What's new

Netaji’s elder brother sought Japan help to raise ‘army of 50,000’ against British

Aepsilons

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
May 29, 2014
Messages
24,960
Reaction score
118
Country
Japan
Location
United States
netaji.gif





Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose’s elder brother Sarat Chandra Bose had allegedly planned an armed attack against the British in 1941. He also wanted to raise an army of 50,000 with the help of Japan —- aligned with Germany and a part of the Axis powers fighting the British-led Allied forces in World War II.

The plan was outlined by Sarat Chandra himself in a letter that had been written to “Mr Ohta, Chancellor of the Japanese Consulate” in Kolkata.

“We have 10,000 men ready to immediately take up arms. We can raise the number of 50,000 within a few months of getting the money and the arms we want. Please let me know when we may expect the arms we want and if you can arrange for the money we want through any other channel. This is very important and very urgent,” the letter said.

Dated September 18, 1941, the letter was intercepted by intelligence agents and is among a set of detailed correspondence between the Japanese consulate in Kolkata and the Bose family.

Another report, dated April 15, 1942, said that “even the Congress circles are satisfied that Sarat Bose had Japanese connections and that government was probably justified (in) putting him in jail”.

Dr Ashit Mukherji, the then editor of Eastern Economist, was believed by intelligence agents to be “acting as a go-between for the Japanese Consulate and the Bose family”. A report notes that the Indian National Army lacked “financial strength and it was therefore again in accordance with the instructions of Subhas Bose that they desired to make contact with the Japanese Consulate”.

The British intelligence agents also believed that Dr Kani Ganguly, a “first friend” of Netaji had contacted “with Nazis in Germany and Calcutta” and had conceived the idea of installing a “broadcasting station under the patronage of the Nazis ostensibly for the purpose of broadcasting anti-British to India.
 
.
It is indeed empowering and refreshing to know that India and Japan have had nationalistic ambitions together and nationalistic spirit that deigned to fight against European Imperialism. It is refreshing to know that the Indo-Japanese Rapport and Cooperative Paradigm is not new, but, rather, is a return to the original relations during the inter-war years. I hope that the relations between Japan and India will always be centered in this cooperative framework, and a spirit of strong interoperability, dependability, and growth-centered focus is maintained in perpetuity.

From times of peace, war, and peace again. Japani-Hindi Bhai Bhai.

:)
 
.
It is indeed empowering and refreshing to know that India and Japan have had nationalistic ambitions together and nationalistic spirit that deigned to fight against European Imperialism. It is refreshing to know that the Indo-Japanese Rapport and Cooperative Paradigm is not new, but, rather, is a return to the original relations during the inter-war years. I hope that the relations between Japan and India will always be centered in this cooperative framework, and a spirit of strong interoperability, dependability, and growth-centered focus is maintained in perpetuity.

From times of peace, war, and peace again. Japani-Hindi Bhai Bhai.

:)

Indeed, we Indians will always appreciate the help of Imperial Japan to overthrow the British
Long live the brotherhood between our 2 great nations :yahoo:
 
.
Indeed, we Indians will always appreciate the help of Imperial Japan to overthrow the British
Long live the brotherhood between our 2 great nations :yahoo:

This is why I believe that India is truly a comprehensive power and partner for Japan and for the world community at large. I raise my cup with you, my friend.
 
.
Indeed, we Indians will always appreciate the help of Imperial Japan to overthrow the British
Long live the brotherhood between our 2 great nations :yahoo:
There was no brotherhood. You only need to have a cursory google search for 'Japanese war crimes in WW2'. Heck check what they did to your own people.
War Crimes in WWII: Japanese Practised Cannibalism on Indian Soldiers
Had the Japanese succeeded in defeating the British Indian Army, your country would faced the same fait that China, South-East Asia and the Westerners caught in these countries faced. The IJA used INA as nothing more than a tool to limit British influence and would have disposed off it when they were done.
Japanese occupation of the Andaman Islands - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Mind you well, a lot more Indians fought against the Japanese than for them. The Burma campaign was one of the most incredible feats of human endurance.
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/06/22/w...ld-war-ii-mostly-forgotten-in-india.html?_r=2

fight against European Imperialism
More like conquer Asia then rape, kill and eat its peoples.
 
