Pakistan asks India to hand over Jinnah House

[Peshwa]

Just like India having embarrassing oh embassy in Kabul but have multiple on Pakistan border as well

Just to be clear, a country can have only ONE embassy, usually in the capital.
The rest are consulates.
Please know the difference. India cannot have multiple embassy's in a country!

 

[RealNapster]

Since Enemy property act of 2016 is accepted and passed by the parliament, Jinnah family members or legal heirs can't claim its right as the act prevents the vested properties from falling into the hands of legal heirs of those who moved to other countries.

Your country. Your Rules.

I just wanted to say that this "demolishing" is not going to help you (or your ego) in either way. and i think i said it.

 

[Peshwa]

The property belongs to members of Jinnahs bloodline. Namely the Wadia's.
Pakistani claims are baseless.

Your country. Your Rules.

I just wanted to say that this "demolishing" is not going to help you (or your ego) in either way. and i think i said it.

Why should anyone demolish the property?! That's just plain stupid.
BJP needs to get its dogs under check. some have been barking a lot these days, much to the inconvenience of the rest of India.

 

[Qutb-ud-din Aybak]

All Mosques are managed by Muslims & those mosques which were built over Hindu Temples should be given back to Hindus.

All temples in Pakistan are managed by Hindus.
Mosques demolished in India should be reconstructed and culprits punished.

 

[foxtrot1]

So was your Ancestor's , I mean, born in Now-a-days "Pakistan".

I think you can do better then just trolling. Your time worth more Sir. spent it in good ways.

it's the most preferable logic presented

 

[RealNapster]

The property belongs to members of Jinnahs bloodline. Namely the Wadia's.
Pakistani claims are baseless.

Pakistan's claim is based on "NATIONAL HERITAGE" basis. not some "personal claim".

Why should anyone demolish the property?! That's just plain stupid.
BJP needs to get its dogs under check. some have been barking a lot these days, much to the inconvenience of the rest of India.

Bro you want to keep it just keep it. turn it into a museum or library or something else but "honorable". but when we hear voices of "demolish it" , it's simply insane. as Jinnah belong's to Combined India. You can not deny the fact that your and mine soil Produced a Leader of such caliber.

Do You know Baghat singh is considered as "Shaheed" in Pakistan, we have road named after him in Lahore. because

1. he fought for Combined India's independence.

2. He belonged to this land.

the only thing which we are asking is "respect that place".

 

[kmc_chacko]

Your country. Your Rules.

I just wanted to say that this "demolishing" is not going to help you (or your ego) in either way. and i think i said it.

Did anybody supported that Shiva Sena's MPs request ? every MP/MLA can put forward his point in Parliament, that's what we call as democracy. But it doesn't mean that every wish will be granted.

if, demolition was in minds of GoI, then long ago itself it would have demolished, they would have not cared for South Court.

The property belongs to members of Jinnahs bloodline. Namely the Wadia's.
Pakistani claims are baseless.

Why should anyone demolish the property?! That's just plain stupid.
BJP needs to get its dogs under check. some have been barking a lot these days, much to the inconvenience of the rest of India.

I approve that.

Pakistan's claim is based on "NATIONAL HERITAGE" basis. not some "personal claim".

Bro you want to keep it just keep it. turn it into a museum or library or something else but "honorable". but when we hear voices of "demolish it" , it's simply insane. as Jinnah belong's to Combined India. You can not deny the fact that your and mine soil Produced a Leader of such caliber.

Do You know Baghat singh is considered as "Shaheed" in Pakistan, we have road named after him in Lahore. because

1. he fought for Combined India's independence.

2. He belonged to this land.

the only thing which we are asking is "respect that place".

Don't worry about a Jinnha House it will be kept honorably.

there will be very few takers for that SS MP.

Few years back they wanted to throw out Non-Marathis from Maharastra, did that happen? Instead Marathis showed real place for SS and put them in to a position from where they can bark but can't bite.

 

[Ashesh]

I edited Post. read now

Nankana Sahib is Important for Sikhs, so i think handing it over to India will be the "human way".

All temples in Pakistan are managed by Hindus.
Mosques demolished in India should be reconstructed and culprits punished.

Temples demolished, should be reconstructed. Temples on which Mosques were constructed in India & Pakistan. Those Mosques should be Demolished + culprits should be punished & Vise-versa. I am fine with it.

 

[RealNapster]

Nankana Sahib is Important for Sikhs, so i think handing it over to India will be the "human way".

You must be really dumb. i can see that.

NATIONAL HERITAGE
NATIONAL HERITAGE
NATIONAL HERITAGE
NATIONAL HERITAGE
NATIONAL HERITAGE

A thing belong's to our "father of the Nation". it's our National Heritage. we asked for it. India is a secular country (atleast you guys claim so), On what basis are you going to ask for Nankana ? And Nankana is not a "house", but a CITY.

You want us to give you a city ? Atleast, Logic to sahe wale use karo mere bhai..

Don't worry about a Jinnha House it will be kept honorably.

Thank You.

 

[Ashesh]

The property belongs to members of Jinnahs bloodline. Namely the Wadia's.
Pakistani claims are baseless.

Bro, are you aware of New Enemy Property act? If not Google & learn about it.

Why should anyone demolish the property?! That's just plain stupid.

BJP needs to get its dogs under check. some have been barking a lot these days, much to the inconvenience of the rest of India.

Indian Tax Payers money is spent on maintaining it. Why not demolish it & built a Hospital for Poor?

One can name it after Jinnah?

 

[Robinhood Pandey]

Mandir wahi banayenge

oh wait this is not the right thread

 

[YeBeWarned]

If Indians are very keen to demolish Jinnah House than at least make a Hospital for Poor people or a old home age ... I am sure Quaid-e-Azam will Understand and Poor and homeless old people will get some benefit from it, but the Accessories in the house must be returned to Pakistan

 

[NakedLunch]

In a future Hindutva maniac India the Taj Mahal would seem out of place. Pakistan should ask for that too. Indians need no reminders of their Islamic past.

 

[Ashesh]

Apparently, it's you.

I can list down many MONUMENTS OF IMPORTANCE TO HINDUS & SIKHS. They've been converted to MADRASSA'S, Mosques or are in Shambles.

Like you mentioned about Dleep Kumar House, India is protecting many such buldings as National Heritage.

Jinnah might be revered figure for you, not us.

You must be really dumb. i can see that.

NATIONAL HERITAGE
NATIONAL HERITAGE
NATIONAL HERITAGE
NATIONAL HERITAGE
NATIONAL HERITAGE

A thing belong's to our "father of the Nation". it's our National Heritage. we asked for it. India is a secular country (atleast you guys claim so), On what basis are you going to ask for Nankana ? And Nankana is not a "house", but a CITY.

You want us to give you a city ? Atleast, Logic to sahe wale use karo mere bhai..



Thank You.

 

[Indika]

The property belongs to members of Jinnahs bloodline. Namely the Wadia's.
Pakistani claims are baseless.

Exactly, not blood line alone but must be citizens of India.

Pakistan's claim is based on "NATIONAL HERITAGE" basis. not some "personal claim".

Jinnah has no importance in India. At the best hes considered as enemy , muslims of India will point him as the one who gave them a bad name.