'Over 10 million Karachiites missing in census': MQM-P, PSP reject results

[Syed Mukkarram]

I wonder how arabs feel when you tell them about your Syed linage while originally belonging to gutter cleaning chamars race of ganga? I bet they laugh their a** off. Wasim Akran doesn't earn living in Karachi you moron. He work in tv channel which earn ad revenues from all over Pakistan, mostly outside Karachi.

Yeah you cocksuckroach, but I dont know how it feels to be convert from Hinduism(Dalits) to Islam(Munafiqoon), you must be a product of raped by some Afghanis or Persians...

 

[defence_analyst]

Yeah you cocksuckroach, but I dont know how it feels to be convert from Hinduism(Dalits) to Islam(Munafiqoon), you must be a product of raped by some Afghanis or Persians...

How it feel to be cleaning gutters in Ganga and suddenly becoming Syed after changing name? I guess all of you were changed inside out, right my arab friend?

 

[Syed Mukkarram]

How it feel to be cleaning gutters in Ganga and suddenly becoming Syed after changing name? I guess all of you were changed inside out, right my arab friend?

IGNORE.....................................

 

[AUz]

The bold part just about sums up your post and intentions.

P.S. Karachi doesn't give a shit about your fake results either!





Bravo....!!

So when I dented your entire narrative and explained you how stupid you are for declaring census fake without any proof...and showed you how Karachi's population was never 25 million---you got taken by balls and had no come back.

So all you can do is to like one, don't discuss my arguments, and run away.

As expected

 

[Syed1.]

MQM/Muhajir bhaiya, ghutka wala etc same thing different labels. You can't explain how muhajir population growth could possibly be 250% when national average is 57% and now is projecting your own ethnic insecurities on to others.



I wonder how arabs feel when you tell them about your Syed linage while originally belonging to gutter cleaning chamars race of ganga? I bet they laugh their a** off. Wasim Akran doesn't earn living in Karachi you moron. He work in tv channel which earn ad revenues from all over Pakistan, mostly outside Karachi.



We know ground reality of Karachi and ethnic history. Muhajirs are only 7m even if Karachi is 30m. If you believe since 1998 muhajir growth rate was 250%, many times above national average 57% then only one biased here is you. Can't you bhaiyas use some logic for once? Even if Pakistan bring all biharis from Bangladesh muhajirs will not grow 250%.

And we know muhajirs are not 20% of Karachi population, its impossible. From 48% in 1998 they are likely 40% now but not much lower.

Chutiyay who the hell are you that you know ground reality??????

 

[Narcissist]

Born and grew up in Karachi for many many years before migrated to Canada where i met many many many Pakistanis Canadians who are mostly from Karachi.

Ahh So I was right. You do enjoy getting rear-ended by sikhs. That explains everything.

 

[Finer]

Ahh So I was right. You do enjoy getting rear-ended by sikhs. That explains everything.

Did something sexually abusive happen to you by Sikhs? Just curious to know since despite your sarcasm, you are having hard time masking your real pain through the repetitive explosive one might argue very disturbing mindset.

 

[Mav3rick]

So when I dented your entire narrative and explained you how stupid you are for declaring census fake without any proof...and showed you how Karachi's population was never 25 million---you got taken by balls and had no come back.

So all you can do is to like one, don't discuss my arguments, and run away.

As expected

Yes you dented my entire argument by a single line comment stating that all local and international surveys have been inaccurate. Yeah that just about demolishes the ground reality of Karachi's population that has grown at an unprecedented rate.

People like you have been denting and demolishing ground realities all my life. It is such an irony that a non-Karachiite wants not just to add his 2 cents but wants to establish the entire 'fact' about Karachi based solely on what he wants it to be.

 

[defence_analyst]

Yes you dented my entire argument by a single line comment stating that all local and international surveys have been inaccurate. Yeah that just about demolishes the ground reality of Karachi's population that has grown at an unprecedented rate.

People like you have been denting and demolishing ground realities all my life. It is such an irony that a non-Karachiite wants not just to add his 2 cents but wants to establish the entire 'fact' about Karachi based solely on what he wants it to be.

All that goes out of window when so called Karachi walas want population to be 25-30m which is only possible with migrations. But at the same time muhajir political hegemony over Karachi. This isn't how it works. Forget about me but read what this senior journalist from Karachi wrote in today column

"The Mohajir exclusionists forget that the greater the growth of population in Karachi, the worse will be the loss of the numerical strength of Mohajirs. Yet, the provisional results of census give all adversaries in Sindh an ‘opportunity’ to fuel their ethnic incompatibility, even though the fact is that Sindh has grown a little above the national average and its share in the overall population remains the same (23 percent). Indeed Karachi’s population growth has been stymied by bloody ethnic politics, lawlessness and the prolonged Rangers’ operations. In fact, a reverse migration could be observed during all these bloody years that made the lives of so many miserable."
https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/227485-Political-economy-of-demographics

To counter this point so called unbiased Karachi walas now are coming up with ridiculous muhajir growth figures which range between 150-250% over last 19 years compared to 57% national average. They want us to believe not only Karachi population is 25-30m but some how muhajirs still make 50% of population like in 1998. But of course at the same time ethnicity doesn't matter for Karachi walas and for proof they present themselves as supporters of PTI.

