Pakistan should not accept Indian aid even through UN: Pak media Read more: Pakistan
- Thread starter t_for_talli
- Start date
KingOfGods
FULL MEMBER
- Joined
- Aug 12, 2010
- Messages
- 237
- Reaction score
- 0
Bojitive neuj
FULL MEMBER
New Recruit
- Joined
- Aug 29, 2010
- Messages
- 49
- Reaction score
- 0
Is pakistan doing India a favour by accepting our aid? Is this a service they are providing us?
Damning attitude. There's a well suited saying that I wont mention right now, but situation is clearly against pakistan and certainly they cannot act as "choosers" anymore.
Agnostic_Indian
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Jun 19, 2010
- Messages
- 3,102
- Reaction score
- 0
- Country
- Location
Flood and natural disasters can happen in any country...when people suffer from this calamitys its our duty to help..and its your duty to accept it gracefuly.We can still remain enemys if we wish.. even in war countries avoid attacking enemy civilians,exchange war prisoners etc. And pakistan can pay the money back when india is in trouble...
third eye
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Aug 24, 2008
- Messages
- 18,519
- Reaction score
- 13
- Country
- Location
as long as there are 'no strings attached' which i think are not, it is ok - we shd be grateful to India for their gesture of goodwill !it is little steps like these which can turn the 'tide' in our relationship!
Siddi Gal Kiti hai !
Well said. India & Pak must help each other whenever they can.
Oye , dushman hi nahi hoga to dushmani kis se karenge ? !!
GUNNER
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Jun 2, 2010
- Messages
- 1,489
- Reaction score
- 0
- Country
- Location
Pakistan accepts India aid, but no real disaster diplomacy
NEW DELHI - India said on Tuesday that arch-rival Pakistan had accepted its offer of flood aid, but analysts say this piecemeal attempt at disaster diplomacy will not help improve relations between the two sides.
Pakistan's floods, which began over a month ago, have submerged a fifth of the country and left around 6 million people homeless in one of the world's biggest humanitarian crises of recent years.
But despite a shortage of funds hampering Islamabad's ability to provide relief to the millions in need, Pakistan had delayed deciding whether to accept $5 million in aid from New Delhi due to historical tensions between the two neighbours.
"Pakistan has conveyed its deep appreciation of India's offer of assistance," Indian Foreign Minister S.M. Krishna told parliament. "Pakistan requested on Aug 27 that India may channel its contribution to the flood victims through the U.N."
Krishna added that, given the scale of the disaster, India would increase its donation to $25 million from the $5 million it had originally offered.
Divided Kashmir remains at the heart of the dispute between India and Pakistan, with both sides claiming the Himalayan region in full. They have fought two of their three wars over it.
India accuses Pakistan of fuelling unrest in Kashmir, but Islamabad says it only lends moral support to what it calls Kashmir's independence movement, which has killed tens of thousands of people.
PIECEMEAL DIPLOMACY
The floods have inundated an area the size of Italy and aid workers have struggled to respond to the needs of millions of people who urgently need clean water, food, shelter and medical assistance.
The United Nations says donors have come good on around 63 percent of the $459 million needed in flood relief over the next three months, and so far only a fraction of those who need aid have received it.
Analysts say Pakistani authorities have been concerned about how their acceptance of Indian aid will play out nationally, but add that possible pressure from the United States may have played a role in Islamabad finally accepting the money.
U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton earlier this month said she hoped Pakistan would accept the aid and show that "despite years of misunderstanding and conflicts and threats ... in the face of a natural disaster of this significance, the people of India and Pakistan can come together".
But analysts say the signals by both sides show neither is serious about using this opportunity to improve relations.
Some experts have criticised New Delhi for delaying its offer of aid, which came almost two weeks after the floods, and for publically announcing its gesture rather than donating through the United Nations, a more modest approach.
Others have criticised Islamabad for dithering.
"I think the churlishness with which the aid has been accepted - it wasn't accepted for weeks and then Pakistan won't accept directly but only through the U.N. - has undermined any possible diplomatic advantages," said Ajai Sahni, executive director of the Institute for Conflict Management in New Delhi.
"It shows the whole kind of scoring of points that is typical of Indo-Pak relations."
NEW DELHI - India said on Tuesday that arch-rival Pakistan had accepted its offer of flood aid, but analysts say this piecemeal attempt at disaster diplomacy will not help improve relations between the two sides.
Pakistan's floods, which began over a month ago, have submerged a fifth of the country and left around 6 million people homeless in one of the world's biggest humanitarian crises of recent years.
