Allahs earth is vast. I love my Allah n the Messenger n my deen. My loyalty love attachment for them and those connected with it. Not to land house money. My life n my families life before house land wealth.

 

[Trango Towers]

I would like to live n make sure my fam lives. If situation was same as what plastinians face i would pack my bags n leave. Its called Hijrah. There is no shame in it. Allah instructed it and Allahs Messenger left barbarity of Mushrikeen for safety of Madinah. You put too much emphasis on land property house ... I rather loose my house land money then hair finger life of my child family member. I value what matters in reality. Allahs earth is vast. I love my Allah n the Messenger n my deen. My loyalty love attachment for them and those connected with it. Not to land house money. My life n my families life before house land wealth.

You will die a thousand deaths....a brave dies once. Good luck with creating a family of cowards

 

[Saifullah]

@Zarvan @Philip the Arab @Dalit @Falcon29

How effective would it be to launch Taliban style shoot n scoot guerilla warfare against Israel?

Has it been tried before? What are some hindrances? What are some edges that the Palestinians/Muslims in the region have against Israel?

There is No room to maneuver like that Taliban had the ability to maneuver rapidly you are in Gaza abd that's it. There were tactical withdrawals and maneuvering during this occupation by outside forces but the Taliban never lost anything. Taliban had learnt that skill when they first came in to being and part of it is in the Afghan Blood as well. It's funny for me to watch Pakistanis claiming their success as their own which they earned with their Blood and paid for it with their shaheeds. At best there was some advice from Pakistan and some looking away in somethings but they would have managed without the Pakistan with ease as well, As they were determined and don't blaber much and focused. On the other Hand Pakistan earned what we deserved from ALLAH PAK and we are still not learning our lessons. I will leave it at this as Mods ko as a chaki k patu harkat mn ana parta ha and besides Pakistanis doesn't have the stomach to have honest conversation specially American Chatos, they loose their minds.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

No it is hell'va tiny and has no strategic depth.. Karachi and it's surrounding areas is bigger then Israel.. Guerilla is fit for bigger areas and mountainous regions or rain forest like jungles

The country is tiny. Slightly larger than Karachi and with population 3 times less. At one point it is only 30 mile wide.

 

[Yongpeng Sun-Tastaufen]

The country is tiny. Slightly larger than Karachi and with population 3 times less. At one point it is only 30 mile wide.

View attachment 744102

A 2D project is not accurate. Only on a globe is the image accurate.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

A 2D project is not accurate. Only on a globe is the image accurate.

I used a website that specifically sizes surface area and takes into account the earths curvature. As you know on maps size gets distorted but this site adjusts for that.

Compare Countries With This Simple Tool

Drag and drop countries around the map to compare their relative size. Is Greenland really as big as all of Africa? You may be surprised at what you find! A great tool for educators.

thetruesize.com

 

[Ahmet Pasha]

There is No room to maneuver like that Taliban had the ability to maneuver rapidly you are in Gaza abd that's it. There were tactical withdrawals and maneuvering during this occupation by outside forces but the Taliban never lost anything. Taliban had learnt that skill when they first came in to being and part of it is in the Afghan Blood as well. It's funny for me to watch Pakistanis claiming their success as their own which they earned with their Blood and paid for it with their shaheeds. At best there was some advice from Pakistan and some looking away in somethings but they would have managed without the Pakistan with ease as well, As they were determined and don't blaber much and focused. On the other Hand Pakistan earned what we deserved from ALLAH PAK and we are still not learning our lessons. I will leave it at this as Mods ko as a chaki k patu harkat mn ana parta ha and besides Pakistanis doesn't have the stomach to have honest conversation specially American Chatos, they loose their minds.

Yes I don't claim Afghan victory as ours. They earned it themselves. But they serve as an example for rest of muslims to learn from.

 

[Saifullah]

What if Palestinians somehow succeed in establishing a Darra style cottage industry with 3D printers??

Syria and Lebanon as launch pads to retreat back to?

Vietnamese built an intricate tunnel systems with booby traps and everything.

A lot of Palestine/Israel is very hilly.