Last edited:
.
Indeed, we Indians will always appreciate the help of Imperial Japan to overthrow the British
Long live the brotherhood between our 2 great nations :yahoo:
Only that the Japanese did more atrocities against civilians in the islands of Andaman and Nicobar than the British did in the past 100 years! :D

Subhas Bose knew that a powerful INA was needed and he was pragmatic about it. He also knew that the IJA could not be trusted. Which was why the INA administration was supposed to be the supreme one on Indian territory. How much of that could have been implemented in reality is another matter.

Bose needed a military force and took the assistance of anyone who could. If the Japanese would have tried to impose their will on INA liberated India (a land they absolutely did not know, compared to China), they would have been packed off from the mainland pretty quickly.
 
.
Netaji was just a pawn.At most they are using each other as tools if Netaji was not a true idiot.
 
Last edited:
. . . . . .
Only that the Japanese did more atrocities against civilians in the islands of Andaman and Nicobar than the British did in the past 100 years! :D

Subhas Bose knew that a powerful INA was needed and he was pragmatic about it. He also knew that the IJA could not be trusted. Which was why the INA administration was supposed to be the supreme one on Indian territory. How much of that could have been implemented in reality is another matter.

Bose needed a military force and took the assistance of anyone who could. If the Japanese would have tried to impose their will on INA liberated India (a land they absolutely did not know, compared to China), they would have been packed off from the mainland pretty quickly.

Its ok bro. I understand some Indians resent the fact that Britain colonised them. However as you said, for them to be claiming Japan was a holy peaceful saint who just wanted to help free India and its people from oppression is more than laughable.:rofl: They must be very very naive i must say.

Do they even know the amount of attrocities/crimes carried out by Japan in the Asian countries they invaded or 'liberated'?lol . Well, seems they need to ask the Chinese,Vietnamese and koreans about that.:lol: I dont need to say more. Lol

Just because you despise one country shouldnt mean you should cover your eyes and ignore what another country did even far worse. That's something i have noticed about most PDF members. :disagree:
Anyway Japan lost the war and was nuke as a result. It did take on more than it could chew too fast, shows it was inexperienced in international diplomacy/playing the great game. In geo politics its not just about having the military might. But knowing when and how to use it.we could teach Japan one thing or two in this field but that's history anyway. :D
 
.
Anyway Japan lost the war and was nuke as a result. It did take on more than it could chew too fast, shows it was inexperienced in international diplomacy/playing the great game. In geo politics its not just about having the military might. But knowing when and how to use it.we could teach Japan one thing or two in this field but that's history anyway. :D
Since its inverted war Japanese had formed a funny tradition/habit that they always made the same strategic mistakes with different styles.:rofl:
 
Last edited:
.
There was no brotherhood. You only need to have a cursory google search for 'Japanese war crimes in WW2'. Heck check what they did to your own people.
War Crimes in WWII: Japanese Practised Cannibalism on Indian Soldiers
Had the Japanese succeeded in defeating the British Indian Army, your country would faced the same fait that China, South-East Asia and the Westerners caught in these countries faced. The IJA used INA as nothing more than a tool to limit British influence and would have disposed off it when they were done.
Japanese occupation of the Andaman Islands - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Mind you well, a lot more Indians fought against the Japanese than for them. The Burma campaign was one of the most incredible feats of human endurance.
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/06/22/w...ld-war-ii-mostly-forgotten-in-india.html?_r=2


More like conquer Asia then rape, kill and eat its peoples.

I know that the Japanese did commit some crimes against the Indians in A&N islands,but at the same time they did assists us to wage war against the British. While we should condem the Japanese for what they did in A&N,we should not forget how they helped us.Make no mistakes everyone knows that the Japanese supported us to help them fulfill their own objectives, but sadly that's his the real world works.

Only that the Japanese did more atrocities against civilians in the islands of Andaman and Nicobar than the British did in the past 100 years! :D

Subhas Bose knew that a powerful INA was needed and he was pragmatic about it. He also knew that the IJA could not be trusted. Which was why the INA administration was supposed to be the supreme one on Indian territory. How much of that could have been implemented in reality is another matter.

Bose needed a military force and took the assistance of anyone who could. If the Japanese would have tried to impose their will on INA liberated India (a land they absolutely did not know, compared to China), they would have been packed off from the mainland pretty quickly.

All the great powers in WW2 wanted to fullfill their interests,while condemning their atrocities we should thank them for helping us(even if they did it for their own purpose)
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom