Pakistan fence to seal off Afghan border - Al Jazeera English ( Video Report)

[El Sidd]

no.we are done with this zaleel kaum.

send them back home and if they try to cross the border illegally send them to Allah and let him decide their destiny.

Afganistan is a namak haram nation

Why be so narrow minded?
Where you see desolation i see opportunity

 

[Sully3]

Why be so narrow minded?
Where you see desolation i see opportunity

not narrow minded just know Afghanis inside out.

we took 12 million refugees they should be loyal to pakistan, infact they became indias dogs barking every time they got orders from new delhi.

i hope one country or another bombs afganistan to the stone ages once and for all.

Namak Haram Afghani is not our doost.

 

[El Sidd]

not narrow minded just know Afghanis inside out.

we took 12 million refugees they should be loyal to pakistan, infact they became indias dogs barking every time they got orders from new delhi.

i hope one country or another bombs afganistan to the stone ages once and for all.

Namak Haram Afghani is not our doost.

You are just caught up in Brexit fever.
I am just glad blokes like you do not handle our foreign affairs.
Learn to respect others. Afghanistan is a complex society which only Pakistani nation can understand and streamline it to their advantage.

 

[Morpheus]

You are just caught up in Brexit fever.
I am just glad blokes like you do not handle our foreign affairs.
Learn to respect others. Afghanistan is a complex society which only Pakistani nation can understand and streamline it to their advantage.

If a car keeps breaking down, and you have to keep spending money to just keep it running, then its time to get rid of that car. No point in wasting resources on something that is sucking you dry.

 

[El Sidd]

If a car keeps breaking down, and you have to keep spending money to just keep it running, then its time to get rid of that car. No point in wasting resources on something that is sucking you dry.

Geopolitics is not a commodity.

 

[Morpheus]

Geopolitics is not a commodity.

The point is not about commodity, it about the principle. You can apply the principle in just about any scenario from daily tasks to long term plan, to even state security. If something costs more then its worth, it not worth spending resource (money, time, people, etc.) on it.

 

[Verve]

Pakistan has 2 options

1) Educate the Afghans and cultivate the historical relationship
2) Isolate the Afghans and suffer the consequences

I would agree with this. We shouldn't isolate a needy muslim neighbour just because of a few thousand nut-jobs claiming to control the whole country when in reality they do not.

Fencing is need of the hour however before the education can commence.

 

[313ghazi]

Pakistan has 2 options

1) Educate the Afghans and cultivate the historical relationship
2) Isolate the Afghans and suffer the consequences

I both agree and disagree. This fence is a requirement now because of decades of failure in foreign policy. We haven't built any links with the Afghan people, only with groups and power players, much like the colonialists of the past. We had a massive opportunity during Taliban regime, we wasted it. We had another one when re-patriating people. we should have offered people the chance to leave alone and take their family in a years time if they felt it was safe. We could have helped setup schools, or other minor facilities in the areas our refugees were moving too. We could have liased with Taliban to ask for security for returning refugees, we could have provided seed for farming, all sorts of little support. Instead we push them out the door with a kick up the backside for good measure!

 

[Dark-Destroyer]

Pakistan has 2 options

1) Educate the Afghans and cultivate the historical relationship
2) Isolate the Afghans and suffer the consequences

The consequences can't be worse than what we have been suffering while calling them brothers so we rather call them our enemies atlease we won't feel hard done by because that's what they are our enemies

 

[El Sidd]

I both agree and disagree. This fence is a requirement now because of decades of failure in foreign policy. We haven't built any links with the Afghan people, only with groups and power players, much like the colonialists of the past. We had a massive opportunity during Taliban regime, we wasted it. We had another one when re-patriating people. we should have offered people the chance to leave alone and take their family in a years time if they felt it was safe. We could have helped setup schools, or other minor facilities in the areas our refugees were moving too. We could have liased with Taliban to ask for security for returning refugees, we could have provided seed for farming, all sorts of little support. Instead we push them out the door with a kick up the backside for good measure!

Stronger border policy is the need of the hour.
Having said that, haven't we learned that military action alone is not the solution.

Please do not call it a foreign policy failure. Call that what it is a failure of political will to own the strategy.

The consequences can't be worse than what we have been suffering while calling them brothers so we rather call them our enemies atlease we won't feel hard done by because that's what they are our enemies

Pakistan will never declare Afghans or Afghanistan as enemy state or enemy.

 

[Sully3]

I would agree with this. We shouldn't isolate a needy muslim neighbour just because of a few thousand nut-jobs claiming to control the whole country when in reality they do not.

Fencing is need of the hour however before the education can commence.

We took in 12 million afghan refugees during the soviet war what did we get in return for that.

other then empty promises by the muslim world that they would support us financially for taking so many afghans inn and sharing our home with them.

in return we got bomb blasts, friendships with india, terrorist shelters.

bro i hope that country gets bombed into the stone age because thats what namak haram afghanis deserve

 

[YeBeWarned]

Seal it ........... Just Seal it ... (Micheal Jackson Style)

 

[SHAH820]

Pakistan has 2 options

1) Educate the Afghans and cultivate the historical relationship
2) Isolate the Afghans and suffer the consequences

1)lol educate the afghan and how you are going to do that when they support terrorism when they are involved in attacks in pakistan when they refuse to remove indian terrorist center(embassies) from afghanistan near pakistan when they protest to those who have supported more population of afghanistan then afghanistan itself who have fight a war for them and asked nothing in return we have supplied arms, money to their army (free) but they are like their rulers namak haram

2)isolate afgahn? are far as i know US army are in afganistan to fight terrorism,almost all trade of afghanistan goes through pakistan even to india with half taxes on them. our trade goes to central via afghanistan cause we support afghanistan (trade taxes and duties goes to afghan government ) despite having more safe and reliable route iran

we only securing our borders if you are ok with killing of people in terrorism through afganistan you can go to afghanistan and can live their for us we have our people to save

 

[Dark-Destroyer]

Stronger border policy is the need of the hour.
Having said that, haven't we learned that military action alone is not the solution.

Please do not call it a foreign policy failure. Call that what it is a failure of political will to own the strategy.



Pakistan will never declare Afghans or Afghanistan as enemy state or enemy.

Wheater it is declared or not doesn't mean the reality is hidden from us we know know who our enemies are.the people of Pakistan know - and they have shown how they valued pakistans hospitality so what more do we need to see

 

[RazaGujjar]

Educate them.
You very well know we are stuck with them no matter what. So instead of presenting them to the forces of anti Pakistan elements, we should face the reality and just mainstream them one way or the other.
Isolating them is just inviting trouble.

Why should we worry about educating Afghans when we cannot educate our own? Seal the border.