What's new

Pakistan has friends in Kabul

Shahzaz ud din

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jun 12, 2017
Messages
7,877
Reaction score
14
Country
Pakistan
Location
Canada

SHARE TWEET
Pakistan has friends in Kabul
By Taimur Shamil
Published: January 25, 2018
106SHARES
SHARE TWEET EMAIL
1617144-afghanroboticsgirlsreuters-1516859430-865-640x480.jpg

PHOTO: REUTERS

1617144-afghanroboticsgirlsreuters-1516859430-865-160x120.jpg
1617144-taimurshamilnew-1516814537-994-160x120.jpg

Thousands of innocent lives lost and millions lost to the economy is Pakistan’s story of being a frontline ally of the US war on terror. But Pakistan isn’t alone. Its neighbouring country Afghanistan perhaps has suffered more. In terms of loss of human life and economy, the numbers of victims of the war on terror are different in both countries but the pain is equally intense. After returning from my recent trip to Kabul, many people that I met back home were concerned about Pakistan’s image in Kabul — opportunities for cooperation and the intensity of anti-Pakistan sentiment in Afghanistan. My answer to them was simple. Pakistan, socially and politically, has friends in Kabul and the opportunities for Pakistan are many, if we try.

Here are the facts: in terms of social relations, every day between 2,000 to 3,000 visas are issued from Kabul alone to Pakistan. The numbers of visas issued from the rest of Pakistani consulates are additional, that may vary from 800 to 1,000 as per Pakistani officials. The Afghans who travel on these visas are usually travelling for health and educational reasons. The patients who travel to Pakistan feel more comfortable in Pakistan than any other country. The reasons being obvious, most of them share the same culture, language, religion and most of the times clans and tribes as well. Also that many of them have been frequently travelling to Pakistan for the last many years. Majority of them have their families in Pakistan that either migrated during the Soviet-Afghan war or later during the last decade. These Afghans who come to Pakistan also find Pakistan economically affordable as compared to other countries in the region. It is to be kept in mind that most of the Afghans live in abject poverty and lack basic health facilities. Therefore, Pakistan is the logical and economical option.

Kabul taking steps to cut peace deal with Pakistan: Ghani

Interestingly almost every third person that I met, Dari (Persian spoken in Afghanistan) dominated, Kabul could speak and understand Urdu. Most of the people who could speak Urdu were young Afghans. They had either been educated or had spent considerable time doing jobs in Pakistan. They have good memories attached to the neighbouring country which welcomed and hosted them.

After meeting the young Afghans, I realised that when it comes to Pakistan-Afghanistan relations, higher education is Pakistan’s strength. While Pakistan has itself improved the quality of higher education, it has worked on giving scholarships to Afghan students who want to pursue their academic ambitions. Islamabad is generally multi-linguistic city and multi-ethnic as well. One can find Hazaras, Persian speaking, and Pakhtuns in large numbers in different universities of the capital. This naturally gives the Afghan students a conducive environment to blend in.

Last year the Higher Education Commission announced scholarships to 3,000 Afghan students and a large number of those are females. These young students are the bridges and ambassadors of peace between Pakistan and Afghanistan, and a huge potential for the future of democracy and peace in Afghanistan. The tapping of this potential needs the Foreign Office’s attention now more than ever.

A lot of Pakistanis are concerned about anti-Pakistan sentiments brewing in Kabul. The concerns are, no doubt, justified and show Pakistan’s concern and urge to improve its relations with the people of Afghanistan. After all, Pakistan has hosted millions of Afghan refugees over the decades and expects that the refugees become the ambassadors of goodwill between the two countries when they return to their home country. For that Pakistan too needs consideration on smooth transition of refugees from Pakistani soil to Afghanistan. It doesn’t need to be rough and loaded with blame. That ruins the very spirit with which Pakistan hosted them for decades.

In Kabul, the sentiments regarding Pakistan are mixed. The anti-Pakistan sentiment propaganda is over-blown and exaggerated. There are many people, especially young, who want to have better relations with Pakistan. The anti-Pakistan sentiment, which cannot be outrightly denied, but certainly does not require exaggeration, needs careful consideration.

The people who become a part of small anti-Pakistan rallies in Kabul and surroundings are usually funded and supported by the local intelligence agencies, foreign-funded groups and few local political factions which work for their vested interests. The majority is not the part of it. If things are overlooked the anti-Pakistan sentiment has the potential to be exploited by those that Pakistan has been wary of. So what should be done?

Kabul urges Pakistani Ulema role in ending Afghan war

Proactive diplomacy is the answer. The areas of convergence between Pakistan and Afghanistan are many. The Afghan youth and the parliamentarians who have spent years in Pakistan are the probable saviours of the day. Terrorism, extremism and hatred are common enemies. That can be overcome by devising and speeding up the Foreign Office’s well-planned outreach programmes. Though the Pakistan Embassy in Kabul and consulates elsewhere in Afghanistan are active, it is in Pakistan’s national interest to have a proactive approach in reaching out to the youth in Afghanistan.

Published in The Express Tribune, January 25th, 2018.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.


Read more: Allies , Analysis , Editorial
 
. . .
2,000 to 3,000 visas are issued from Kabul alone to Pakistan. The numbers of visas issued from the rest of Pakistani consulates are additional, that may vary from 800 to 1,000 as per Pakistani officials.
Wow that,s why we were not able to control suicide bombings and other terrorism related stuff.Issuing such a large no of visas without any background checks??
 
