Muslim In Awadh Will Not Do Qurbani On Eid, They Will Cut A Goat Shaped Cake Instead

[VivasvatManu]

Please explain the difference. Thanks.

Varna + Jaathi = Caste

Varna was created to eliminate the differences between Jaathi. Person from any Jaathi could learn any skill to be counted as one among any Varna.

With the elimination of schooling infrastructure during the invasions, the Jaathi's were forced to teach their trade to members of their own tribe. The British later created the 'caste' to pigeonhole each jaathi into a distinct caste. Those outside their jaathi were called 'out caste'. i.e. dalits.

 

[911]

Save Cow - Superstitious Hindu (Extremist)
Sacrifice Cow - Practicing Religion (Secular)

 

[hussain0216]

@Razia Sultana are your family scared?

What did you sacrafice this Eid?

What precautions are you taking to protect yourselves?

 

[VivasvatManu]

What is that? Holi?

(eid killing) Blood + Rain water = streets of BD.

 

[el che]

Killing a living being is cruel anyway...it is hypocritical to act holier then thou when it comes to killing animals in any way...we are omnivores...we eat meat....we must kill animals to eat them...the moral scale of human civilization does not and will not depend on its treatment of cows....besides bleeding any animal out is slightly healthier.

If you do not care about the way the animal dies then no point arguing with you. It should not even bother you when ISIS halal people. Even stoning to death used to be a common practice in some muslim countries. Why was it stopped? Certain practices in Islam are barbaric. Cruelly killing an animal, circumcision of new born babies. Why only muslim terrorists kill in the name of religion and kill the innocents while not having the balls to face military? Some introspection for authenticity of religious laws is necessary for peace

 

[Gandhi G in da house]

Varna + Jaathi = Caste

Varna was created to eliminate the differences between Jaathi. Person from any Jaathi could learn any skill to be counted as one among any Varna.

With the elimination of schooling infrastructure during the invasions, the Jaathi's were forced to teach their trade to members of their own tribe. The British later created the 'caste' to pigeonhole each jaathi into a distinct caste. Those outside their jaathi were called 'out caste'. i.e. dalits.

Okay what is the origin of the concept of Jaati ?

 

[Anubis]

If you do not care about the way the animal dies then no point arguing with you. It should not even bother you when ISIS halal people. Even stoning to death used to be a common practice in some muslim countries. Why was it stopped? Certain practices in Islam are barbaric. Cruelly killing an animal, circumcision of new born babies. Why only muslim terrorists kill in the name of religion and kill the innocents while not having the balls to face military? Some introspection for authenticity of religious laws is necessary for peace

Killing people for any reason and killing animals for consumption are two completely different arguments..I personally am not absolutely sure about the moral authority of capital punishment...don't assume stuff about me that you have no idea about...either present your point or shut the **** up.

 

[Nilgiri]

Another religion thread.

I thought these kinds of topics are banned @waz @WAJsal ?

 

[Anubis]

Save Cow - Superstitious Hindu (Extremist)
Sacrifice Cow - Practicing Religion (Secular)

Impose dietary restriction on other people for your silly superstitious belief: Superstitious Hindu(Extremist)
Let people eat what they want: Secular.

 

[Nefarious]

I've got a Hindu mate here in the UK who eats all meat except beef. I'm sure there are more similar cases in India?

 

[untitled]

This is not the point. In that case you can argue "India is largest beef exporter"

OK but will it be too much to ask if I say why the double standards against Indian muslims?

The point is Muslims in south Asia sacrifices cow for just to hurt Hindu sentiments.

I am not going to defend any muslim who sacrifices a cow with the sole intention of hurting the sentiments of Hindus. But will the Hindus allow a muslim to sacrifice a cow if he wants too?

Look at the Arab world ,they sacrifices camel or goat only.

I am afraid you are badly misinformed here. The Arabs do sacrifice cows when available. A simple google search will do

And i think it hasn't wrriten in Quran also to sacrifice cow specially.

The second chapter of the Quran is called 'Baqra' which means cow in Arabic. The Quran does tell of a story where the children of Israel where ordered to slaughter a cow. But ofcourse like you said that does not make it obligatory on muslims to slaughter cows

Then why south Asia's Muslims prefers to sacrifice Cow?

No they don't. This eid I saw more goats than cows. Cows are expensive too

And this brutality started from Mugal era to hurt Hinduism, not from Muhammad Prophet. So you South Asian Muslims are following Mugal brutality ....

It appears brutality to you because you feel cows are sacred but to an ordinary muslim a slaughtered cow is just dinner. But like I said if the sole intention is to hurt the sentiments of the larger Hindu population then I will not defend it

 

[VivasvatManu]

Okay what is the origin of the concept of Jaati ?

WTF......You don't know your own jaathi ? Try "Jath'.

its your tribe. Its your clan.

 

[The BrOkEn HeArT]

Arabs sacrifice animals that are most common to their region...South Asians sacrifice animals that are more common to their region....it is your bad luck that your deity just happens to be one of the most consumed food around the world...being an ex-Muslim I can assure you Hindu sentiments are the last things Muslims have to worry about in carrying out their superstitious rituals....so to make sure every one feels better about their superstition either you pay for Camels to be brought to South Asia in ship loads for the Muslims to sacrifice....or you stop worshiping cows and move to something that people don't eat...lions or tigers maybe.

That's what other faiths gotta problem with Muslims. Muslims feels proud to hurt other faiths and when other faiths asks not to do that, Muslims starts playing victims.
And you can find Goat easily than cow in SA. This is not about regional animals anymore in SA.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

(eid killing) Blood + Rain water = streets of BD.

Ok. Do non Muslims live there? In that locality?

 

[Bitter Melon]

Arabs sacrifice animals that are most common to their region...South Asians sacrifice animals that are more common to their region....it is your bad luck that your deity just happens to be one of the most consumed food around the world...being an ex-Muslim I can assure you Hindu sentiments are the last things Muslims have to worry about in carrying out their superstitious rituals....so to make sure every one feels better about their superstition either you pay for Camels to be brought to South Asia in ship loads for the Muslims to sacrifice....or you stop worshiping cows and move to something that people don't eat...lions or tigers maybe.

Or we ban cow killing as we have done and periodically repeat an Akalah to keep people in check.