My opinion is such:
India is not completely secular. It has problems with Hindu nationalists (who are also tools for the West). We should acknowledge these problems and discuss how to get rid of them. However, some Pakistani posters use these problems as reasons to take a sanctimonious attitude towards India. This is not justified, since Pakistan is even less secular than India.
you are correct. about hindu nationalist and india not been completly secular even though its constitution states it is. As far as pakistan is concerned there are lots of threads that expose Pakistans inadequacies and we are more than happy to acknowledge and discuss them on those thread. But pakistans or others shortcomings do not mitigate and or excuse some indians insisting they are secular when they are not, I dont even know why some of them defend this claim other than the west likes to describe itself as secular and many inidans would rather associate themselves with whites not from the neighbourhood.
Its been a real eye opener on this thread that they are so much in denial