Partition of India on religious lines was a historic mistake: Indian defence minister Rajnath Singh

[SIPRA]

Partition of British India (Subcontinent) was indispensable and inescapable. Why would the Muslim-majority areas choose to live under the yoke of discriminatory Hindu Raj?

 

[xeuss]

You are mistaken if only Muslims of Kashmir are unhappy. There are many more Muslims in India @xeuss who are unhappy with the current setup.

The only solution to this is give Muslims of India their own home lands.

Asking to live in peace and dignity in India does not mean that Muslims want a separate country.

Unless you have concluded that Hindus are incapable of allowing Muslims to live in peace and dignity in India and that only a Muslim homeland can provide that.

 

[SuvarnaTeja]

Asking to live in peace and dignity in India does not mean that Muslims want a separate country.

Unless you have concluded that Hindus are incapable of allowing Muslims to live in peace and dignity in India and that only a Muslim homeland can provide that.

Yes. Lasting peace is only possible by segregating Hindu males from the rest of India.

This is my proposal.

Should India be partitioned based on gender to prevent Rapes?

India is the rape capital of the world. The best way to prevent this is to divide India based on gender. All Muslims and Hindu girls should get South India while all Hindu men can have North India. This will eliminate all rapes and communal violence in India.

defence.pk

@jamahir

 

[FreeFromFear]

Asking to live in peace and dignity in India does not mean that Muslims want a separate country.

Unless you have concluded that Hindus are incapable of allowing Muslims to live in peace and dignity in India and that only a Muslim homeland can provide that.

Are you yet to make that conclusion about the depraved society?
Your peace & dignity are already gone since 7 years, aint it?

 

[mig25]

The Indians are a confused bunch. Some say partition was good. Some say it was bad. Undecided and confused.

Absolutely not. My fellow men who say partition was bad are only talking about the land -- they still don't want Pakistanis among us. People saying partition is good are also saying we don't want Pakistanis but don't mind the land. I'm sure Pakistanis think the same. Don't get the confusion at all.

 

[The Eagle]

You all are just reading too much into it. That RSS mob Rajnath is actually saying that they don't have enough Muslims to lynch since Hindutva wanted all of them eliminated while being called as Indian at once. The partition actually made it much difficult and impossible. That's the real pain.

 

[Pandora]

Indians will never be able to digest existence of Pakistan. Rajnaath ki agli 10 generations ko bi gand mein mirchein lagti rahein gi Akhand Bharat ki.

 

[ARMalik]

Oh God, not this Indian defence monkey again. Can someone throw this primate a banana??

 

[Vapnope]

that's not how it works. if the two nation theory is accepted, then the RSS is also right and Hindus will ask for a Hindu Rashtra. it's incoherent to say Jinnah was right but India should be secular. of course RSS also claims that it doesn't hate minorities blah blah but you know what that means in theocratic terms, looking at Pakistan etc.

To be fair to both founding fathers of India and Pakistan, both countries deviated from their vision.

 

[jamahir]

Yes. Lasting peace is only possible by segregating Hindu males from the rest of India.

This is my proposal.

Should India be partitioned based on gender to prevent Rapes?

India is the rape capital of the world. The best way to prevent this is to divide India based on gender. All Muslims and Hindu girls should get South India while all Hindu men can have North India. This will eliminate all rapes and communal violence in India.

defence.pk

@jamahir

Not every Muslim Indian male is disciplined, far-seeing and rational. My proposal is to somehow gather the louts and the yobs in India and send them to Siberia and to Antarctica to do mining or a similar activity for the next 10 years and learn humanism and discipline. In the meanwhile the remaining males in India along with the sensible and rational females should build a better India.

 

[fitpOsitive]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1470059378657185806

Its in the psyche of the people of South Asia. We tend to oppress each other. We find an excuse to do it. Religion was one such thing. But later on separation of Bangladesh proved that it was not religion due to which Muslim majority areas got separated in 1947. It's the hyena in our mentality that was responsible for partition. It's my prediction, based on past and our mentality, that there are more partitions to come both in India and Pakistan, if we didn't change ourselves.

 

[faithfulguy]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1470059378657185806

I agree with this minister. India should partitioned along the kingdoms before British arrival.

 

[Thorough Pro]

Like it was their doing, where do they produce such dickheads in such abundance?

https://twitter.com/x/status/1470059378657185806

 

[SIPRA]

Like it was their doing, where do they produce such dickheads in such abundance?

Fantasies have no boundaries.

 

[FuturePAF]

The state of Indian democracy speaks for itself; what hope would there have been had partition not happened, if this is how they treat fellow Hindus. And this is jot a one off incident but indicative of a mindset that has always been there, just now it has been allowed to come to the fore and therefore spread to a large portion of the population