Pakistan’s mini-nukes won’t guarantee security, only annihilation

[Sine Nomine]

First you says Chinese share all intel data even satellite imaganary data from her spy satellite to monitor indian movement in realtime, then jump to Beidou navigational satellite inputs of military grade. -- Either civil or military how the hell its going to spy indian movement. Do you have any ellementory knowledge of the satellite.

kiddo i just presented Beidou navigational satellite as an Example.We have our own assets for such work+no war is going to happen because we never helped any group outside kashmir to attack India,that too IA personal only.
Until or unless India wants a war and just uses another false flag like Ganga Hijack to do so.

OK KIDDO don't quote me again

I am only quoting you to remove you ignorance.otherwise when i engage trolls they are just got banned forever along with me going on leave.

 

[zebra7]

kiddo i just presented Beidou navigational satellite as an Example.We have our own assets for such work+no war is going to happen because we never helped any group outside kashmir to attack India,that too IA personal only.
Until or unless India wants a war and just uses another false flag like Ganga Hijack to do so.

I am only quoting you to remove you ignorance.otherwise when i engage trolls they are just got banned forever along with me going on leave.

Dear sir, if we are having a healthy discussion, then its important that we stick to some topic.
I have to go now, we will have debate some other time.

quote me then.

 

[MEAGAN FOXSS]

WE WILL SEE WHOSE ANNIHALATION IT WILL BE. START IT MODI WE ARE WAITING WE ARE READY FOR IT . . . . START IT ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

 

[singh sahab]

WE WILL SEE WHOSE ANNIHALATION IT WILL BE. START IT MODI WE ARE WAITING WE ARE READY FOR IT . . . . START IT ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

Increase the font and add your lolwa~i~hind crap.

It would look more scary that way.

 

[Sine Nomine]

Dear sir, if we are having a healthy discussion, then its important that we stick to some topic.
I have to go now, we will have debate some other time.

quote me then.

I personally think there is no room for Nuclear Discussion because as you know after effects of Chernobyl,only an insane dumb idiot will troll on this topic about which General Public has no knowledge.There is going to be no war and nuclear one never.
As you know from past many decades LOC firing is common in fact in past years before advent of TRP hungry media during 80's&90's that was immense,in fact company and battalion level skirmishes were common.Good to see they are not happening today.
Regards
Till Next bye bye..

 

[deckingraj]

He is comparing Nasr missile with small nukes in 1950. He is so ignorant that he forgot that there is a complete difference if their firing and security mechanism. NASR missile is secured by the layered password mechanism and no soldier can fire it on will unlike US recoil less nukes.

With all due respect a tactical nuke doesn't enjoy the same command and control like its regular counterparts...no??

Well the writer has been infamous for his bashing on Pakistan's nuclear program since start. He thinks that Pakistan should rollback nuclear program which requires few millions to operate and use conventional large force which requires multi billion extra budget

Fair reasoning..however that's where the problem lies as well....Nukes can't be an alternative to conventional weapons...Imagine a Mumbai II like scenario...and India actually does apply the Cold Start doctrine...Use of NASR brings in huge risks...vs a conventionally strong Pakistan which can withhold India's thrust without nukes....

Not only that he is against the installation of peaceful nuclear plants for energy generations in Pakistan.

This guy has been so obsessed with Pakistan's nuclear tech and it seems that there is some thing fishy behind the scene otherwise why only one person out of hundreds is against and he is unable to provide solid evidences yet.

no comments on that...though i always believe killing the messenger is not the best choice...

 

[django]

Who told you kid We are going to use these nukes on our soil,they will be used to destroy Indian Troops just before war,you know Chinese sats are watching every inch of India.We have strong HUMINT and UAV base to guess right time of attack.


I don't think we have only two nukes,but actually even 2 to 3 blats by each will poison Whole of SA.

Kid your idiotic rhetoric of 20 billion and 100 billion population figures or clear cut sign of mental problem.


blah..blah RAW deal, that all happened due to crazy,lanti Mushy who pulled support out of kashmir in 2004 for peace,everybody knows about IA death rate and desertion from 1991 to 2005 in IOK.


