PCB's case against BCCI has been dismissed by ICC's dispute panel

[Awan68]

Yeah those were the days and look at you guys now. Begging for a bilateral series, despite being turned down a dozen times. tsk..tsk.

Crawl on troll, crawl on.

 

[@RV]

What else was the expected outcome? The money was unnecessarily wasted for emotional reasons. Always the case with Pakistani authorities, be it PCB or their water board.

 

[Qutb-ud-din Aybak]

Indians should show the guts and been not play against pakistan in ICC tournaments.

 

[manga]

Now that pakistan is defeated in this matter BCCI should sue PCB for wasting our precious time and maligning our image. Squeeze the dead even more.

Your entire country used to be our property, u little bakht. Ive encountered a lot of indians here in Australia, u act all macho online while face to face u act like little girl scouts.

Yeah you are so brave you win more medals for this bravery in asian games. We all saw that last month or so.

 

[Laozi]

Has Pakistan ever won any legal battle internationally ?

Indians should show the guts and been not play against pakistan in ICC tournaments.

We are happy with the ICC

Thse who felt jilted should boycott ICC

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

Should go to court

Agreement to play , meant Pakistan voted for India in ICC election and due to that India got Top Series vs Australia and England on continuous basis while Pakistan was deprived of playing vs top teams

• India Racked in Top $$$ from Series vs Australia , England and on repetitive times
• Favorable schedule also meant more games and tests in order to rack up stats

The ICC role also helped India make up favorable schedules for it's team so it played top teams before World Cups so it went in to Top tournaments in prime form vs Pakistan was stuck playing vs Zimbabwae or Ireland


Pakistan's part of bargin was we would get India-Pakistan Series and that would help our Cricket. Agreement was for 10 years meaning every year there would be series

• Test/ODI/T20 series

 

[Indrajit]

Indians should show the guts and been not play against pakistan in ICC tournaments.

Nope. We play Pakistan where it suits us. What’s difficult to understand.

Should go to court

Agreement to play , meant Pakistan voted for India in ICC election and due to that India got Top Series vs Australia and England on continuous basis while Pakistan was deprived of playing vs top teams

• India Racked in Top $$$ from Series vs Australia , England and on repetitive times
• Favorable schedule also meant more games and tests in order to rack up stats

The ICC role also helped India make up favorable schedules for it's team so it played top teams before World Cups so it went in to Top tournaments in prime form vs Pakistan was stuck playing vs Zimbabwae or Ireland


Pakistan's part of bargin was we would get India-Pakistan Series and that would help our Cricket. Agreement was for 10 years meaning every year there would be series

• Test/ODI/T20 series

Not appealable. No jurisdiction. Not enforceable. Pakistan originally supported the Big 3 plan and later voted against it. Big 3 doesn’t exist. Even if this was an agreement and not just a worthless MoU, it still would have been a difficult sell since you didn’t do your part of the bargain. If Pakistan’s argument was that the changed their vote because India didn’t play with them, then that’s all squared off already. Silly to provoke BCCI with this idiotic claim for compensation. The BCCI is interested in the money and they might have looked favourably at an India pak series if the political signal was there to do it. Now the new PCB boss has to mend that relationship first. More buttering up BCCI honchos. Foolish.

Has Pakistan ever won any legal battle internationally ?

Easy to predict reaction. India bought off ICC, otherwise they had a brilliant super-duper case which they could never lose. Same play book for everything, from defeats at the ICJ, to the World Bank on the IWT, heck even to the FATF gray listing or the stoppage of American aid....Indian influence everywhere...

 

[Imran Khan]

 

[Samlee]

Why is Pakistan so desperate to play against India, this is beyond pathetic!

B'Coz We Like Humiliating You The Same Way We Did At Lords

 

[Osiris]

B'Coz We Like Humiliating You The Same Way We Did At Lords

Didn't you just loose 2 back to back matches against us, not even 2 months ago ?

In other new - this is what PCB was saying about this case - just a month back.



PCB officials hopeful of favourable verdict in compensation case against BCCI
Mohammad YaqoobUpdated October 05, 2018

LAHORE: Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) officials are hopeful for a decision in their favour in the compensation case against India after hearings were completed on Wednesday in Dubai by a panel of the ICC, headed by Michael Beloff.