 

[AUz]

Yes you dented my entire argument by a single line comment stating that all local and international surveys have been inaccurate. Yeah that just about demolishes the ground reality of Karachi's population that has grown at an unprecedented rate.

People like you have been denting and demolishing ground realities all my life. It is such an irony that a non-Karachiite wants not just to add his 2 cents but wants to establish the entire 'fact' about Karachi based solely on what he wants it to be.

Dumbass, I've exactly pointed out that your main premise is wrong. There have been no surveys stating Karachi's population to be 25 million.

Read my post again here, you dimwit idiot (The red part highlighted for slow retards like yourself)

Lmaoooo

There are no "surveys" or "estimates" that say Karachi is 25 million.

ALL those surveys use Pakistan's 2011 housing survey as their "source"---the housing survey stated Karachi's population to be 23 million etc but that housing survey was disregarded as ineffective, and with huge disparities by the authorities that conducted the survey.

Hence official census was done independently without relying on the housing survey of 2011. Current census is the most comprehensive demographic study available in Pakistan. And that survey revealed that Karachi's population was around 17 million (Karachi+outskirts).

So stop harping about oh Karachi's 25 million population. It never was. It was something based on a housing survey that was declared unreliable by the very body conducting the survey due to mass irregularities and malpractices found. All foreign newspapers, estimates, and reports were based off of that housing survey which was proven to be wrong.

And again, the reason Lahore has over 10m population is because Lahore city and surrounding rural areas have been marked as "Lahore Urban" area under census and that's the population of Lahore+RURAL AREAS SURROUNDING LAHORE...which are many.

Other than you idiot karachites, nobody gives a shit about Karachi. Karachi is just another city of our dear homeland. So we don't have to conspire entire census to "take away resources" from the god-sent "Karachi"

 

[asif1986]

Either there has been reverse migration from karachi or its natural birth rate has dropped substantially.

 

[Mav3rick]

Dumbass, I've exactly pointed out that your main premise is wrong. There have been no surveys stating Karachi's population to be 25 million.

Read my post again here, you dimwit idiot (The red part highlighted for slow retards like yourself)

Do you have to be little bitch in every argument and every thread??

 

[Indus Pakistan]

Can all of you guys stop trying to claim Karachi's premier economic position to a particular ethnic group. The success of Karachi is down to geography and political landscape which existed even during the British era and which is why Karachi was rather famous even then despite having only been a fishing village when Britain began developing it.

The geographic monopoly of Karach guarantees it the entire Indus hinterland. Which means everything that 210 million people import or 200 million export will go to or come from Karachi because it is the main entry point for such a large country. This is what gives it the economic leverage.

Even with development of Gwadar geography still favours Karachi. That is exactly why people migrated to it before 1947. That is exactly why Mohajirs from far away India migrated to it post 1947. That is why people continue to migrate to it today. The model below makes this clear.

 

[AUz]

Do you have to be little bitch in every argument and every thread??

No, only to those who play victim card for no reason and are not rational about their objections.

I have never seen people from some region or city Fromm Pakistan to put their region/city first and foremost more so than the country itself to such an extreme extent----ONLY karachitees do that and bitch about every fucking thing and relate it back to Karachi.

Time for u to stfu. Nobody is conspiring against karachi. You guys made ur own city shit thanks to Mqm and ppp.

Look at Lahore-----it's fucking first world city compared to dirty, disorganized pile of shit known as Karachi. Better fix your city before bitching about conspiracy conspiracy for no reason

 

[Mav3rick]

No, only to those who play victim card for no reason and are not rational about their objections.

I have never seen people from some region or city Fromm Pakistan to put their region/city first and foremost more so than the country itself to such an extreme extent----ONLY karachitees do that and bitch about every fucking thing and relate it back to Karachi.

Time for u to stfu. Nobody is conspiring against karachi. You guys made ur own city shit thanks to Mqm and ppp.

Look at Lahore-----it's fucking first world city compared to dirty, disorganized pile of shit known as Karachi. Better fix your city before bitching about conspiracy conspiracy for no reason

First it is the Federal Government that sucks us dry and than the Sindh Government, what does the elected representatives of Karachi get to be able to serve Karachi? The Mayor cannot even hire or fire KMC staff and has to beg Sindh Government every month to release salaries. Unlike the CM of Punjab who hails from Lahore and holds Lahore near and dear, we Karachiites have been left either at the mercy of PPP or absolute neglect.

And on top of that you Punjabi's instead of listening to Karachiites genuine complaints prefer to rub it in. Karachi should have been a model city but it is a massive garbage dump with no water and hours of electric load-shedding. And yes, we elect MQM over PPP and PML any day, so why don't you all just leave us be? Oh, that is after you return a chunk of the funds, under NFC, that you take from us. Go be more concerned about your beloved disgraced PM or the wannabe who thinks he will become PM one day.