It doesnt work that way in the real world if not do you think we would be having soo many Afghanis in our country?
Since when did you fall down in the real world from the high horse of humanity you were riding?
Yes usually but the reality is they havent been...
Pointless.
Giving green ids will magically make them Pak loving law abiding citizens?
Money! If they can run our business as so many have been crying...How do you think punishable people got their hands that deep?
Giving them green IDs will make them law abiding ?
Do you have any clue how many Pakistanis are tax evaders? Most Pakistanis who make bucketloads of money through business don't pay a penny to FBR.
In case you did not care to read the whole report, those Pakistanis were against the award of citizenship to the Afghans.
Moreover it looks like you want tax paying law abiding patriotic Pakistani businessmen to keep on crying and suffering---and at the same time allow anti-Pakistan elements to do what they want at will.
You are so desperate you even picked EU migration policy? Sweden isnt Afghanistan's neighbour!
You said we can't kick refugees because of international laws. I showed you that not only we did but others like Sweden also did.
There was nothing left for you to reply, so you made a useless and hollow statement instead.
Now talk of desperation
You mean to say prior to refugee problems our feudal lords and landlords had no access to guns nor owned any which they used for badmashi? Really?
How old are you?
Brings a landlords firearm and a law and order issue in an Afghan refugee thread and says it's a civil war.
How old are you or let me rephrase how confused are you?
.We CANT meddle with Refugees they are protected under human rights BS laws!
I already showed you that we were kicking them out till the new PM came.
This blackmail wont continue. Iran kicked all of Afghan refugees out so must we.
State comes first. International law(blackmail) can take a hike.
Civil war is any war within the land...FATA and Balochistan are examples of civil war by definition! When tribal wars occur that too by definition is a civil war...Might not be as big as the only example people know (American civil war) but it is a civil war!
You should learn to properly read what you are about to quote before jumping on your keyboard to reply.
I am talking about real civil war like one in FATA/Balochistan.
THEN you will be able to deal with them coz they will have Pakistani citizenship and are not under INTERNATIONAL LAWS which govern refugees!
They claim Pakistani land from Khyber till Attock as Afghan land.
Hate Pakistan from the bottom of their hearts.
Involved in most crimes.
And THEN you want us to grant them citizenship? Might as well award Nerendra Modi and Jogi Addittyanath with Pakistani citizenship while you are at it.
And no, you WONT be able to deal with them as they wouldn't be distinguishable from the ordinary folk and will hide under the charade of patriotism.
We kicked 600000 of them already out, it's far easier and safer option.
The fact of the matter is we CAN and SHOULD deal / help our citizens coz we can
If you really want to HELP them then let me inform you that THEY want Afghan refugees out, and they oppose grant of citizenship to Afghans.
It's better we listen to their concerns as they are our own.
Kind of shows your mentality more than mine!
No, it shows your mentality since you always said if they are against the idea of giving Afghans citizenship then we must "deal with" them. It is clearly visible what you mean when you say
"I thought the army was dealing with them" ...
I on the other hand always talked about listening to their concerns as they, according to me, are our own.
THEN you will be able to deal with them coz they will have Pakistani citizenship and are not under INTERNATIONAL LAWS which govern refugees!
Yeah deal with people who will be able to infiltrate Armed forces, police, civil institutions, bureaucracy and parliament ....sure it will be much easier to deal with them then....after we let these Pak-hating people get in these sensitive institutions in place of our own patriotic children...Then the real subversion will start.
Sigh...Why did I even think children on this forum can be reasoned with when they cant even grasp simple words of English and simple concepts at international levels?!
Saw the "quality" of your arguments, if they can be categorized as such. Must say, I am unimpressed.
Now you resort to personal attacks after you failed to bring any solid argument in favor of your stance. It is useless since you are perhaps unaware of the simple fact that morality and humanity have no business in the matters of the state. That is the practice worldwide, only those who are ruthless survive, the softer ones perish.
Imran Khan made a blunder but finally, sanity prevailed in the corridors of power and they decided not to give citizenship to the Afghans---a bad news for you.
https://www.dawn.com/news/1434169
@Desert Fox
Good bye
