Pakistani , a nation?

[BelligerentPacifist]

A nation is defined as
" A large aggregate of people united by common descent, history, culture, or language, inhabiting a particular country or territory"
Now pakistani as nation doesnt fit into above defination. But if i take pashtun as a nation then it satisfies the defination of a nation. Dont you people think that pakistan should be considered federation of nations?

MDL, I understand that a definition without provenance from the Divine or proof/support from the Divine, is likely to fall into error.

Even qaum can be evidently seen being used in different manners, let alone other words like taa'ifa.

I so want to quote an example but I don't want to be egregious and transgressing my bounds. If you want you could go read Al A"raaf signs 160 and 168 for yourself. Thank you.

 

[jetti]

Living in a homo-ethnic nation would be boring as hell. True story.

what about homo-religious?

No caste system menace in the meanwhile....... Pakistan. !!

same in india

 

[BelligerentPacifist]

meanwhile no spontaneous human combustion in India.

Haha good one!

 

[Sher Malang]

Even your Afghanistan is made up of Tajik, Uzbek, Hazara, and Pashtun. So according to this monkey afghani refugee, Afghan is not a nation either.

Don't drag Afghanistan into this; he is a proud Pashtun if you can't counter his remarks don't bring imbecility into your posts!

 

[Uchiha]

A nation is defined as
" A large aggregate of people united by common descent, history, culture, or language, inhabiting a particular country or territory"
Now pakistani as nation doesnt fit into above defination. But if i take pashtun as a nation then it satisfies the defination of a nation. Dont you people think that pakistan should be considered federation of nations?

nope, not even pashtun qualifies - because they arent as homogenous as you think.

Don't drag Afghanistan into this; he is a proud Pashtun if you can't counter his remarks don't bring imbecility into your posts!

He's a bit too proud then, he can leave peacefully.

 

[Windjammer]

No Sectarian violence in the meanwhile....... India. !!

meanwhile no spontaneous human combustion in India.

Just try some Beef, all the cobwebs get blown away.

http://www.defence.pk/forums/world-...university-beef-festival-sparks-violence.html

Slaughtered cows in factory, locals go on rampage - Indian Express

 

[Sher Malang]

He's a bit too proud then, he can leave peacefully.

How many of those 28 mln Pashtuns living in Pakistan you will ask to leave?

 

[INDIC]

How many of those 28 mln Pashtuns living in Pakistan you will ask to leave?

They say same things to Muhajirs," If you want a muhajir Subah, then go back to India where you actually belong."

 

[Sher Malang]

They say same things to Muhajirs," If you want a muhajir Subah, then go back to India where you actually belong."

That shows a dedicated rule of Punjabis over others!

by a facebooker:

some vacancies in khyber pukhtoonkhwa but quota alloted to pajnab then how we say pakistan zindabad

 

[Uchiha]

How many of those 28 mln Pashtuns living in Pakistan you will ask to leave?

Just this one, the others are PAKISTANI and proud - infact we'd be stopping them from going anywhere.

 

[Sher Malang]

Just this one, the others are PAKISTANI and proud - infact we'd be stopping them from going anywhere.

Every Pashtun is a proud Pashtun than that would make it impossible for you to tell them to leave!

 

[Uchiha]

They say same things to Muhajirs," If you want a muhajir Subah, then go back to India where you actually belong."

that's different because they actually face discrimination - muhajirs are randomly rejected from the army, cant get govt jobs, can rule the province they were born in etc. BUT this guy probably just walked over from afghanistan in his smuggle prado with heroin in the trunk and a flock of goats and wives running behind. But muhajirs fought against hindus for their freeedom.

Every Pashtun is a proud Pashtun than that would make it impossible for you to tell them to leave!

unlike the gloomy picture you paint, most pushtuns i know are so closely intermingled with punjabis and karachiites they'd chose us theyre firends over you anyday
an example wud be my own school

 

[Sher Malang]

that's different because they actually face discrimination - muhajirs are randomly rejected from the army, cant get govt jobs, can rule the province they were born in etc. BUT this guy probably just walked over from afghanistan in his smuggle prade with heroin in the trunk and a flock of goats and wives running behind. But muhajirs fought against hindus for their freeedom.


unlike the gloomy picture you paint, most pushtuns i know are so closely intermingled with punjabis and karachiites they'd chose us theyre firends over you anyday
an example wud be my own school

You are trying to tell me a Pashtun is a proud Punjabi? :/

 

[Don Jaguar]

That shows a dedicated rule of Punjabis over others!

by a facebooker:

some vacancies in khyber pukhtoonkhwa but quota alloted to pajnab then how we say pakistan zindabad

Because punjabis are 60% of the total population they deserve bigger quota.

 

[Sher Malang]

Because punjabis are 60% of the total population they deserve bigger quota.

They are 60% in Punjab not in Khyber, Baluchistan or Sindh!