Mismanagement cause of power crisis
Ex-WAPDA chief says IPPs producing below capacity
Friday, May 30, 2008
LAHORE: Gross mismanagement of WAPDA affairs has caused power shortage as is evident from current electricity production of 11,000 megawatts against installed generation capacity of 18,000MW and the demand for 15,000MW.
Former WAPDA chairman Lt-Gen (Retd) Zulfiqar Khan stated this during a panel interview with The News and Daily Jang.
He said independent power producers had an installed electricity generation capacity of 6,500MW while they were supplying 4,000-5,000MW to the Water and Power Development Authority (WAPDA).
Similarly, he added WAPDAs thermal units with an installed capacity of 5,000MW produced only 2,500-2,700MW of electricity daily. He mentioned that when he was WAPDA chairman the production from its thermal units was more than 3,700MW.
He said the hydro-electric generation capacity was 6,500MW, out of which only 4,000MW were being generated, but added lower hydropower production was understandable as it was linked to water released from reservoirs.
He claimed the IPPs were not producing electricity to their full capacity as they were not being paid to cover even the cost of fuel they required for their generators.
WAPDAs financial woes, he said, were due to its inability to recover dues from influential quarters. WAPDA dues have exceeded Rs130 billion, he said and claimed when he left WAPDA it had a positive balance of Rs13 billion. The only way to recover dues was to cut power supply to defaulters, he suggested.
He said the cost of electricity production had increased because the country was dependent on imported furnace oil whose prices had skyrocketed.
About the potential of Thar coal, he said it had not been exploited during the last five years, adding coal-based power projects or hydro-electric projects were the only viable solution to the ever-increasing energy needs of the country.
He deplored that all projects launched under Water Vision 2000 had been unduly delayed. Had those projects been completed on time, they would have added 1,200MW of cheap hydro power to the system.
There is a need to correct the hydro-electric and thermal generation mix. He said the cost of power generation from Mangla and Tarbela came to 10-11 paisa per unit and that of Ghazi Barotha project was Rs2.60 per unit while the fuel cost of furnace oil-fired generators was 11 US cents per unit plus other expenses of 6 to 7 cents.
Gen Zulfiqar deplored the decision to put the Kalabagh dam project on the back burner and said the country just needed $1 billion in foreign exchange to cover the cost of consultants and electric generators.
The balance amount of $5 billion, he added, could have been arranged locally as it related mainly to cement, concrete and steel.
He said the cost of the project could be recovered in five years, adding the genuine grievances of provinces, which opposed the project, should have been addressed to pave the way for the construction of the project.
He was of the view that Karachi Electric Supply Cos privatisation needed to be reversed, particularly after the buyer failed to make promised investment of $450 million for upgrading its systems.
Separation of the Pakistan Electric Power Co (PEPCO) from WAPDA was a wrong step as most of the WAPDA activities were placed under the chairmanship of water and power secretary, he said.
Mismanagement cause of power crisis