The PCB had filed the compensation case against India before the ICC Dispute Resolution Forum which heard both the parties at the ICC headquarters in Dubai between Oct 1 to 3. The PCB’s stance in the case is that the Indian cricket board (BCCI) had signed an MoU with Pakistan in 2014 in order to restore the bilateral series between the two countries which have remained suspended for the last 11 years. However the BCCI has refused to honour their commitment and have not implemented the conditions agreed in the MoU.

It was agreed between the two boards at the time of signing the MoU that in order restore the bilateral series, the PCB would have to cast a vote in favour of the Big Three under which formula the cricket boards off India, England and Australia were to get more share of the ICC funds. The PCB, therefore, cast a vote in favour of the Big Three and the MoU was subsequently signed.

Well informed sources from Dubai told Dawn that BCCI’s defence appeared quite weak on both the major points raised during the hearing. The BCCI took the plea that its government did not allow its cricket team to play Pakistan in the bilateral series. However, since this point is not mentioned in the MoU, so raising it as an after-thought does not augur well for the BCCI in the case.

ARTICLE CONTINUES AFTER AD
Sources further said that BCCI’s second point that the Indian team could not travel to Pakistan on security grounds, since no major country has visited there in the last ten year, also failed to carry weight as the PCB time and again offered the BCCI to hold their part of the series in the UAE or at a neutral venue.

“According to the MoUs, four full home series with Pakistan were to be played in the UAE, from 2015 to 2023, in exchange for PCB agreeing to vote for the Big Three resolutions whereby India was expected to reap huge financial benefits,” sources close to the officials who appeared from Pakistan in the hearing told Dawn.

Ex-PCB chairman Najam Sethi and incumbent Chief Operating Officer Subhan Ahmad appeared as witnesses of the PCB. Both had signed the MoU with then BCCI chief Srinivasan who refused to appear as witness in the hearings.

The sources further said that for not honouring that MoUs, the PCB claims that BCCI should compensate for lost revenue to the tune of US$70million approximately. “However, the BCCI says the agreement was not a binding and it was “understood” to be conditional on government approval which was not forthcoming but that is not a strong enough argument,” the sources said.

The written arguments by lawyers from both side will be presented to the tribunal next weektoldand the judgment is expected in due course.

Both the PCB and the BCCI hired the services of British lawyers to defend the case, which may be the first one of its kind in cricket history.

Published in Dawn, October 5th, 2018

 

[kmc_chacko]

I am just wondering whats next, now that the case has been dismissed. Is the PCB going to come with a begging bowl and beg for a bilateral series?

Ehsan Mani will be making a tour of India in the name of discussions just like earlier PCB members did.

Not appealable. No jurisdiction. Not enforceable.

Pakistan Court is the only place they can win this case, let them try it.

 

[manga]

Imran khan should take a trip to new delhi at modi's door and place a official request.
But wait ... did imran khan called someone small people with big offices ? Damn, i doubt if modi will open door for him after this foolishness.
But hey... then imran khan also said that taking a u-turn is sign of a great leader so he should take that u turn sooner than later.

 

[Roybot]

B'Coz We Like Humiliating You The Same Way We Did At Lords

Yeah clearly we are the one's getting humiliated. I mean you guys are so pathetic we had to get an international court to ask your cricket board to sod off

 

[Jackdaws]

It seems India will now demands costs of legal proceedings against the PCB. Does PCB have the money?

 

[maithil]

Rai said BCCI will now file a counter compensation case against the PCB to demand the cost of arbitration. “We will make a presentation to the panel and demand entire cost of compensation to be borne by the PCB for the arbitration where there claims have been dismissed,” he added.

https://indianexpress.com/article/sports/cricket/india-vs-pakistan-bcci-pcb-icc-5455626/


Must say.. very foolish step on part of PCB. First lost the case and now will have to pay tons of money to BCCI. All this because Najam Sethi Har hope that he could win this for Pakistan. What a horrible situation he has put current governing body into. He should be forced to pay this fine from his pocket.