Once Huddod bahi joined Pakistani Nuclear Program but he was not cleared to work in Program,due to security reason's.

Sir do you have any evidence to authenticate your claim in regards to Hoodbhoy and his attempt of employment at Pakistan nuclear facilities.

 

[Sine Nomine]

Sir do you have any evidence to authenticate your claim in regards to Hoodbhoy and his attempt of employment at Pakistan nuclear facilities.

May be he have got copies of those security sheets provided to him,but right know that record in unassailable,he is blacklisted,there are even Non-Muslim Pakistanis working there but he wasn't allowed.
He is beyond doubt a genius in his field and at that time he was among handful of Pakistanis expert in that Particular field.
In spite of having close ties with many Scientists working there,he wasn't Given clean certificate by "INTEL"agencies.
As,i know work in those Labs and installations require highest Degree of clearance and background check,which he failed due to reasons unknown.

 

[tarrar]

As soon as these rented whores get money from their foreign pimps, these whores start to bark.

 

[vsdave2302]

WE WILL SEE WHOSE ANNIHALATION IT WILL BE. START IT MODI WE ARE WAITING WE ARE READY FOR IT . . . . START IT ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

Ok Use one tactical nuke and see the result.

 

[Mrc]

Ok Use one tactical nuke and see the result.

Its very very very difficult for indians to understand.....but i will say it again...

They will not use one....
Least number they will use would be around 100

 

[Counterpunch]

Its very very very difficult for indians to understand.....but i will say it again...

They will not use one....
Least number they will use would be around 100

To add to your statement, if Pakistan at all decides to use them...they will of course go all out
Smaller/miniaturized nukes are only there to put the cold start doctrine back to cold storage and restore status quo..which actually favors Pakistan more and embarrasses India in the sense that it is being caged by a country many times smaller its size and resources

 

[django]

May be he have got copies of those security sheets provided to him,but right know that record in unassailable,he is blacklisted,there are even Non-Muslim Pakistanis working there but he wasn't allowed.
He is beyond doubt a genius in his field and at that time he was among handful of Pakistanis expert in that Particular field.
In spite of having close ties with many Scientists working there,he wasn't Given clean certificate by "INTEL"agencies.
As,i know work in those Labs and installations require highest Degree of clearance and background check,which he failed due to reasons unknown.

He is without doubt one of Pakistan's leading theoretical physicists if not the leading one, from what I can deduce from his writings, is that he is highly opposed to Pakistan's nuclear program (military aspect), could he have worked in the peaceful aspects, sure , but then he seems more interested in being an academic and doing research into theoretical physics, I highly doubt he ever applied for such a role as it does not seem to fit in with his views.
BTW he is an excellent physicist, one of the leading ones in south asia and well distinguished internationally however words like genius should be reserved for physicists like Hawking and Weinberg with the latter being Hoodbhoys teacher at MIT and someone who has co-authored papers with him.kudos

 

[Sine Nomine]

from what I can deduce from his writings, is that he is highly opposed to Pakistan's nuclear program (military aspect)

That rejection may lead him to hostility.

could he have worked in the peaceful aspects

In Pakistan unfortunately research in peaceful aspect at large scale,only is carried out in those facilities which are under strict control of Govt Security Apparatus.Any meaningful research in Pakistan is only done in defense field.We are quite ahead,even from western nation in Nuclear field only because it's related to Defense.

 

[django]

That rejection may lead him to hostility.

In Pakistan unfortunately research in peaceful aspect at large scale,only is carried out in those facilities which are under strict control of Govt Security Apparatus.Any meaningful research in Pakistan is only done in defense field.We are quite ahead,even from western nation in Nuclear field only because it's related to Defense.

Our centrifuge technology is world class, I believe we even helped China in that field. I have read that we have also developed lazer enrichment technology thanks to Shaukat Hameed Khan. Mashallah our strategic defense is impregnable due to the efforts of AQ Khan, Dr Samarmubarkmand, Riazuddin, Rafi Choudary , Shaukat Hameed Khan etc.kudos