Syria and Lebanon doesn't want to bare the burden of being that friendly with Palestine. People has to be motivated enough to be able to do that and of course governments has look away but it will be on huge cost, instant Sanction, Militarily retaliation, huge Campaign by Western Media and if the Push shoves to come there will be a Invasion from the west as well.
If somehow Iran was next to Israel, they could have done it or perhaps there wouldn't be any Palestine right now in this world.

Vietnamese gave lives in millions millions and than they got their independence. None Arabs wants to get out of their Air Conditioned Rooms just like our Babus.

Brother it's a tiny tiny place no neighbouring country wana help, they are even against it on government level. There is resistant from Gaza because there is no Jordan to stop the assistance. Only Lebanon used to do something or perhaps now Syria is doing a barely a bit because of Iranian elements that's it. All the Arabs are Chatus of Israel just like our Babus as well. Our Brown Babus are wishing to accept Israel in their hearts and are just scared of "extremist" Muslims (Even though if it was time of Prophet Muhammad (SAAW) or Sahabs(R.A) were alive they would have been doing Jihad against Israel) who would lynch them on roads if any one even utter something like accepting Israel. There was some guy saying Pakistan is doing things quietly, this is what Pakistan is doing quietly i.e. Accepting them a legitimate government.

 

[Saifullah]

Yes I don't claim Afghan victory as ours. They earned it themselves. But they serve as an example for rest of muslims to learn from.

The claim was not Targeted to you it was a general statement which is repeated multiple times by people to create an impression that this was the case.

They do in some ways, but how many of the Muslims want to learn it ?
If you put Afghanis in Palestine there would have been quite more resistantance.

 

[Oldman1]

@Zarvan @Philip the Arab @Dalit @Falcon29

How effective would it be to launch Taliban style shoot n scoot guerilla warfare against Israel?

Has it been tried before? What are some hindrances? What are some edges that the Palestinians/Muslims in the region have against Israel?

Different conflict. Taliban can fight and withdraw into Pakistan hence why they call every offensive each year the Spring Offensive when snow melts and they climb over the hills and mountains after getting new recruits and weapons. Another problem is Israel is right there. They are not going to withdraw anywhere. The U.S. can, Israel cannot and its their country being attacked, they will fight hard.

 

[jamahir]

For those on this thread so volubly adoring of the Taliban read my thread from last year about what the Taliban are doing now and what they will do when they form the government soon or "share" government power :

Afghan woman shot, blinded, for getting a job

Afghan woman shot, blinded, for getting a job Reuters | Nov 10, 2020, 13:24 IST 33-year-old Khatera was blinded after a gunmen attack in Ghazni province of Afghanistan KABUL: The last thing 33-year-old Khatera saw were the three men on a motorcycle who attacked her just after she left her...

defence.pk

 

[Vapnope]

Asymmetrical warfare can only be successful when your adversary is on ground in the area of the conflict. In case of Israel and Palestine, Israel has effectively choked supply chain of Hamas and use jets and other assets from their safe zones making it impossible for Palestinians to cause damage to Israel.

 

[VkdIndian]

For those on this thread so volubly adoring of the Taliban read my thread from last year about what the Taliban are doing now and what they will do when they form the government soon or "share" government power :

An apt analysis. Hope that new regime is more sensible and doesn’t take the country back to Stone Age.

 

[BRAVO_]

 

[Sinnerman108]

@Zarvan @Philip the Arab @Dalit @Falcon29

How effective would it be to launch Taliban style shoot n scoot guerilla warfare against Israel?

Has it been tried before? What are some hindrances? What are some edges that the Palestinians/Muslims in the region have against Israel?

That is not going to work, not at this moment in time,

For an A-symmetrical war plan to work, you need a committed population, that acts as a opaque
substrate to the guerillas.
In case of palestine or anywhere in the ME you will not find a honest and committed population
as they are divided and will not hesitate one least bit, selling off and throwing the guerillas under the bus.

The only thing that "may" work is a full frontal show of force.
The weakness in enemy's armor is the land. There can be only one israel.
It cannot be anywhere else, thus once they are convinced that part of land maybe annihilated
they will fall in line.

It is for THIS and only THIS one purpose, that Gaddafi, Iraq and Syria were punished and Iran is
their target, since they think Pakistan is counterbalanced with India.