Nearly 4,000 army soldiers killed in last 12 years: AK Antony

[Spring Onion]

Active war.... PA has still not entered area and started operation. They think about that after Malala incident but back off.

you are ignorant about the area and facts. PA is already there doing operation. Only air strikes have not taken place and we dont need to do that.

anyway coming back to the topic, we are doing pretty good than you who are not in a war .

 

[IND151]

you are ignorant about the area and facts. PA is already there doing operation. Only air strikes have not taken place and we dont need to do that.

anyway coming back to the topic, we are doing pretty good than you who are not in a war .

If base of you saying this is our causalities then remember our army is larger than yours and we have also brought down insurgency in J&K and NE.

 

[Windjammer]

Suicides bigger killer than death in action in central forces

New Delhi, Nov 27, 2012, (PTI) :

Suicide incidents killed more central security forces' personnel than death while in action in the last four years, Parliament was informed today.

"As reported by the central armed police forces (CAPFs) and Assam Rifles, a total of 417 CAPFs and AR personnel committed suicide/killed themselves since 2009 till date, whereas 398 personnel laid their lives in the service of the nation during this period.

"During the same period, 49,188 personnel have proceeded on voluntary retirement or resigned, which works out to be about 1.5 per cent of force strength per year," Minister of State for Home R P N Singh told Lok Sabha in a written reply.

The causative factors, the Minister said, in most of the cases were found to be generally personal and domestic problems like marital discords, personal enmity, mental illness and depression among others.

"In a few cases, the same could be owing to work related stress," he said.

Singh said personnel were proceeding on voluntary retirement and resigning from service mainly due to various personal and domestic reasons including children or family issues, health or illness of self or family, social or family obligations and commitments among others, he said.

The minister also said these personnel will also be given the status of ex-CAPF on the lines of ex-servicemen in order to boost their morale.

"Giving status of ex-CAPF personnel to retired personnel of CAPF, which is expected to boost the morale of the existing CAPFs personnel and also expected to provide better identity, community recognition and thus higher esteem and pride in the society to the ex-CAPF personnel," he said.

To another query, he said during 2012 (up to August 31) only 14 youths in Kashmir Valley reportedly joined militant groups.

"The government has adopted various counter terrorist methods to neutralise the efforts and capabilities of militants and to watch activities of those supporting such groups. The government has also encouraged policies to mainstream the youth and discourage them from joining militancy," he said.

Suicides bigger killer than death in action in central forces

 

[Spring Onion]

If base of you saying this is our causalities then remember our army is larger than yours and we have also brought down insurgency in J&K and NE.

The larger number should not be a reason for high rate of suicides. and also remember that your casualties are not due to war on terror but mostly suicides thats someting where numberes should not be a reason

 

[IND151]

The larger number should not be a reason for high rate of suicides. and also remember that your casualties are not due to war on terror but mostly suicides thats someting where numberes should not be a reason

Hard to say as data for only last three years has been given.

BTW what do you want to say about later part of my post?

 

[Spring Onion]

Hard to say as data for only last three years has been given.

BTW what do you want to say about later part of my post?

will reply to later part as i dont agree with that will give you my reasons. Thats not decrease due to your army but a slumber due to many factors.

 

[SamantK]

The immense satisfaction of Pakistanis notwithstanding they must look at figures of civilian deaths in Pakistan... The figure has crossed 40,000 in a few years.

Military deaths in last 12 years is not very high, ESP for a force which is actively fighting the Pakistani insurgents in Kashmir..

Less than 40 deaths an year considering the size of IA there is nothing to worry...

 

[Abingdonboy]

The immense satisfaction of Pakistanis notwithstanding they must look at figures of civilian deaths in Pakistan... The figure has crossed 40,000 in a few years.

Military deaths in last 12 years is not very high, ESP for a force which is actively fighting the Pakistani insurgents in Kashmir..

Less than 40 deaths an year considering the size of IA there is nothing to worry...

Don't bother mate. If any idiot want's to get worked up at 333 deaths/year for a 1.2 MILLION man army let them. They are only highlighting their own ignorance and stupidity.

 

[W.11]

Look at the success ratio. Kashmir insurgency is in total control. Even our enemies dont think that Kashmir is going anywhere except India. Khalistan moment finished. Pakistan is struggling for existence. They neither can handle Pakistan Talibaan nor US drone attacks on their citizens.

very bold statement, as usual hyper exaggerating the statements, thats all what u indians are good at

 

[Windjammer]

The immense satisfaction of Pakistanis notwithstanding they must look at figures of civilian deaths in Pakistan... The figure has crossed 40,000 in a few years.

Military deaths in last 12 years is not very high, ESP for a force which is actively fighting the Pakistani insurgents in Kashmir..

Less than 40 deaths an year considering the size of IA there is nothing to worry...

Ignorance is a bliss....recently in just in a week of clash between Israel and Palestine, some 150 people were killed, where as we have been fighting a war with an elusive enemy for a decade now. Casualties are expected in a war, more so when the enemy has no regard what so ever for the innocents. India may have been fighting low intensity home grown insurgency but as the article points out that "Suicides bigger killer than death in action", means fighting is the last reason for IA in making headlines.

 

[SamantK]

Ignorance is a bliss....recently in just in a week of clash between Israel and Palestine, some 150 people were killed, where as we have been fighting a war with an elusive enemy for a decade now. Casualties are expected in a war, more so when the enemy has no regard what so ever for the innocents. India may have been fighting low intensity home grown insurgency but as the article points out that "Suicides bigger killer than death in action", means fighting is the last reason for IA in making headlines.

Indeed it is a bliss, especially for Pakistan which has been fighting its own creations. Not India.


Home grown, yes yes, I see that you are completely ignorant..

Pakistan the victim, as always. In all the 65 years Pakistan has always been the victim, just like Palestine

 

[Amolthebest]

Since 26/11 has just passed....i will not mention any slow boat sailing right down your throat. !!

We hanged Kasab. Do you think anybody including you believes that a US marin is hanged in Pakistan for OBL operation . Neither can you avenge India for 1971 nor US for OBL operation/ drone attacks

 

[Windjammer]

We hanged Kasab. Do you think anybody including you believes that a US marin is hanged in Pakistan for OBL operation . Neither can you avenge India for 1971 nor US for OBL operation/ drone attacks

You mean, you show boated with Kasab for all these years....as for the US marines...you need to keep yourself more updated....most of them were killed when their helicopter was shot down by whoever and whatever means.....as for the rest of banter....i think the BR are doing a pretty decent job. !!

DISTURBED BORDER

OT.....some more tragic incidents have taken place within the Indian armed forces.

CRPF trooper shoots self in Ayodhya

Woman air force officer commits suicide in Jodhpur - The Times of India

 

[noksss]

You mean, you show boated with Kasab for all these years....as for the US marines...you need to keep yourself more updated....most of them were killed when their helicopter was shot down by whoever and whatever means.....as for the rest of banter....i think the BR are doing a pretty decent job. !!

DISTURBED BORDER

OT.....some more tragic incidents have taken place within the Indian armed forces.

CRPF trooper shoots self in Ayodhya

Woman air force officer commits suicide in Jodhpur - The Times of India

If Sucide rate is higher in the army steps will be taken to reduce that so how does that make your army doing better than ours
the actual comparison should be made in containing the insurgency by both the armies so where does PA stands in that