Not Shinkansen ? India plans high-speed rail project with China

[Nova2]

Wait a minute,Shinkansen is obsolete ?..May be that's why China license produced them( along with Alstom,Siemens & Bombardier train sets) ? .Even your 'indigenous HSR train sets' are based on ToT from Alstom,Hitachi and many other foreign firms.You're so ungrateful

Nothing new they hardly give any credit to foreign manufacturers from Japanese to europeans who had set up and built HSR from mid 90's in china.

 

[gslv mk3]

Look who is ranting about off-topic.The guy who goes around dragging in Pakistan and pakistan railways is complaining of Off-topic?My,my..that's certainly rich.

@Chak Bamu do you think this guy is an Indian ?

 

[AgentOrange]

You are a moron.The so called semi-hsr an reach operational speeds of 200 kmph.

Nowadays, most trains that aren't steam locomotives have a max speed of over 200 km/h. American trains like the Amtrak Acela express have a top speed of 250 km/h. Doesn't mean they run anywhere near that speed. Similarly, Indian "semi-bullet" trains are normal trains with a fancy name. You can paint a turd but underneath it all, it's still a piece of crap. With Indian trains, they don't even get that coat of paint.

 

[gslv mk3]

Nowadays, most trains that aren't steam locomotives have a max speed of over 200 km/h. American trains like the Amtrak Acela express have a top speed of 250 km/h. Doesn't mean they run anywhere near that speed. Similarly, Indian "semi-bullet" trains are normal trains with a fancy name. You can paint a turd but underneath it all, it's still a piece of crap. With Indian trains, they don't even get that coat of paint.

Are you so stupid ? The so called semi HSR is a project to upgrade existing track to 200 kmph,and run existing, capable loco hauled train sets as well as EMU/DMU types.

 

[ChineseTiger1986]

Wait a minute,Shinkansen is obsolete ?..May be that's why China license produced them( along with Alstom,Siemens & Bombardier train sets) ? .Even your 'indigenous HSR train sets' are based on ToT from Alstom,Hitachi and many other foreign firms.You're so ungrateful

Our HSR is running faster than theirs, and how can it be an inferior copy of their products?

Today, the HSR is a synonym of the Chinese product, so Japan and the rest can just go crying about that.

 

[gslv mk3]

Our HSR is running faster than theirs, and how can it be an inferior copy of their products?

so you're claiming that you didn't receive any ToT ?

Today, the HSR is a synonym of the Chinese product

nopes

 

[ChineseTiger1986]

so you're claiming that you didn't receive any ToT ?



nopes

Since we are now eating all their lunch, and let's see if they can cut off our ToT supply?

They would already do to prevent the expansion mode of China's HSR, but unfortunately China is now controlling everything, and there is nothing they can do to stop us.

 

[bolo]

As per WTO agreement we cannot ban you just like that, but we are terrified that you guys have submitted your bid and might end up winning it since it will probably be the lowest, but for this project we don't want cheap, we want quality and you are incapable of delivering that.

However, it would be great if you guys can convince your government to withdraw the bid, let Japanese do it, they will be expensive, but quality comes for a price.

Yup, you want to ride in a limousine but pay rickshaw prices. Typical indian mental thinking.

 

[gslv mk3]

Since we are now eating all their lunch, and let's see if they can cut off our ToT supply?

They would already do to prevent the expansion mode of China's HSR, but unfortunately China is now controlling everything, and there is nothing they can do to stop us.

Do you realize how ToT works ?How can they cut off ?Its not about supplying components,its about transferring designs..

 

[AgentOrange]

Are you so stupid ? The so called semi HSR is a project to upgrade existing track to 200 kmph,and run existing, capable loco hauled train sets as well as EMU/DMU types.

The reality of your "semi bullet trains" is basically a whole bunch of Indian style BS driven by a national inferiority complex.

"critics have disputed the Delhi-Agra trial, claiming the reduction in travel time due to speed is a mere three minutes, and other manoeuvrings such as shifting the train's departure point, doing away with the scheduled stop and limiting the locomotive to 10 coaches led to reduction in travel time."

Eight more routes to have semi high-speed train trials by year-end - The Times of India

 

[ChineseTiger1986]

Do you realize how ToT works ?How can they cut off ?Its not about supplying components,its about transferring designs..

Ironically, our product is still superior, so losers can just stop whining about that.

 

[bolo]

By the way, can Chinese high speed trains be equipped with 200 or so exterior roof hooks per carage before China bids for India contract ? because that is decisive.

I spoke to the engineers they say yes for indian market only. but it will cost extra like an option but Indians don't want to pay for it.

 

[bolo]

The reality of your "semi bullet trains" is basically a whole bunch of Indian style BS driven by a national inferiority complex.

"critics have disputed the Delhi-Agra trial, claiming the reduction in travel time due to speed is a mere three minutes, and other manoeuvrings such as shifting the train's departure point, doing away with the scheduled stop and limiting the locomotive to 10 coaches led to reduction in travel time."

Eight more routes to have semi high-speed train trials by year-end - The Times of India

India high speed train. What next, indian Ferrari

 

[gslv mk3]

"critics have disputed the Delhi-Agra trial, claiming the reduction in travel time due to speed is a mere three minutes, and other manoeuvrings such as shifting the train's departure point, doing away with the scheduled stop and limiting the locomotive to 10 coaches led to reduction in travel time."

You are contradicting yourself.First you claimed most modern trains have speeds around 200kmph,and do not reach anywhere close to that figure in service-due to various factors.And now you are criticizing Indian Railways for removing those factors responsible for slowing trains down?

 

[gslv mk3]

Ironically, our product is still superior, so losers can just stop whining about that.

So you lost the argument.