.
Wow that,s why we were not able to control suicide bombings and other terrorism related stuff.Issuing such a large no of visas without any background checks??


These kids are coming to Pakistan to get an education. Conflating them with terrorists is absurd. And there is a lengthy visa process. Not to mention, very stiff competition for each spot.
 
. .
These kids are coming to Pakistan to get an education. Conflating them with terrorists is absurd. And there is a lengthy visa process. Not to mention, very stiff competition for each spot.
Afghanistan is an ENEMY STATE to Pakistan since 1947. PERIOD!!!! (Except for a few years in the 1990's).
Have Pakistani's forget what her Muslim neighbour tried to do to her in the early days of Pakistan's history?

Even if there were NO terrorism emanating from Afghanistan, it would still be prudent to have stringent border controls and visa checks from a nation which does not accept Pakistan's right to EXIST.

(Of course this is not aimed at ALL Afghans, but as a collective Afghanistan for the most part of Pakistan's history has been anti-Pakistani).
 
.
even if we have friends or some neutrals in Afghanistan, the Ghani princely state isnt
 
.
These kids are coming to Pakistan to get an education. Conflating them with terrorists is absurd. And there is a lengthy visa process. Not to mention, very stiff competition for each spot.
Yea the same way we issued visas to afghan refugees and did not conflate them with terrorists but they indeed were terrorists wearing the masks of refugees. Those so called students(teenagers at least) can be potential assets of terrorists in information gathering etc.Hence all should be monitored constantly.

Afghanistan is an ENEMY STATE to Pakistan since 1947. PERIOD!!!! (Except for a few years in the 1990's).
Have Pakistani's forget what her Muslim neighbour tried to do to her in the early days of Pakistan's history?

Even if there were NO terrorism emanating from Afghanistan, it would still be prudent to have stringent border controls and visa checks from a nation which does not accept Pakistan's right to EXIST.

(Of course this is not aimed at ALL Afghans, but as a collective Afghanistan for the most part of Pakistan's history has been anti-Pakistani).
Yeah dude that was my point.They did not accept and still not accept our existence.They are hypocrites of class 1 degree.They get all the benefits from our country and yet deep in heart love india and USA.These unthankul people are known for biting the hand which feeds them.90% afghans i met online are full of hatred towards pakistan and few met in real life were afraid to speak crap in front of me as they were physically present in pakistan.Their country is cursed from the beginning getting invaded by one country after another.They are used to live like that without any morals and dignity.What,s the purpose of this member @Sarah Ahmadzai here?See her twitter page and read her tweets showing her hatred for pakistan https://twitter.com/Sarah_Ahmadzai
 
Last edited:
.
Yea the same way we issued visas to afghan refugees and did not conflate them with terrorists but they indeed were terrorists wearing the masks of refugees. Those so called students(teenagers at least) can be potential assets of terrorists in information gathering etc.Hence all should be monitored constantly.


cbJFcB5.gif


So ISI should be monitoring Afghan teenagers? :partay: :partay:
 
. .
yes as long as they pose threat our national security


Many things pose a threat to Pakistan's national security, Afghan teenagers is the least of my worries. Having said that, I respect your views.


Afghanistan is an ENEMY STATE to Pakistan since 1947. PERIOD!!!! (Except for a few years in the 1990's).
Have Pakistani's forget what her Muslim neighbour tried to do to her in the early days of Pakistan's history?


Don't worry Pakistanis won't let Afghans forget their historical mistakes but the world isn't black and white.


Even if there were NO terrorism emanating from Afghanistan, it would still be prudent to have stringent border controls and visa checks from a nation which does not accept Pakistan's right to EXIST.

(Of course this is not aimed at ALL Afghans, but as a collective Afghanistan for the most part of Pakistan's history has been anti-Pakistani).


Without a doubt, it was a mistake to leave the border open and one that has cost us dearly in blood and treasure.
 
Last edited:
.
Afghanistan is an ENEMY STATE to Pakistan since 1947. PERIOD!!!! (Except for a few years in the 1990's).
Have Pakistani's forget what her Muslim neighbour tried to do to her in the early days of Pakistan's history?

Even if there were NO terrorism emanating from Afghanistan, it would still be prudent to have stringent border controls and visa checks from a nation which does not accept Pakistan's right to EXIST.

(Of course this is not aimed at ALL Afghans, but as a collective Afghanistan for the most part of Pakistan's history has been anti-Pakistani).
And what we did to that Afghanistan when they were not our Enemy?...
 
.
Those so called students(teenagers at least) can be potential assets of terrorists in information gathering etc.Hence all should be monitored constantly.
According to you, afghan students can be potential assets of terrorists in information gathering. What about the extremists who are residing in your country.
Recently a second year student Faheem Ashraf of New Islamia Public College Shabqadar – opened fire at his principal Sareer Ahmed after the two argued over the student's absence from college to attend the Faizabad sit-in in the federal capital in November, police said on Monday.

https://www.geo.tv/latest/178247-college-principal-killed-by-student-laid-to-rest-in-charsadda
 
.
And what we did to that Afghanistan when they were not our Enemy?...
Pray, tell me when they were not Pakistan's enemy? Do you mean when the Afghan Taliban governed in Kabul?
Since 1947 to date, Afghanistan has NOT and does NOT accept Pakistan's right to exist.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom