"No One can deliver under this SBP as currency spikes are too much and should have thrown dollar to control the spikes" EX FM Tarin on Dunya News.

[SD 10]

Now he is trying to pin the incompetence of PMLN government as the responsibility of SBP. Well they are more than we loved to bring new legislation to take SBP’s autonomy away

Time to walk the walk for PMLN government SOBs

thats what they have been telling the public for sometime now that making SBP independent is a mistake.....................

 

[AZ1]

@AZ1 if you by my post on defense and Sisat.pk.

PTI did a blunder by firing Hafeez Sheik as he could have been a senator if someone resigned from senate seat ,however, PTI wanted fast pace growth but it backfire like cannon due to miscalculation of budget.

1) The interest rate is till low. Should be 15% above inflation rate to reduce CAD.

2) PTI lost Fiscal discipline now need to reduce growth as i said PTI did a force growth with cars and subsidizing petrol prices and still inflation was high because of shortage and fixing the prices.

3) Put more pressure on PKR due to stubborn demand of growth and should have stopped vision of growth in Sep 2021.

4) Should have delayed IMF program in April 2021.

this is not the point, point is even you said tarin was not good yet he manage to give subsidy, increase export, gdp growth.

After tarin, this new finance minister is good for nothing? even reming subsidy which was given by tarin

 

[Desprado]

thats what they have been telling the public for sometime now that making SBP independent is a mistake.....................

now PMLN also cannot anything as main condition of IMF is that SBP will be out of government control till Sep 2023 because IMF has agreed to extend the same program till 2023 end in the condition of reforms.

this is not the point, point is even you said tarin was not good yet he manage to give subsidy, increase export, gdp growth.

After tarin, this new finance minister is good for nothing? even reming subsidy which was given by tarin

Export mainly increased due to inflation.

 

[Bilal.]

thats what they have been telling the public for sometime now that making SBP independent is a mistake.....................

Now they have the government. Reverse it. And show result that they had said they can achieve.

You can’t have your cake and eat it to.

 

[Desprado]

Now they have the government. Reverse it. And show result that they had said they can achieve.

You can’t have your cake and eat it to.

Cannot do it till Sep 2023 as they want same IMF program back.

 

[Bilal.]

thats what they have been telling the public for sometime now that making SBP independent is a mistake.....................

Now they have the government. Reverse it. And show result that they had said they can achieve

You can’t have your cake and eat it too.

Cannot do it till Sep 2023 as they want same IMF program back.

Oh so now it’s ok to take directions from IMF

 

[Desprado]

Now they have the government. Reverse it. And show result that they had said they can achieve

You can’t have your cake and eat it too.


Oh so now it’s ok to take directions from IMF

Same like other government. It simply means that Establishment will keep this government till next year because.

If Dar can pull off some loans from Qatar, KSA and UAE than we will have election this year.

 

[ziaulislam]

"No One can deliver under this SBP as currency spikes are too much and should have thrown dollar to control the spikes" EX FM Tarin.

"This SBP is totally clueless under market base currency and they need expertise in this matter as they should used dollar to stablize the market otherwise, no one can deilver under this SBP". Shaukat Tarin.

https://twitter.com/x/status/1518209106762416129

Live on Dunya News.

Reality is the only way to control dollar is to be surplus in exports..and that would take a decade

Pakistanis destroyed the economy from 2008-2018 by decreasing the exports by 25%(rathee then required tripling it) and now suddenly expect hamoon jadogar and ayank wala jin to come and triple the exports in 3 yrs(increased by 50% on pace to become 4x in 10yrs)

Pakistanis are kids..they need chatrool to understand how things wotk in real world
They deserve the chatrool they are getting over last 40 yrs

buzdar made flour cheaper and this.show baz increase the price and said look we are giving low price

medical price increase by show baz 20%View attachment 837585

View attachment 837586


and here comes the big releif from show baz on flour by increasing price. buzdar price was 375 and shahbazoo made 400 calling it crap releif

View attachment 837587

Market manipulation doesnt work
Govt needs to be regulator not a subsidy provider

Only ehasas program should be subsidize
Nothing else

 

[Bilal.]

Same like other government. It simply means that Establishment will keep this government till next year because.

If Dar can pull off some loans from Qatar, KSA and UAE than we will have election this year.

Previous government is gone. Per you and the current government they made bad economic decisions. Now reverse all those “bad decisions” and fix it.

Time to walk the walk

 

[AZ1]

now PMLN also cannot anything as main condition of IMF is that SBP will be out of government control till Sep 2023 because IMF has agreed to extend the same program till 2023 end in the condition of reforms.


Export mainly increased due to inflation.

you meant due to dollar rate. which is in pmln time same as pti. Yet providing subsidy and performance was better.

why pmln proposing to close all the projects started by pti?

https://twitter.com/x/status/1518163401352089601

What you will do with roshan digital account if it goes down ? shortage of dollars in billions.

exports
remittance
reserves

any short amount in the above three will cause pakistan.

If you dont know let me break it to you that ppl have with drawn money in big amount from roshan digital. You will see report in upcoming months.

 

[Bilal.]

you meant due to dollar rate. which is in pmln time same as pti. Yet providing subsidy.

why pmln proposing to close all the projects started by pti?

https://twitter.com/x/status/1518163401352089601

That’s the old habit of Shahbaz takhti Sharif.

If it doesn’t have his takhti on it, close the project.

 

[Desprado]

Previous government is gone. Per you and the current government they made bad economic decisions. Now reverse all those “bad decisions” and fix it.

Time to walk the walk

My take is that PTI did not had any plan. PTI kept grooming Asad Umar as the next big thing in Pakistan for about 8 years and than they could not afford to even keep for 6 months than PTI borrowed all ex PPP finance minster as PTI was too clueless and no one track Policy. However, in April 2021, Shaukat Tarin bluffed with PTI for track policy and look where PTI went and what happened.

I still remember Imran khan said i have 200 Finance team ready for Pakistan in 2018 and still he had to borrow people from opposition.

 

[Bilal.]

My take is that PTI did not had any plan. PTI kept grooming Asad Umar as the next big thing in Pakistan for about 8 years and than they could not afford to even keep for 6 months than PTI borrowed all ex PPP finance minster as PTI was too clueless and no one track Policy. However, in April 2021, Shaukat Tarin bluffed with PTI for track policy and look where PTI went and what happened.

I still remember Imran khan said i have 200 Finance team ready for Pakistan in 2018 and still he had to borrow people from opposition.

Wake up. PTI is not in government. You and PMLN said their policies were wrong. Now fix it and show the results.

Time to walk the walk

 

[Desprado]

Wake up. PTI is not in government. You and PMLN said their policies were wrong. Now fix it and show the results.

Time to walk the walk

I am still shocked that the amazing Journey of 22 years ended like horror movie show.

 

[Bilal.]

I am still shocked that the amazing Journey of 22 years ended like horror movie show.

And now the love story has started

Milk and honey flowing in Pakistan

Public is already on incompetent PMLN’s neck. I am loving the show