No one is a minority in India, says RSS

[The Great One]

Sorry, I should have said even by non-humanly possible estimates - Muslims don end up at more than 25% of the Indian population.

Thats much better.
LOL @asad71 You do realize that you are talking about killing 170 million people in 5 years. You should maybe someday visit India and see for yourself if India or rather Hindus are the evil/bigoted/demonic creatures you make us out to be. Don't try pole vaulting though.

 

[Razia Sultana]

@Razia Sultana What up

Why are you dragging me into this meaningless debate aimed to create frictions within the pluralist Indian society? RSS wants the plurality to be treated as a collective singular and to agree or disagree is the choice of every indian without any malice and prejudice. The fanatics will love this debate and will bring us down to their level if we try to get into it. Anyways, i am hated by both hindu and muslim fanatics but who cares.

 

[HariPrasad]

That is a major step in the ethnic cleansing of Muslims from India. This is totally and squarely directed at Muslims who are the largest minority. The demographic curve makes them emerge as the majority by the middle of this century. Duval and Amit Shah must scratch their heads to find a way out to save Hindutva.

BD ha reduced Hindus to 7% from 33 %. When we say that we do not discriminate than you have a problem? Should we do like BD and wipe the Minorities out?

 

[The Great One]

Why are you dragging me into this meaningless debate aimed to create frictions within the pluralist Indian society? RSS wants the plurality to be treated as a collective singular and to agree or disagree is the choice of every indian without any malice and prejudice. The fanatics will love this debate and will bring us down to their level if we try to get into it. Anyways, i am hated by both hindu and muslim fanatics but who cares.

The debate isn't aimed at dividing anybody. It's only a matter of different perceptions. But anyway, I can't answer you now, I gottta GO.

 

[nair]

^^ What kind of meaningless trolling is this? Was there any need for such a bait? Especially something so genocidal??

@Oscar @WebMaster @SpArK @nair @scorpionx

I normally keep away from such religious discussion, When you know the out come of such discussion, why bother discussing it..... There are friends who are specialized in such threads, i leave it to them to discuss this...... The post which you mentioned is also a bait..... No doubt........

 

[jaunty]

Actually it is. We've learnt to co-exist. Our personal lives are way too different imply commonality. Not that it matters. Hell 55 languages don't mean disunity, why should smaller things like religion have an impact?

There is more to culture than just religion.

 

[Guynextdoor2]

There is more to culture than just religion.

That's not what the RSS is implying right? They're saying all of this is 'Hindu Culture'

 

[jaunty]

That's not what the RSS is implying right? They're saying all of this is 'Hindu Culture'

I was commenting on your statement that people from different religions DO NOT share culture. Both the statements (that of RSS and yours) are from the two ends of the spectrum whereas the truth lies somewhere in between.

 

[scorpionx]

All these discussions are quite meaningless especially when the definition of "Hindu culture" is a bit blurry one and most of the time horribly self contradictory. So, it's wise to leave the thread for jingos.

^^ What kind of meaningless trolling is this? Was there any need for such a bait? Especially something so genocidal??

Indians on this forum have adapted themselves with regular abuse of their own, Sarthak. We have grown a very thick skin to such assaults. So, hope we should not have any problem with that comment too.

 

[SrNair]

Why Indian Hindus have so much problems with minorities?
This is understandable they have negativity towards Muslims as Muslims ruled Hindus for centuries. And always threatens to rule again.

But again they have problems with Christians, Sikhs, N Easterners. Upper cast Hindus have problems with lower casts
Again they haven't got any better relations with a single neighboring country surrounding India.

So can we come to this conclusion that it is the core problem of Hinduism.
Intolerance and Non coexistence with others, its the teaching?

So much again ,'again'.

 

[PlanetWarrior]

Hindus and muslims and christians DO NOT share the same culture. Our lives and ways of living are COMPLETELY different. They DO NOT follow a 'hindu culture'. All that we have achieved is to learn to co-exist. In public places we are civil, in private lives we are COMPLETELY different.



And you have a problem with every other relgion in the world.

No need to mention Christians in your quote. @seiko is a staunch Christian but emulates the Hindus. Hereunder is a picture of @seiko on his way to Sunday morning Church. Notice his attempts to ensure that he fits in with his neighbors. Very admirable

 

[scholseys]

Minorities should start arming themselves.

 

[arp2041]

Just like People in England are ENGLISH (even if they don't know English or not) & People in Ireland are Irish......so are the People in HINDUSTAN called HINDUS, but i simply don't know why these SICKULARS have any problems?

 

[jaunty]

Just like People in England are ENGLISH (even if they don't know English or not) & People in Ireland are Irish......so are the People in HINDUSTAN called HINDUS, but i simply don't know why these SICKULARS have any problems?

The problem is, the term "Hindu" (rightly or wrongly ) is now associated with a particular religious ideology and therefore that analogy is not applicable here.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Why are you dragging me into this meaningless debate aimed to create frictions within the pluralist Indian society? RSS wants the plurality to be treated as a collective singular and to agree or disagree is the choice of every indian without any malice and prejudice. The fanatics will love this debate and will bring us down to their level if we try to get into it. Anyways, i am hated by both hindu and muslim fanatics but who cares.

I don't hate you. In fact your first name is special