Neverforget84.com - Sikhs want own stat.

[haviZsultan]

Sikhs don't want a separate state. Khalistan is just a word to prove your coolness, nothing else. People say it, they post the stickers, get tattoos, but when you ask them, they don't know what it is.

I am yet to see a person who wants Khalistan, and I am a sikh myself.

Only people who want it are Pakistani Sikhs, Canadian Sikhs, and UK sikhs.

I admit that Pakistani Sikhs, Canadian Sikhs and British Sikhs are the primary supporters of the Khalistan ideal however I would not go as far to say it has absolutely no support in Indian Punjab at all. There are times when so called 'terrorists' favouring Khalistan independence are captured from parts of India.

Of course I must admit I cannot argue with a Sardar himself and say he is totally wrong about his own race. But I just don't think the Khalistan movement is a dead movement just yet. And truth is those Canadian, British and some of the Pakistani Sikhs (some moved after 1984 to Pakistan) did originally come from India so they are originally Indian and want independence for their Punjab. Just because they have taken foreign citizenship doesn't mean the issue can totally be ignored and you can call them foreigners.

For example many of us Pakistanis on PDF are living abroad (like Indians), them leaving India or Pakistan does not mean they do not exist or what they do does not matter. They can still influence local opinion. So I wouldn't go so far as to count the Khalistan movement as dead.

Till then notice how every year the Khalistan issue pops up. If its in the news, its happening baby.

Cops want trial of militant via video-link

Citing intelligence inputs that there will be attempts to free him if he is taken out, the Special Cell of Delhi Police has asked a Ludhiana court to allow court proceedings against a Khalistan Liberation Force militant through video conferencing.

Daya Singh Lahoria (50), who is currently lodged in Tihar jail, was extradited from the US in January 1997. He is to be produced before the district and sessions judge SP Bangarh in Ludhiana.

The Special Cell of Delhi Police said it has received inputs from central intelligence agencies that sympathisers of pro-Khalistan groups would try to free him while he is being taken for appearance in the Ludhiana court.

Lahoria was sentenced to life by a Jaipur court in 2004 for abducting the son of senior Congress leader Ram Niwas Mirdha. Lahoria and two others had abducted Rajendra Mirdha while he was on morning walk to put pressure on the then Narasimha Rao government for the release of KLF terrorist Devendra Pal Singh Bhullar, who is on death row, in 1994.

In 2007, the Special Cell arrested four Babbar Khalsa International militants and made Lahoria a co-accused in the case. Baljit Singh, one of the four accused, told police that he met Lahoria when he was lodged in Nabha Jail in Punjab.

“He has militancy related cases registered against him in Punjab and needs to be taken to Ludhiana court for proceedings. We have inputs that there will be efforts to attack the police convoy and set him free. He has serious charges against him so we have decided to initiate the proceedings through video conferencing,” said a senior police officer.

“He has been booked by the Special Cell for waging war against the state. He was arrested as a co-conspirator in the case. Apart from Delhi he has cases registered against him in Kolkata and Punjab,” said Vikas Padora, Lahoriya’s counsel.

Cops want trial of militant via video-link - Indian Express

 

[Peshwa]

Khalistan zindabad. Punjabis aren't the same race as the rest of Indians anyway.

It pleases me to see that the unity of our country even through diversity frustrates your lot to no end....

If only you could fathom the concept that the nation/national identity comes above race or religion...But I dont expect you to understand anyways given the concept your nation is contrived on...

 

[RazPaK]

what race are they ? Do you even know what race means ?

I know what race means. You would have to look at their tribes and individual tribe history. Jatts are mostly Central Asian.

Gujjars are also Central Asian.

 

[jackyy]

some illiterate designed map and indian sikhs dont want khalistan or any other crap.
its the dream of those who ran to canada or US.

 

[TalkToMe:D]

^^ why not report the post instead of feeding him?

 

[haviZsultan]

And therefore, Baluchistan, Karachi, Peshawar should be liberated from Pakistan...

I have never even heard of Karachi and Peshawar wanting to be liberated. You need to learn more about the geography of Pakistan and what regions actually want independence.

 

[Night_Raven]

Calmdown! why to create mess in forum, If indian members have some concerns then they should post their opinions on the provided Facebook page, You better show your regrets on that FB page it would be more benefitial ..

You want Indian members to "like" a worthless Facebook page and then post our "grievances" there to make it more "beneficial" ?



This thread reported and so will the FB page be .. thanks for the link !

 

[metro]

I have never even heard of Karachi and Peshawar wanting to be liberated. You need to learn more about the geography of Pakistan and what regions actually want independence.

Maybe u should ask this question to ure own country mate who thinks Punjabis are entirely different race and therefore should be seprated.
I think Pakistani punjab should seperate itself from Pakistan and should name itself something like Punjabistan, how about Punkistan..

 

[Gandhi G in da house]

My one of classmate is a sikh( pagri in head). He feel insult whenever he hear the word " Khalistan ".

i have had the same experience with my sikh friend here in Delhi .

when i was in school , years back our physics professor said something funny by taking the name of Khalistan to my sikh friend . It wasnt meant to be offensiv but he took so much offense to it that the next day his parents were in school and the professor was reprimanded and asked how dare he take Khalistan name and attach it to a sikh child even if jokingly.He was screwed that professor .

 

[Bobby]

I have never even heard of Karachi and Peshawar wanting to be liberated. You need to learn more about the geography of Pakistan and what regions actually want independence.

So much violence in Karachi and Peshawar proves that there is civil war going on in Pakistan.....

 

[metro]

Its the troll thread of the day-- Lets keep it light guys.

 

[RazPaK]

Wow Indians shooting flames from the backside about one comment. Relax.

 

[K-Xeroid]

some illiterate designed map and indian sikhs dont want khalistan or any other crap.
its the dream of those who ran to canada or US.

And Are you the representator of sikh? Thats the problem with people like you always try to impose their agenda on minorities.

 

[Gandhi G in da house]

I have never even heard of Karachi and Peshawar wanting to be liberated. You need to learn more about the geography of Pakistan and what regions actually want independence.

Do your compatriots think before talking about talking about Indian states and geography they , talk as if all india wants indipendence from india .

You spew out BS , you expect such BS in return .

BTW , dont the afghans particularly Pashtuns claim peshwar and that entire NWFP area ?

 

[metro]

Wow Indians shooting flames from the backside about one comment. Relax.

Are u scared ? I think u regret making that comment.