I agree with most of yr points.......But my friend if u want a change then u must be there to supervise it yourself.
Ap b yahen hain or main b yahe hun dekh lena kuch nai ho ga.
Tell me one family in any Village who is impressed by her and is sending their daughters or sons to school because of her?
She is not the first one to do such campaigns if u remember Shehzad Roy also did not a long ago but again failed badly.
Mukhtara Maai's anti rape campaign is another example.
Now her status is more then of VVIP as she is a world renounced figure and a nominee of Nobel Prize!
Issy ab common na samjho. And also what image r we giving to the world that we cant protect a Kid like her from Taliban that she had to flee from Pakistan to a Foreign Country then tomorrow how will we protect our Nukes from them?
This is west they can make any reason or can use this type Malala like situation's flow or flow of this or such situations for their own goals and objectives.
We need to think broadly with the environment Globally as well in our mind as such type of decision of her not coming and our gov doing nothing in calling her back is gonna give more dirty image of Pakistan then any positive from herself.
Sometimes , the person sitting in the back seat is much more prominent/effective/powerful/influential than the one in the driving seat , is that true too , mate ?
Mate , none , not even God can/wouldn't want to change the state of a nation which doesn't want to change itself and remain in the same condition . A doctor cant treat a disease or disorder both of the mind and the body unless the patient acknowledges that he indeed is suffering from it . Maybe , something will happen or something wont but at least its a step in the right direction . If a family doesn't want to teach or provide education to its offspring/children , then it simply wont , even if the God appears in front of them . Who the hell is a little girl from Swat ? But at least the support , encouragement and the money will be there for women education . This is an achievement in itself . The thinking patterns of the society aren't changed so easily , my friend . The nation of Pakistan is the worst confused one which doesn't really know its right and wrong and cant differentiate between friends and enemies , I have ever seen . Consider this as constructive criticism . Now , unless of course you have gone to every single village across the country , you cant really say or claim that . Sorry , you cant .
Even if it is now , which I sincerely doubt in Pakistan that she will be provided that much security and constant supervision by the authorities , why exactly should she come to her native country where she will again live under constant fear of her life and threats and harassment from the Taliban and other extremist groups ? Would it be wise by any chance now ? Wasn't the opposition to the religious nut jobs and support for the army when majority of the Swat population was silent and bowing down to religious psychopaths enough to prove her courage ? She lived in Pakistan despite being threatened constantly by the terrorists until she was shot . Let her have some peace of mind and continue her work from there , you do not know the feeling of living in " anxiety and fear " . Are you aware of the people who have left Pakistan due to the same reason of law and order ? You cant call them " not courageous " , but wise . You have to draw a line between " bravery " and " foolishness " at times .
Get to the root . We couldn't protect her in the first place , that is a fact , period . What image did we give to the world when we couldn't protect the writ of the Govt and the rights of our people from extremists in Swat ? How did they take control of a part of our country and why couldn't we defend it ? What image did we give when we negotiated and literally left our own people to the mercy of Taliban ? What image did we already give when we couldn't protect her , despite all the threats leading to the event in which she was shot and nearly killed ? First answer me that . Leave the little girl , all alone , for a few moment . Think deeply . Was it West fault ? Does extremism and terrorism exists not in Pakistan ? Who's the one preaching intolerance and hatred ? Who is the suicide bomber blowing up in the country at various places ? The same Pakistani national or in cases " de facto " Pakistanis imported during Afghan Jihad from around the world . Please , learn to take responsibility of your own mistakes . Blaming the West for your every mishap and problem will not help in the slightest .
Yes , but be skeptical and not paranoid . Considering everyone as enemy and everything Western wrong is not logical or sensible or rational . What exactly has West used her so far for if I may know ? With all the politicians and generals in Islamabad under their control , do they really need a little girl ? Not really , listen to any of her speech and see what image of our country she promotes .
@
Stealth
May I have a credible source for all that you have written ? I am sure that such documentary/footage/show is available for all to see , provided that it exists . Why not expose her then by posting it ? Lets put some weight to your claims or if I may interject a new " conspiracy theory " by getting us the link to the new " American channel video " . Apparently , she wrote a lot in her diary , blogs and documentaries which is only being made available to some that too only after she was shot and came in limelight .
Zindabad
Her voice is being heard in the world and in her own country , just fine , the soft image of the tolerant and moderate Pakistanis is being promoted , funds are pouring in for Women education from the world and its getting the support needed for the task . What else do you call a " voice loud enough " ? What the heck are we doing in our capacity ? Posting and commenting on threads with most of us cricizing her , calling her evil only because of the thinking " All things West are evil and should be forbidden " crazy logic , making her controversial and casting doubts ? If you still aren't hearing the voice that its creating , take the headphones off and listen again .
