How if you do not accept these very commands yourself first and questions thier validity and the sincerety of those who would implement them?
There's a difference. Acceptance is of freewill.
"There is no compulsion in religion" (The holy Quran).
How can I ignore this command of Allah's?
If it is wrong then it is also wrong to say to people to abide the laws of the state. After all these very laws also FORCE the public to abide by and to follow. Not it is. there is also no FREE WILL.
Yes but these laws are something that the local populace has granted a right to the governing body.
You break the laws of Islam by forcing someone to pray.
"There is no compulsion in religion".
This clearly shows that you are having the extremist tendency as well. Just because you can not make a person to believe you by argument and logic you are delivering a vieled warning. This is not right Asim!
It's hardly a warning, but a friendly advice. And the only thig I would talk to him about was on personal conduct and hurling comments onto members. The same way I would caution others from talking trash on him.
But here, I gave an example of how would just do the opposite despite of whatever political message he would express. Even though I can suppress it, I won't. The same is expected out of the governing body. Just as me suppressing his message would be an abuse of my power (no matter how right I may be), the use of mutawwa police is an abuse of the governing body's power (no matter how right it may be).
This question is again to you as well. How you are implementing the secular laws? BY FORCE and STATE appratus. Thats what the Khilafah or what ever you want to call it would implement its laws.
So lemme get this straight.
To not abide by the law of the state you're a criminal for example, murderer, thief, rapist.
To not abide by Islam, you're a non-Muslim.
Do you seriously want to propagate a government where a non-Muslim is considered as bad as a criminal, a murderer, a theif, a rapist?
The laws are enforced by the support of the local people. How will you ever get support from a Muslim majority for such insane governance?
Asa for those who do not want to abide or be a muslim, they are free to go and embrace to thier will. They would have same choice as the so called MULLAHS have in this secular society.
Kashif
How about encouraging Islam, ever thought of that? Encourage it, but don't force it by law. You'd find people more receptive to Allah's message than to your coercsion. Unless you, yourself have doubts about the power of Allah's message.