But despite a shortage of funds hampering Islamabad's ability to provide relief to the millions in need, Pakistan had delayed deciding whether to accept $5 million in aid from New Delhi due to historical tensions between the two neighbours.
"Pakistan has conveyed its deep appreciation of India's offer of assistance," Indian Foreign Minister S.M. Krishna told parliament. "Pakistan requested on Aug 27 that India may channel its contribution to the flood victims through the U.N."
Krishna added that, given the scale of the disaster, India would increase its donation to $25 million from the $5 million it had originally offered.
Divided Kashmir remains at the heart of the dispute between India and Pakistan, with both sides claiming the Himalayan region in full. They have fought two of their three wars over it.
India accuses Pakistan of fuelling unrest in Kashmir, but Islamabad says it only lends moral support to what it calls Kashmir's independence movement, which has killed tens of thousands of people.
PIECEMEAL DIPLOMACY
The floods have inundated an area the size of Italy and aid workers have struggled to respond to the needs of millions of people who urgently need clean water, food, shelter and medical assistance.
The United Nations says donors have come good on around 63 percent of the $459 million needed in flood relief over the next three months, and so far only a fraction of those who need aid have received it.
Analysts say Pakistani authorities have been concerned about how their acceptance of Indian aid will play out nationally, but add that possible pressure from the United States may have played a role in Islamabad finally accepting the money.
U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton earlier this month said she hoped Pakistan would accept the aid and show that "despite years of misunderstanding and conflicts and threats ... in the face of a natural disaster of this significance, the people of India and Pakistan can come together".
But analysts say the signals by both sides show neither is serious about using this opportunity to improve relations.
Some experts have criticised New Delhi for delaying its offer of aid, which came almost two weeks after the floods, and for publically announcing its gesture rather than donating through the United Nations, a more modest approach.
Others have criticised Islamabad for dithering.
"I think the churlishness with which the aid has been accepted - it wasn't accepted for weeks and then Pakistan won't accept directly but only through the U.N. - has undermined any possible diplomatic advantages," said Ajai Sahni, executive director of the Institute for Conflict Management in New Delhi.
"It shows the whole kind of scoring of points that is typical of Indo-Pak relations."
omg are some people here suggesting that India is behind pak floods?
Gosh we are becoming like BJP government of the 90s where everything was blamed on ISI hands down.
Dont give India so much respect. It does not command so much authority on over territory.
Gosh we are becoming like BJP government of the 90s where everything was blamed on ISI hands down.
Dont give India so much respect. It does not command so much authority on over territory.
yes even i want to see a court case i dont know why pakistani establishment is not doing it why doesnt some patriotic pakistani citizen do it on their behalf some sort of legal action there are many here on this forum
GentlemanObserver
FULL MEMBER
- Joined
- Aug 9, 2010
- Messages
- 1,393
- Reaction score
- 0
- Country
- Location
A newb has more common-sense that some senior members here. I commend your way of thinking!
BTW, to all the nay sayers and flamers. We have already accepted the aid. So please give it a rest!
I appreciate, but the those in the military and security apparatus of BOTH the countries think otherwise.
Kinetic
BANNED
- Joined
- Feb 12, 2010
- Messages
- 11,200
- Reaction score
- -33
Thats not good. If aid is coming through UN than its not labeled as Indian because the money will be handed over in whole amount.
This 'Pak media' might by the Daily Mail and nation.com.pk. They are as good as Ahmed Qureshi and Moin Ansari, always spreading hatred. I have read few 'editorials' of the Nation written by Shireen Mazari where he accusing everyone from India, USA to Israel for everything happens in Pakistan and many other 'views' like India's poverty etc etc. The daily mail? Nothing to say!!
This 'Pak media' might by the Daily Mail and nation.com.pk. They are as good as Ahmed Qureshi and Moin Ansari, always spreading hatred. I have read few 'editorials' of the Nation written by Shireen Mazari where he accusing everyone from India, USA to Israel for everything happens in Pakistan and many other 'views' like India's poverty etc etc. The daily mail? Nothing to say!!
Last edited:
salman nedian
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Jun 18, 2007
- Messages
- 1,374
- Reaction score
- 0
This is the reason why Indian aid should not be accepted. 5 million$ are not a very big amount. We the People of Pakistan can generate an extra 5 million$ guys.
Coltsfan
BANNED
- Joined
- Jul 12, 2010
- Messages
- 904
- Reaction score
- -2
I am sure you the people of Pakistan, can generate $ 5 Million, but even then the Indian $5 million would be extra that could be used. At this time when waters are receding and affected people need most help, every penny counts. Indians and Pakistanis have till eternity to engage in useless bickering.
Similar threads
